Uncovering the Truth Behind Shanks' Twin: A One Piece Fan Theory Analysis

One Piece has garnered a massive following as both a manga and anime series, with fans eagerly anticipating new releases. Despite the common trend of shonen franchises losing their edge as they become longer, One Piece defies this expectation and only continues to improve with time. Credit for this success goes to Eiichiro Oda, the creator of One Piece, who masterfully weaves intriguing mysteries and secrets into his storytelling, keeping readers thoroughly engaged. While these mysteries inspire some of the best fan theories, not all theories are created equal. One such example is the 'Shanks' Twin' theory, which has gained traction on platforms like Reddit following the release of chapter 1083 of the manga.

The Theory

After the release of chapter 1083 of the One Piece manga, fans have come up with a new theory regarding the character of Red-Haired Shanks. In this theory, it is speculated that Shanks has an evil twin brother who belongs to a family of celestial dragons. According to the theory, Shanks and his twin were both found by Gol D. Roger at God Valley, but while Shanks became a pirate, his twin remained at Marie Joise and joined the group of special warriors known as the Holy Knights or God Knights. This theory is supported by the fact that Shanks' scar was not drawn during his meeting with the Gorosei.

Does the Theory Make Any Sense?

Believers of a fan theory that suggests Shanks has an evil twin may have jumped the gun, as the theory lacks plausibility and concrete evidence. For instance, if Shanks is aligned with the world government and the celestial dragons, why would he steal the Gomu Gomu no Mi from a world government ship? Additionally, while some fans speculate that Shanks has an evil twin due to a scar on his left face, the only image readers have seen of him meeting the Gorosei shows only the right side of his face. It's also important to note that silhouettes in One Piece can be misleading, as seen with the Seven Warlords of the Sea. Therefore, the silhouette resembling Shanks may just be a playful tease from the author.

Therefore, it is unlikely that the Shanks' Twin theory will be confirmed in the future of One Piece. This theory is simply a way for fans to try to understand Eiichiro Oda's secretive yet revealing storytelling style. Oda's unique approach is the only way for readers to understand why he chose to depict a member of the Holy or God Knights with a resemblance to the popular character, Yonko Red-haired Shanks. Fans must patiently wait for Oda to unveil the truth about Shanks.