Top 8 Crew Members Who Should Return to Below Deck Med Season 9

A New Cast of Familiar Faces

The crew of Below Deck Mediterranean season 8 introduced some captivating personalities who would be a perfect fit for the upcoming season 9. The Bravo show, captained by the indomitable Captain Sandy Yawn, has consistently delighted viewers since its debut in 2016. However, season 8 brought about significant changes, featuring a predominantly new cast and a plethora of unexpected escapades. Below Deck Med season 8 graced the screens in September 2023, with the return of several familiar faces. Notably, the two crew members who made a comeback were Kyle Viljoen and Natalya Scudder from Below Deck Med season 7.

Montage Of Brooke Boney Below Deck Mediterranean

While Captain Sandy made her much-anticipated return for her seventh season, the revival of these crew members was not the only reunion. Tumi Mhlongo and Luka Brunton also made a comeback to the delight of Below Deck fans. Tumi, known from her stint in Below Deck Down Under season 1 as the second stew, and Luka, a late addition deckhand from Below Deck Down Under season 2, added their own unique flair to the season.

Montage of Below Deck Med's Haleigh Gorman

Brooke Boney: A Temp Stew with Untapped Potential

One standout from season 9 who deserves a second chance is Brooke Boney, the former temporary stewardess. While temporary crew members are a rarity on Below Deck, Brooke's presence was necessitated after Kyle and Tumi encountered customs delays ahead of the first charter. Despite her brief tenure of only two episodes, Brooke displayed untapped potential that was left unexplored due to her premature exit. Her compelling family background and intriguing persona made her a natural fit for the series, and her return in season 9 would undoubtedly be a welcome addition.

Lily Davison Below Deck Mediterranean Looking At Camera

Haleigh Gorman: A Deckhand with a Unique Persona

Much like Brooke, Haleigh Gorman's limited screen time in season 8 hardly did justice to her potential. Armed with over a decade of experience as a deckhand, Haleigh's quick wit and humor were overshadowed by her minimal involvement in the main storyline. Her charismatic persona has the potential to inject new life into the series if Bravo decides to cast her for the upcoming season.

Montage Of Lara Du Preez Below Deck Mediterranean

Lily Davison: A Latecomer with Unseen Potential

Lily Davison, despite joining the crew in the latter part of the season, exhibited a natural aptitude for her role. Her belated introduction limited the opportunity to fully showcase her personality. A return in season 9 would provide the perfect platform for Lily to share her captivating story and surprise viewers with her chemistry with the rest of the cast.

Below Deck Mediterranean Max Salvador smiled during confessional scene as new deckhand

Lara Du Preez: The Standout Performer

Lara Du Preez's exceptional work ethic and infectious sense of humor made her a standout in season 8. Her adeptness at her job and her dynamic background set her apart from her peers. With her seamless blend of entertainment and professionalism, Lara's presence in season 9 would be a valuable asset to the crew.

Montage Of Captain Sandy Yawn Below Deck

Max Salvador: The Unconventional Frenchman

Max Salvador, with his unconventional approach and humorous antics, added a unique flavor to season 8. His comedic relief and enigmatic persona made for compelling viewing, despite his occasional missteps. Despite his quirks, Max's presence in the upcoming season promises to infuse the crew with a mix of entertainment and intrigue.

Captain Sandy Yawn with raised fists, with four Below Deck Med stars including Tumi and Kyle

Captain Sandy Yawn: The Unwavering Captain

Captain Sandy Yawn has been the unwavering backbone of Below Deck Mediterranean for the past seven seasons. Her resilience and leadership have been instrumental in captivating audiences, making her an irreplaceable fixture on the show. Her remarkable recovery from a significant arm injury in season 8 only solidified her status as the heart and soul of the series.

Below Deck Med Captain Sandy Yawn wearing an olive puffy jacket and smiling gleefully for the camera

Kyle Viljoen: A Controversial Figure with Room for Redemption

Kyle Viljoen's tumultuous journey in the series has been marked by both adoration and disdain from fans. While initially admired for his confidence and pivotal role in the drama, his descent into toxic behavior tarnished his image. Despite his flaws, Kyle's potential for redemption and personal growth makes him a compelling candidate for a return in season 9.

Captain Sandy Yawn and Max Salvador from Below Deck Mediterranean Season 8 during private interviews

Natalya Scudder: A Potent Force of Drama

Natalya Scudder's bold personality and penchant for stirring up drama made her a captivating presence on the show. Her departure in season 8 amidst a tumultuous work environment left her story unresolved. A return in season 9 would provide an opportunity for Natalya to conclude her journey on a more fulfilling note, captivating viewers with her fiery exchanges and entertaining responses.

Captain Sandy Yawn from Below Deck Mediterranean in a light blue top smiling

Luka Brunton: A Chance at Redemption

Luka Brunton's rocky journey in Below Deck Med season 8 showcased both his highs and lows. After a promising start in Below Deck Down Under season 2, Luka's struggles in season 8 presented a new side to his character. A chance at redemption in season 9 as a bosun presents an opportunity for Luka to reclaim his position and showcase his growth as a crew member.

Below Deck's João Franco, Kyle Viljoen and Luke Jones, with neon X behind Kyle

Tumi Mhlongo: A Journey of Growth

Tumi Mhlongo's initial challenges in season 8 served as a learning curve, paving the way for her growth as the chief stew. Her resilience and ability to learn from her mistakes make her a compelling candidate for a return in season 9. With the potential for a fresh start, Tumi's presence in the upcoming season promises to showcase her evolution as a valued co-worker.

Montage of Below Deck Med’s Kyle Viljoen and Natalya Scudder