Why Wayward Sisters Would Be A Better Path Forward For Supernatural Than Season 16

The Legacy of Supernatural

Supernatural, one of the best fantasy shows on The CW, captivated audiences with its thrilling 15-season run and 327 episodes. Since its premiere in 2005, the series followed the remarkable journey of Sam and Dean Winchester as they battled demons and saved the world multiple times. With an impressive fan base, the show's conclusion in 2020 sparked discussions about potential future projects.

A blended image featuring the 5 Supernatural spinoff characters for Wayward Sisters: Jody Mills (Kim Rhodes), Donna (Briana Buckmaster), Claire (Kathryn Newton), Alex (Katherine Ramdeen), Kaia (Yadira Guevara-Prip), and Patience (Clark Backo)​​​​​​​ 

After the end of Supernatural, The CW attempted to keep the franchise alive with a prequel titled The Winchesters, focusing on the parents of Sam and Dean. Despite the involvement of Jensen Ackles and efforts to capitalize on the original series, The Winchesters did not achieve the same level of popularity and was ultimately canceled. However, speculation about a new Supernatural project continues to circulate, indicating the enduring interest in the franchise's universe.

The cast of Supernatural's

The Case for Wayward Sisters

The CW's canceled spinoff, Wayward Sisters, offers a promising alternative to Season 16 of Supernatural. Unlike previous failed spinoff attempts, Wayward Sisters showcased potential by featuring popular characters from the original series, such as Jody Mills, Donna, Claire, Alex, Kaia, and Patience. Additionally, it provided opportunities for cameo appearances by familiar Supernatural characters, adding a sense of continuity to the franchise.

Kim Rhodes as Sheriff Jody Mills and Kathryn Newton as Claire Novak in Supernatural's "Wayward Sisters"

Despite the initial setback of not being picked up for a full season, the concept of Wayward Sisters aligns closely with the original show's universe while offering a fresh and unique perspective. With the passage of over three years since the conclusion of Supernatural, the introduction of new characters and storylines can thrive without competing with the established chemistry of the original cast. This spinoff holds the potential to reignite the passion of Supernatural fans and attract new audiences.

Kim Rhodes as Jody Mills and Kathryn Newton as Claire Novak in Supernatural Wayward Sisters

A New Direction for Supernatural

The prospect of Season 16 for Supernatural presents challenges in finding a compelling narrative following the definitive conclusion of the series. Undoing the impactful ending of Sam and Dean's journey risks falling into clichés and overdone tropes, potentially undermining the legacy of the original show. In contrast, Wayward Sisters offers an opportunity to explore untold stories, particularly those of female characters like Donna and Jody Mills, who have already demonstrated remarkable chemistry and potential in their interactions with the Winchester brothers.

Kim Rhodes as Sheriff Jody Mills standing next to a woman holding coffee in Supernatural's "Wayward Sisters"

Furthermore, the shift towards a female-led narrative represents a refreshing departure from the predominantly male-focused storytelling of Supernatural. Wayward Sisters represents a logical step in diversifying the franchise's storytelling and appealing to a broader audience. By embracing new perspectives and characters, the spinoff holds the potential to breathe new life into the Supernatural universe and continue its legacy in a meaningful and compelling manner.

Katherine Ramdeen as Alex Jones, Briana Buckmaster as Donna Hanscum, and Kathryn Newton as Claire Novak in Supernatural's "Wayward Sisters"