Unveiling Netflix's One Piece Reviews: The Ultimate Verdict is Finally Here!

Summary

Critics are divided on whether the faithfulness of Netflix's One Piece series to the manga is a rewarding aspect of the show.

The series features a cast that includes Iñaki Godoy as Monkey D. Luffy and Mackenyu as Roronoa Zoro.

Overall, critics find that One Piece will appeal to both fans and newcomers.

The reviews are in for Netflix's One Piece, and critics agree that the show stays true to the source material, despite differing opinions on its overall satisfaction. The series, which premiered on Netflix on August 31, is a fresh interpretation of Eiichiro Oda's long-running manga series of the same name. Starring Iñaki Godoy as Monkey D. Luffy, a determined aspiring pirate king in search of a legendary treasure, alongside Mackenyu as Roronoa Zoro, Emily Rudd as Nami, Jacob Romero Gibson as Usopp, and more. Now that the series has officially debuted on Netflix, critics are free to share their complete thoughts on One Piece season 1. While some feel it becomes tiresome, many find it an uplifting joy, with the majority agreeing that it will be enjoyable for both dedicated fans and newcomers alike. The sets, costumes, and performances garner near-universal acclaim, although most critics agree that the show's cinematography suffers somewhat due to the slightly murky look of Netflix's signature style. Here are select quotes from critics:

Ben Sockol, Screen Rant:

Overall, the One Piece live-action show is an incredibly enjoyable viewing experience for both longtime enthusiasts and newcomers. It also bodes well for the future of upcoming live-action anime adaptations planned by Netflix. If they receive the same level of dedication and enthusiasm as One Piece, they have the potential to be fantastic. However, many fans will likely agree that the most thrilling live-action anime adaptation will be One Piece's second season.

The production team has successfully recreated the vibrant settings and costumes of the anime, featuring clown pirates, shark-men, multicolored ships, and punk-esque hair dyes. Unlike many anime adaptations that shy away from such bold visuals, this adaptation embraces them. However, it feels somewhat out of place due to the series' emphasis on realism in cinematography, which often undermines the beauty of the original material. This is a common issue seen in Netflix's adaptation of "Cowboy Bebop" and is prevalent in many American blockbuster films.

Angie Han, The Hollywood Reporter:

In this whimsical setting, even the slightly imperfect aesthetics of One Piece become endearing: When Luffy's mentor Shanks (played by Peter Gadiot) sports candy-apple-red hair that resembles a wig from Party City, it only enhances the feeling that this is a large, delightful pretend world - a world crafted by a mature writer with a keen eye for consistency.

Despite its ability to transport viewers, the live-action adaptation of "One Piece" often reminds us of its awkward fit within the medium. No matter how much money is poured into it, seeing a human-sawtooth shark hybrid in an open Hawaiian shirt strolling into a restaurant will never look natural. Even the regular cast's acting style, while stiff yet exuberant, leaves a lot to be desired. Godoy's charm is evident, but his imitation of Luffy's signature pose, complete with an extended cheer and fist pump, lingers for a few beats too long, resembling a frozen image. This unsettling effect prompts a crucial question: What does this version of "One Piece" offer that the original cannot, aside from a close or distant approximation of the source material?

Barry Levitt from Slashfilm praises the live-action adaptation of One Piece for its impressive action set-pieces, especially the battle between Luffy and Buggy (played by Jeff Ward). Unlike many other live-action adaptations, this version successfully captures the spirit of the manga, and the intentionally exaggerated characteristics of the characters fit in well.

Surprisingly, their rendition of One Piece is remarkably successful. Despite covering numerous story arcs in a single season, the narrative never feels hurried or overly prolonged like Luffy's adventures. Ample time is dedicated to exploring Oda's expansive world, all the while highlighting the intricate character dynamics that bind this group together as a tight-knit family.

Every aspect of One Piece's production is exceptional: the set designs are wonderfully crafted, the costumes stay true to the manga, the fight choreography flawlessly translates comic action to 3D, and the actors demonstrate unwavering commitment. It is impossible to overstate the brilliance of Godoy's portrayal of Luffy - the casting choice feels absolutely perfect. Godoy's exuberance in the role brings the character to life with an unparalleled energy and a charming toothy grin that instantly wins over everyone he encounters. Unfortunately, all of this brilliance is overshadowed by the Netflix house style, which dulls the vibrant colors and places the performances at a distance that fails to truly showcase their greatness.

Alan Sepinwall, Rolling Stone:

The deeper we get into the season, and the more we learn about each member of the crew, the more One Piece drags.

Unfortunately, rather than fully embracing this retelling, One Piece frequently veers back into familiar territory and indulges in fan service, which ultimately detracts from the overall experience. It is disappointing because the other elements, such as the impressive visual and practical effects, exciting action sequences, and lovable cast, all work harmoniously. While this live-action adaptation commendably captures the essence of One Piece, its condensed portrayal of the storyline leaves little, if any, emotional depth.

"One Piece" is an incredibly dynamic show, encompassing various genres that may lead to a somewhat jarring experience. The combination of slapstick comedy and slasher horror creates tonal whiplash. However, the show manages to strike a fine balance, avoiding excessive over-the-top action. Additionally, the storytelling is generally well-paced.

Will One Piece Strike Gold On Netflix?

The success of One Piece holds significant importance as it comes after Netflix's failed endeavor to adapt the beloved anime Cowboy Bebop into a live-action series. The live-action adaptation of Cowboy Bebop received a tepid response from viewers and was discontinued just three weeks following the premiere of its first season in November 2021.

The newer series of One Piece is off to a strong start, indicated by positive reviews and high scores on Rotten Tomatoes. Currently, it has earned 78 percent from critics and 95 percent from audiences. The future looks promising for One Piece, as it has the potential to attract a large viewership and continue for a long time. With the original manga running since 1997 and the anime adaptation since 1999, there is plenty of source material to draw from. Although it may not run as long as the manga or anime, the live-action show could become one of Netflix's successful and influential series.

One Piece Manga - Anime One Piece is an incredible adventure-filled series that has captivated its fans for over two decades. It follows the journey of Monkey D. Luffy and his pirate crew, the Straw Hat Pirates, as they search for the ultimate treasure, the One Piece, in order to become the King of the Pirates. With its compelling storyline, diverse and lovable characters, epic battles, and themes of friendship and determination, One Piece has created a vast and immersive world that keeps fans eagerly anticipating each new chapter or episode. It is a timeless masterpiece that continues to redefine the boundaries of the shonen genre, making it a must-watch or read for any anime or manga enthusiast.