Throughout fifteen seasons of Supernatural, the Winchester brothers, Sam and Dean, experienced numerous fleeting romances. However, their love lives were consistently hindered by their interconnected lives and strong sibling bond. Supernatural, a paranormal mystery series, chronicles the brothers' pursuit of demons as part of their family profession. Throughout their journey, they bravely battled countless monsters and continually risked their lives to protect the world.
While the main storyline of Supernatural primarily revolved around the apocalypse and the brothers' ongoing conflicts with formidable villains, there were various subplot occasions where Sam and Dean found themselves entangled in love, albeit temporary in nature. In most cases, Sam and Dean never truly found genuine and reciprocated love. Sam initially embarked on his journey with Jess, a woman who, despite not knowing about his tumultuous past, seemed to comprehend him on a profound level. Conversely, Dean tended to embrace his solitary nature, consistently engaging in flings with different women. In summary, Sam and Dean's romantic entanglements in Supernatural were myriad, encompassing both human and supernatural encounters. Nevertheless, there exists a justification for why none of these relationships endured.
Sam & Dean's Best Supernatural Relationships Came When The Other Brother Died
Regrettably, Sam and Dean's most successful romantic relationships in Supernatural only seem to manifest when one of them is absent. Towards the conclusion of the series, Sam moves forward with his life and finds lasting love, even settling down and starting a family following Dean's demise. It is during this period of freedom from their hunting missions that Sam finds the opportunity to truly fall in love. A similar situation arises in season 6 when Dean, believing Sam to be dead and trapped in Lucifer's Cage, seeks solace with Lisa and her son Ben. Though Sam eventually returns, it is intriguing to note that Dean's initial response to his brother's death is to seek comfort in Lisa.
This pattern persists even when the brothers are physically separated. In the beginning of the series, Sam becomes estranged from Dean and their father as he pursues a college education, during which time he enters into a relationship with Jess. The subsequent relationships that develop within the Supernatural universe are often short-lived, fueled by intense passion rather than genuine emotional connection. As the Winchesters progress, they find themselves prioritizing their bond and common objectives, leaving little room for their romantic partners. Hence, the brothers inadvertently hinder each other's romantic pursuits throughout the series.
Sam & Dean's Family Bond Left No Room For Romantic Relationships
Sam and Dean's exclusive ability to form deep romantic connections with each other stems from the overwhelming strength of their brotherly bond. Supernatural consistently emphasizes the importance of family, and while the Winchesters do welcome individuals like Castiel or Jack into their inner circle, introducing a romantic relationship into this dynamic would disrupt the delicate balance. Aware that their unwavering protection of one another must take precedence, Sam and Dean understand that any romantic involvement would have detrimental consequences.
The show adhered closely to this principle by ensuring that romantic partners never became too close to the Winchesters. While they could establish bonds and share tender moments, ultimately, the brothers would either have to part ways or face a transformation in dynamics, thereby making a love interest an adversary. Through this approach, the Winchesters experienced only fleeting distractions before reuniting with even greater unity and strength. Although one could argue that this hindered their individual growth, it undeniably fortified their ability to face challenges together.
Supernatural Would Have Killed Any Serious Winchester Love Interest Anyway
Even if Sam or Dean attempted to introduce a romantic partner into their lives, the show made it clear that none of these relationships would last. Supernatural has gained a reputation for eliminating every single character, including Sam and Dean, so it's safe to assume that any love interest would quickly meet their demise, becoming nothing more than a source of emotional hardship for the brothers. While the deaths of allies like Kevin and Charlie were already painful, losing a lover would have added another layer of anguish.
Though it's disheartening that the Winchesters never experienced enduring, genuine love on-screen, it is likely for the best. Supernatural provided ample drama without incorporating romantic entanglements, and if anything, the lack of romance solidified the deep familial bond between Sam and Dean. However, it's worth noting that the show didn't completely disregard romantic elements, and some of the most captivating storylines involved the Winchesters encountering strong-willed, demonic women whom they had to either release, protect, or eliminate.