Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig's Love Is Authentic: They Are Thriving Together (Exclusive)

Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig have found happiness together as they move forward from previous relationships with Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, a source exclusively reveals in the latest issue of We. The insider adds that their budding romance is not just a rebound, but that their feelings for each other are genuine.

Shue and Fiebig had known each other from going on double dates while they were still married to Robach and Holmes. According to an insider, they always got along. The group made headlines in November 2022 when Robach and Holmes, who were then cohosts on GMA3, were seen getting close outside of the office. Following the scandal, Holmes and Robach were taken off the air and ABC announced their departures in January.

Holmes filed for divorce from Fiebig, with whom he shares 10-year-old daughter Sabine, in December 2022. Nearly one year later, Us confirmed in October that the former couple reached a settlement. Robach and Shue, meanwhile, were declared legally single earlier this year. (Both Robach and Shue welcomed children with their first spouses before tying the knot in 2010.)

Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig at the ADAPT Leadership Awards, photo by Mike Coppola/Getty Images; Courtesy of Marilee Fiebig/Instagram.

After leaving GMA3, Robach and Holmes collaborated on a new project while sharing their romance with fans. The debut episode of their "Amy & T.J." podcast was released on December 5, where they revealed that they were both single when they began dating. They kept their relationship secret at the time, not informing anyone at ABC or their families.

Robach admitted that she is still apologizing to her daughters and that the difficult journey continues. She revealed that they are all seeking therapy.

The news of Shue and Fiebig’s relationship came out shortly after their ex-partners shared their perspectives on the affair. Despite feeling hurt by the way her marriage to Holmes ended, an insider revealed that Fiebig is ready to move on from the past.

Sara Jaye/Getty Images for ABA

According to the source, she is ready to release the anger and move forward as she believes she has found a genuine connection with Andrew, who shares the same sentiment.

Deal of the Day

Score Serious Savings on This Makeup Remover and Lash Conditioner Duo

View Deal

The news of the relationship surprised fans, but another source tells Us that Holmes and Robach have known about their exes' connection for a few months. "They were taken aback, but they didn't consider it to be significant or worthy of much attention," the second source says. They also mentioned that Holmes and Robach were "irritated" by the timing of the relationship being made public. "It felt deliberate...and quite immature."

To learn more about Shue and Fiebig's developing romance, check out the video above and grab the latest issue of We, available now.