Dave Filoni Sparks Controversy by Asserting That Anyone Can Become a Jedi
Dave Filoni stirs debate by asserting that Jedi training is accessible to all in the Star Wars universe, causing a division among fans
Dave Filoni, the showrunner for Ahsoka, has stirred up controversy with his suggestion that anyone in the Star Wars universe has the potential to become a Jedi. This challenges the long-established Star Wars canon, which has traditionally depicted the Jedi Knights' connection to the Force as a rare and mystical gift.
In the same vein, this aligns with Sabine Wren's (Natasha Liu Bordizzo) path to becoming a Jedi in Dave Filoni's Disney+ series, Ahsoka. The series depicts Sabine's ability to overcome her natural lack of Force sensitivity through her dedicated training with Ahsoka (Rosario Dawson), emphasizing the idea that hard work surpasses innate talent in the expansive galaxy.
Dave Filoni divides Star Wars fans by saying anyone can be a Jedi
Filoni essentially confirmed this to be the case in a recent episode of Entertainment Weekly’s Dagobah Dispatch podcast.
Filoni pointed out that Sabine's unlocking of her Jedi potential was supported by existing Star Wars continuity. "If you pay attention to the films... you understand that the Force is an energy field created by all living things," he explained. "But... it takes time and commitment [to become a Jedi]."
Some Star Wars fans disagree with Filoni's interpretation of the series' lore. One user argued, "The Force doesn’t work that way, Dave. It takes good genetics and training for one to harness it." Another user questioned, "If what Filoni is saying is true, then why didn’t the Empire or the Rebellion teach and train their armies to wield the Force?"
Filoni's approach to opening the doors to Jedi recruitment had its own supporters. One proponent of the showrunner's stance expressed that "Every single living being is a part of and in tune with the Force, but some have a natural talent greater than others, and those children are chosen by the Jedi." Supporters also cited an old interview where Star Wars creator George Lucas declared that "everybody" could potentially use the Force, further defending Filoni.
Lucasfilm appoints Dave Filoni as Chief Creative Officer
Whether you embrace it or oppose it, followers must adapt to Filoni’s interpretation of who qualifies for Jedi Knighthood. With Lucasfilm naming him as its Chief Creative Officer, his perspective will determine the direction of all future Star Wars content.
For all the newest Star Wars content, you can find comprehensive coverage on Dexerto.
Editor's P/S
As a hard fan of Star Wars, I have mixed feelings about Dave Filoni's assertion that anyone can become a Jedi. On the one hand, I appreciate the idea that the Force is accessible to everyone and that anyone can achieve greatness with enough hard work and dedication. This is a very inspiring message, and it's one that I think is important for kids to hear.
On the other hand, I'm concerned that this assertion undermines the significance of the Jedi Order and the training that they undergo. The Jedi are supposed to be a special group of individuals who are gifted with the Force and who have dedicated their lives to its study and practice. If anyone can become a Jedi, then what's the point of the Jedi Order?
Overall, I think Filoni's assertion is a positive one, but I hope that he doesn't take it too far. The Jedi Order should remain a special and elite group, and not just anyone should be able to join.
