Rumored Romantic Connections: Amy Robach and TJ Holmes Amidst Reports of Exes Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig Moving On

Monica Schipper/Getty Images

Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes are seemingly paying no mind to their haters — or their exes — following the launch of their tell-all podcast.

Robach, aged 50, re-shared a photo originally posted by Holmes, who is 46, on Wednesday, December 6, on her Instagram Story. The photo featured the couple cuddled up together, with Holmes lying closest to the camera in a slightly unbuttoned white shirt, while Robach lounged behind him with her hand on his chest. The caption read "Thank you all ️."

The upload was accompanied by a song from Fred Hammond & Radical for Christ, and the screen displayed lyrics that seemed to convey a powerful message: "No weapon formed against me shall prosper."

Holmes and Robach were first linked in November 2022 while still married to Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue, respectively. Photos of Holmes and Robach being affectionate outside of the office emerged late last year. The GMA3 cohosts were quickly removed from the ABC morning show after their affair was discovered, and in January, we reported that Holmes and Robach were no longer with the network. ABC officially terminated the couple that same month.

Courtesy of Amy Robach/Instagram

Amid the ongoing relationship turmoil, both Holmes and Robach initiated divorce proceedings with their respective partners. The news presenters had kept their romance largely private until they decided to air their perspectives on their podcast, “Amy & T.J.,” which was first aired on Tuesday, December 5.

“I had removed my ring in early August, and it was evident to those close to me that I was going through a divorce,” Holmes stated. “T.J. is a private person and chose to keep the divorce to himself, but it was difficult because it was not known to anyone outside of a very small circle.”

Holmes claimed that the photos showing his relationship with Robach were taken at the apartment he moved into after separating from Fiebig. He admitted that as of November 2022, he hadn't even told his mother about his divorce. "I had been living by myself since last summer," he said. "So the picture that they claim shows cheating actually confirms that I was out of my marriage, as it shows me coming out of a building where I no longer lived with my ex-wife."

However, sharing their rendition of the story did little to prevent further drama from escalating. Several sources revealed on Tuesday that Fiebig and Shue are now in a relationship following the cheating scandal involving their ex-partners.

Jason Mendez/Getty Images; Courtesy of Marilee Fiebig/Instagram

One day before the news broke about Fiebig's connection with Shue, it was confirmed that Fiebig had cut ties with Holmes and Robach by unfollowing them on Instagram. As the news spread, eagle-eyed fans revisited the past social media interactions between Fiebig and Shue.

Deal of the Day

1 Day Only! Save 50% on This Next-Level Cold-Sculpting Body Treatment Duo

Check out the offer.

Previously, Shue had cleared all mentions of Robach from his Instagram profile. However, his son Nate posted a heartwarming family picture in January, showing brothers Aidan and Wyatt sitting next to Shue on a couch. Fiebig liked the photo at that time.

In December 2016, Fiebig posted a selfie with Shue on Instagram, which was highly praised by Robach in the comments section. "️this!" Robach wrote, as Fiebig showed off her extended "GMA family."