Report: Andrew Shue, Amy Robach's Ex-Husband, Allegedly Dating Marilee Fiebig, TJ Holmes' Ex-Wife
Amy Robach’s ex-husband Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig, former spouse of TJ Holmes, have reportedly found love together, sparking a fascinating connection between the former ‘GMA3’ coanchors' former partners
The scandalous romance between former GMA3 coanchors Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes first made headlines over a year ago. Now, their ex-spouses have moved on... with each other.
Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig are reportedly dating, with sources stating that the bond between them was formed over their shared pain from Robach and Holmes' affair. It was first reported by Page Six, with Robach still being married to Shue when photos of her and Holmes were widely circulated in November 2022. Their divorce was later finalized in March.
Holmes quickly filed for divorce from Fiebig after news of his relationship with Robach came out. They were able to settle their divorce in October and share a 10-year-old daughter. Fiebig has also unfollowed both Holmes and Robach on social media, indicating a further distancing in their relationship.
Fiebig's attorney Stephanie Lehman expressed frustration with Robach and Holmes' relationship in a statement to Us in January, stating, "We continue to be disappointed by T.J's lack of discretion, respect and sensitivity toward Marilee and the party's daughter." Despite the scandal fallout, ABC pulled them from the air in January and the couple insisted on their "Amy and T.J." podcast that they were not unfaithful to their former partners.
"We were mistakenly thought to be revealed as cheating on our spouses when in fact we were just being recognized as being in a relationship. At the time the photos were taken and the article was released, we were both in the process of getting divorced," Holmes explained during the episode on Tuesday, December 5.
Robach added that Shue had moved out of their home three months earlier. "We were already in the middle of divorces, with attorneys and mediators involved. We believed we were protecting our children and families, assuming we had privacy and time, which in hindsight may have been naive."
Robach and Holmes denied infidelity but did not disclose their relationship to ABC or their families, leaving their employer and loved ones to learn about it along with the rest of the world.
Holmes expressed concern about telling his 10-year-old daughter, Sabine, about his new relationship with Robach, as he had been trying to help her adjust to her parents' separation for the past few months. He did not want to spring the news on her abruptly.
Deal of the Day
Serious Skincare’s Wildly Popular Glycolic Acid Cleanser Is on Sale Today
View Deal
Robach expressed that she continues to apologize to her daughters Ava, 21, and Annie, 17, who she co-parents with her ex-husband Tim McIntosh.
"This is their family and they are still young, lacking the experience and tools to fully understand," she explained. "It's been a tough journey and we are all seeking help through therapy."
