The Mandalorian-Era TV Show Cancellation Poses a Major Obstacle for Star Wars

Article Overview

Star Wars has struggled to successfully implement concepts from the canceled Rangers of the New Republic, often detracting from the main plot and holding the franchise back.

The New Republic subplot in Ahsoka was the weakest part of the show, but there is room for improvement in future stories with better writing and planning. Effective execution of the New Republic arc could successfully connect it to the First Order in the sequel trilogy, ultimately elevating the Mandalorian era as a whole.

During development, one of The Mandalorian's spinoff shows was canceled, causing Star Wars to face challenges in successfully implementing the concept. This particular storyline had the potential to contribute to The Mandalorian and other Star Wars TV shows, but unfortunately, its execution has been disappointing and often detracts from the main plot. If Star Wars does not address and resolve this issue in future movies and TV shows, it will hinder the franchise's ability to reach its full potential.

Nevertheless, despite its flaws, certain aspects of this arc have shown promise and could have been improved with better writing. Dave Filoni's upcoming Star Wars movie, based on The Mandalorian, offers an opportunity to properly incorporate these ideas. With the replacement of The Mandalorian's canceled spinoff, the overarching narrative of this era will be brought to a satisfying conclusion.

Your browser does not support the video tag.

Star Wars Is Still Using Plot Elements From Rangers Of The New Republic

Despite the cancellation of Star Wars: Rangers of the New Republic, its intended narrative has found its way into other Star Wars TV shows. Initially introduced in The Mandalorian season 2, the storyline of Rangers of the New Republic would have revolved around Captain Carson Teva and his fellow X-Wing pilots as they combated lawlessness in the outer rim and investigated the growing Imperial threat. This story arc has continued in The Mandalorian season 3, with dedicated episodes exploring corruption within the New Republic and Teva's endeavors to confront the Imperial Remnant. While these components seamlessly contribute to the main plot, the same cannot be said for Ahsoka's involvement.

Ahsoka's New Republic Scenes Were The Show's Greatest Weakness

Unfortunately, the New Republic subplot is crucial to Ahsoka. However, these scenes were the weakest element of the show. It becomes tiresome to witness Hera Syndulla and Senator Hamato Xiono repetitively engage in the same argument, while the remaining senators concur with Xiono. The portrayal of Genevieve O'Reilly as Mon Mothma offers her limited significance, aside from appearing upset and failing to stand up for her allies, which ultimately presents her as a weak and ineffective leader. This is particularly disappointing considering O'Reilly's exceptional performance in Andor season 1, where she transformed Mon Mothma into one of the finest Star Wars characters.

Regrettably, the New Republic scenes ultimately hold no influence on the plot and divert the focus away from Ahsoka Tano, the titular character of the show. Mon Mothma and the New Republic senators do not aid Ahsoka, and although Hera convinces Teva and a few others to pursue Thrawn, their mission results in the death of several X-Wing pilots. While they did manage to save Ahsoka's life, they return without any evidence to support their claims, and Hera faces no repercussions for her actions. Consequently, the characters find themselves in the same predicament at the end of Ahsoka season 1 as they did at the beginning — aware of Thrawn's impending arrival but ill-prepared to confront him.

How Can Star Wars Fix Its New Republic Arc?

Fortunately, Star Wars has the opportunity to improve its New Republic storyline in either Ahsoka season 2 or the Heir to the Empire film. While the concept of the New Republic scenes in Ahsoka was not lacking, their execution fell short and contributed very little to the main narrative, merely setting the stage for Dave Filoni's Star Wars movie. With superior writing and careful planning, the New Republic arc has the potential to be extraordinary in future narratives, now that the groundwork has been laid. The characters will boldly confront Thrawn as he launches his assault on the galaxy, generating tension and more captivating conflicts among the New Republic senators and military leaders.

By doing so, the New Republic arc will fulfill its purpose and connect with the events of the Star Wars sequel trilogy, specifically the emergence of the First Order. As revealed in the Star Wars books, the New Republic's reluctance to take action drove Leia to establish the Resistance, particularly when she became aware of First Order infiltrators within the New Republic. This mirrors how The Mandalorian and Ahsoka have portrayed the Imperial Remnant. After Thrawn's defeat, the story can neatly align the final elements for the sequels. Although Rangers of the New Republic's impact on Star Wars has yielded mixed results, it can be rectified and enrich the era of the Mandalorian.

Editor's P/S

As a hard fan of Star Wars, I am deeply invested in the franchise and have closely followed the development of the Mandalorian-era TV shows. The cancellation of Rangers of the New Republic was a significant disappointment, as it had the potential to greatly enhance the Mandalorian era and explore important aspects of the Star Wars galaxy, such as the formation of the New Republic and the lingering threat of the Imperial Remnant.

The New Republic subplot in Ahsoka was, in my opinion, the weakest part of the show. It felt disjointed from the main story and detracted from the character development of Ahsoka Tano. The repetitive arguments between Hera Syndulla and Senator Hamato Xiono became tiresome, and the portrayal of Mon Mothma as a weak and ineffective leader was disappointing, especially after her strong performance in Andor season 1.