Unbelievable Reality TV Tragedies: The Most Heartbreaking and Shocking Deaths

Reality stars have a unique connection with their fans, who come to see them as genuine individuals rather than mere characters. Therefore, bidding farewell to these beloved celebrities is especially challenging. Sadly, in recent times, we have witnessed the sudden and tragic deaths of stars from popular shows such as The Deadliest Catch, The Real World, Survivor, The Real Housewives, Buckwild, and The Bachelorette.

The production of the show can be greatly affected in certain situations. For instance, in April 2013, the production of the second season of the reality series Buckwild was halted by MTV. The show followed the lives of nine young adults in West Virginia. This decision was made following the tragic death of one of the show's stars, Shain Gandee. To support the cast and crew during this difficult time, grief counseling services were immediately provided on set.

Shain Gandee, along with his uncle and friend, was discovered dead after being involved in an off-roading accident. At the time of his passing, Gandee was only 21 years old. According to the West Virginia Sheriff's Department, the group succumbed to carbon monoxide poisoning when their vehicle became stuck in the mud.

Scroll through the gallery below to witness a series of devastating reality TV tragedies.

Credit: Kevin Winter/Getty Images

Reality TV Tragedies: The Saddest and Most Shocking Deaths

Parting ways is never easy. Reality stars possess a unique appeal, as fans come to perceive them as genuine individuals rather than mere fictional personas. Consequently, bidding farewell to these personalities becomes even more emotionally challenging.

In recent years, several stars from popular reality shows such as The Deadliest Catch, The Real World, Survivor, The Real Housewives, Buckwild, and The Bachelorette have experienced untimely and tragic deaths.

These unfortunate incidents have had a significant impact on the production of the respective shows. A notable example is the temporary halt in the production of the second season of Buckwild, an MTV reality series that documented the lives of nine young adults in West Virginia. This decision was made following the sudden death of one of the show's stars, Shain Gandee, in April 2013. To support the cast and crew during this difficult time, grief counseling services were immediately offered on set.

The reality star, his uncle, and friend were tragically discovered deceased after an off-roading incident. Gandee, who was only 21 years old, and the group lost their lives due to carbon monoxide poisoning when their vehicle became trapped in the mud. In response to this devastating event, West Virginia Mayor Danny Jones appealed to the network to terminate the series, as he believed it further perpetuated the negative stereotype already associated with the Kanawha Valley.

The show's cancellation came just one week after the tragic demise, resulting in the first portion of season 2 never seeing the light of day. Producer J.P. Williams made efforts to pitch the show to other networks, but alleged that MTV hindered the process.

In speaking to The Hollywood Reporter, Williams expressed his discontent with MTV, labeling them as the epitome of hypocrisy. He specifically called out Van Toffler and Susanne Daniels for their promotion of premarital sex and endorsing the notion of abandoning a child after its birth on shows like Teen Mom. Williams sarcastically remarked on their apparent discovery of a moral high ground.

Scroll through the gallery below for more heartbreaking reality TV tragedies.

Credit: YouTube

Larry 'Mr. Buttermilk Biscuits' Myers Jr.

The My 600-Lb. Life star, who appeared on a 2022 episode, died in June 2023 at age 49.

Credit: Courtesy of Aubrey Wilson/Facebook

Aubrey Wilson

The 22-year-old Indiana native, who was a contestant on the first season of Netflix's Girls Incarcerated, passed away on September 30, 2022. Her grandmother, Robin Waters, confirmed the heartbreaking news in a statement to In Touch, expressing devastation over the loss. "We are devastated. I am usually a private person, but this situation is different. I hope that all those who cared about her can find solace in the knowledge that she is now at peace. Perhaps her story can also serve as a source of support for others facing similar struggles," Waters shared. She further revealed that her granddaughter's cause of death was believed to be an overdose, possibly involving fentanyl or heroin.

The star of My 600-Lb. Life, who was featured in a 2020 episode, passed away at her residence in New Jersey in August 2021 at the age of 30. Upon learning of Gina Krasley's death, TLC expressed deep sorrow and condolences, as she had bravely shared her weight-loss journey on My 600lb Life. The network tweeted, "Our thoughts and prayers are with her family during this difficult time."

Credit: Discovery

Billy Brown

In February 2021, the patriarch of the Alaskan Bush People, Billy Brown, passed away at the age of 68. His son Bear shared the heartbreaking news on Instagram, expressing their deep sorrow over the loss. Billy was not only a beloved father, grandfather, and husband, but also a best friend to his family. He lived a unique and unconventional life, choosing to reside off the grid and away from civilization, and he imparted this way of living to his loved ones. In the wake of his passing, the family plans to honor his legacy by carrying on his dreams. During this difficult time, they kindly request privacy and prayers.

Credit: Courtesy of Nick McGlashan/Instagram

Nick McGlashan

The Discovery Channel expressed their condolences to the loved ones of the late Deadliest Catch star who passed away on December 27, 2020 in Nashville, Tennessee, at the age of 33. Nick, who hailed from a family of crabbers, was renowned for his extensive knowledge and had a remarkable sense of humor, even in the most challenging circumstances. He will be deeply missed by all who had the privilege of knowing him.

Credit: Courtesy Whitney Collings/Facebook

Whitney Collings

Collings, a former cast member of Bad Girls Club season 3, passed away in December 2020 at a hospital close to her hometown of Boston. She was 33 years old at the time of her death, and the cause was undisclosed when the news initially surfaced. Expressing her profound grief on Facebook, her mother wrote, "I am completely shattered and will never be able to overcome this tragedy. Life can be so unjust. She possessed a kind soul and a generous heart."

Credit: FOX/YouTube

Ben Watkins

Ben Watkins, who competed on season 6 of MasterChef Junior, died in November 2020 after battling cancer for nearly two years. He was 14.

Credit: Newscom/MEGA

Nikki McKibbin

The talented singer, who secured the third position on the inaugural season of American Idol in 2002, alongside Justin Guarini and Kelly Clarkson, passed away on November 1 at the age of 42 due to a brain aneurysm. American Idol host Ryan Seacrest expressed his admiration for Nikki, stating that she was a superstar from the moment she walked into auditions, impressing everyone with her exceptional talent and unforgettable stage presence. He considered it a privilege to witness her growth and the immense inspiration she provided to millions of people. Our thoughts and condolences go out to her family, friends, and fans who are mourning this devastating loss.

The star of The Little Women: Atlanta tragically passed away on April 27, 2020, as a result of a hit-and-run accident. According to her publicist, Liz Dixson, the 34-year-old was driving alone on April 26 when another vehicle collided with hers, rendering her unconscious. Despite her critical condition at the scene, emergency personnel were able to resuscitate her and transport her to the hospital.

Dixson stated, "They were able to detect a pulse and successfully revive her. She was not pronounced dead on arrival. She remained in the hospital for approximately 24 hours before her passing. Initially, the medical professionals were uncertain if she would survive until morning, so we were grateful to have a few more hours with her. She ultimately passed away at Grady Memorial Hospital at 10:30 p.m. EST."

Credit: ABC/Ed Herrera

Tyler Gwozdz

On January 13, 2020, the Bachelorette season 15 contestant suffered an apparent overdose, leading to his emergency hospitalization in Boca Raton, Florida. After spending a week in the hospital, Gwozdz tragically passed away at the young age of 29.

Gwozdz garnered attention in May 2019 when he unexpectedly departed from the ABC dating series during the third episode. Lead Hannah Brown expressed her disappointment, stating, "Tyler G. had to leave, and it's disheartening because I genuinely had a great time on our date."

In response to allegations made by a Reddit user, who accused Gwozdz of being an "extreme misogynist" and spitting on an ex-girlfriend, he refuted the claims in a statement provided to Refinery29.

"Addressing unfounded rumors shared on Reddit by an unidentified user appears unwise," he stated in May 2019. "I believe that even acknowledging them gives them some form of attention and validation. However, I maintain my faith in my own journey and find purpose in everything that has happened to me in my life. Above all, I am a devoted son to my mother, who raised me to rise above such baseless accusations. These rumors are so contrary to my character and values that it seems pointless to waste time refuting them. Nevertheless, I suppose I will do so for the sake of clarity."

Credit: Courtesy Alexis Eddy/Instagram

Alexis Eddy

The young Are You The One? contestant passed away in January 2020 when he was only 23 years old. Authorities were called to Eddy's residence in West Virginia following his sudden cardiac arrest.

Credit: Jason Merritt/Getty Images

Beth Chapman

In June 2019, Beth Chapman, who had starred on both Dog the Bounty Hunter and Dog and Beth: On the Hunt, died following a battle with throat and lung cancer. She was 51.

Credit: TLC

Lisa Fleming

After appearing on season 6 of My 600-Lb. Life, Lisa Fleming died at the age of 50 on August 23, 2018.

At the young age of 30, the My 600-Lb. Life star was found dead on August 2, 2018. A coroner’s report later confirmed his cause of death was suicide.

Credit: Courtesy of Lyric McHenry/Instagram

Lyric McHenry

One of EJ Johnson’s best friends, Lyric McHenry, starred on and produced the E! reality show EJNYC. She was found dead in NYC on August 14, 2018, at age 26.

Credit: Angela Weiss/Getty Images for The Humane Society Of The United State

Christina Grimmie

The talented singer, who achieved third place in season 6 of The Voice, tragically passed away on June 10, 2016. She was fatally shot during a meet and greet event in Orlando, Florida, at the young age of 22.

Credit: Courtesy of Dr. Brandon Rogers/Instagram

Dr. Brandon Rogers

A promising participant on America's Got Talent, Dr. Brandon Rogers, tragically passed away a few weeks before his scheduled episode airing in June 2017. His exceptional talent as a singer had earned him the opportunity to perform on stage with Boyz II Men in January 2016, leaving a lasting impression on the audience.

Credit: Carley Margolis/FilmMagic

Danny Dias

The reality TV personality was discovered deceased in his residence in Brooklyn on June 3, 2017, at the age of 34. He gained fame through his participation in season 13 of Road Rules in 2004, and subsequently made appearances on The Challenge in 2005.

Credit: Chris Polk/FilmMagic

Clay Adler, Newport Harbor: The Real Orange County

The MTV reality star reportedly died after an apparent suicide at age 27. According to TMZ, he shot himself while in the desert with friends on March 25, 2017. 

Hill tragically passed away on April 23, 2014, following a paragliding accident in Utah. His untimely demise occurred before his season of The Bachelorette aired. Despite being one of the contenders vying for Andi Dorfman's heart, he had already been eliminated from the competition prior to his injury. Prior to his appearance on the show, Hill had embarked on a remarkable journey to visit every U.N.-recognized country. Heartbreakingly, his sister informed us through Facebook that Eric had shared his final moments with his immediate family by his side as he breathed his last breath.

Credit: Craig Sjodin/ABC

Gia Allemand, The Bachelor

The 29-year-old model and former contestant on The Bachelor tragically passed away in New Orleans on Wednesday, August 13. Just two days prior, she was discovered unconscious at her residence by her boyfriend, professional basketball player Ryan Anderson, following what was described as a suicide attempt by her representative. She gained recognition after appearing on season 14 of The Bachelor, where she made it to the final three. Known for her compassion towards animals and dedication to rescuing homeless pets, she will be remembered as a loving woman who cherished her family dearly.

Credit: MTV

Shain Gandee, Buckwild

Gandee, along with two others, tragically lost his life at the young age of 21 when they were found dead in his truck on April 1, 2013. The West Virginia Sheriff's Department determined that the cause of death was carbon monoxide poisoning, resulting from the vehicle and its muffler becoming stuck in the mud. The passing of the MTV star deeply affected his costar Cara Parrish, who expressed her profound sadness through a tweet: "This is the emptiest I've ever felt." A week later, Gandee's funeral was attended by hundreds of friends and fans, all dressed in camouflage as a tribute to him.

Credit: Blair Bunting/Discovery Channel

Phil Harris, Deadliest Catch

The renowned captain of the crab-fishing vessel Cornelia Marie, who was widely known for his appearances on The Discovery Channel, tragically passed away on February 9, 2010. His untimely death was caused by an intracranial hemorrhage resulting from complications of a severe stroke he had experienced in late January. At the age of 53, he left behind a legacy of resilience and determination. In a heartfelt statement, his sons Josh and Jake expressed their admiration for their father, stating, "Dad has always been a fighter, and he continued to exhibit strength until the very end. We will forever cherish and honor his unwavering spirit."

Credit: Discovery Channel

Justin Tennison, Deadliest Catch

On Feb. 22, 2011, just over a year following Captain Harris' demise, Tennison, a deckhand of Cornelia Marie, was discovered deceased in a hotel room in Alaska. An examination conducted postmortem disclosed that the 33-year-old celebrity had succumbed to untreated complications arising from sleep apnea.

Credit: Prince Williams/Getty Images

Ashley "A.J." Jewell, The Real Housewives of Atlanta

Kandi Burruss' former fiancé tragically passed away following a severe head injury sustained during a confrontation at an Atlanta strip club on October 2, 2009. At the age of 34, his untimely demise left Burruss in complete disbelief. In a heartfelt tweet, she expressed her deep concern for A.J.'s children, urging others to keep them in their thoughts and prayers. Overwhelmed with emotions, Burruss now seeks solace and rest for her weary eyes.

Taylor Armstrong's estranged husband tragically passed away on August 15, 2011, in what appeared to be a suicide. In the aftermath of his death, his family placed blame on the show for irreparably damaging the couple's marriage and even suspected foul play. It is worth noting that during that period, he was facing allegations of defrauding investors. "Knowing him as a person and understanding how much he valued life," his mother expressed her doubts about his involvement in such a tragic act.

Credit: ANIMAL PLANET

Steve Irwin, The Crocodile Hunter

The 44-year-old Australian adventurer was fatally injured while snorkeling in the Great Barrier Reef near Port Douglas, Queensland, on September 4, 2006. He was pierced in the chest by a stingray, causing his crew, who were accompanying him to film the documentary "Ocean's Deadliest," to rush him back to the boat. Despite their efforts to administer CPR, it was unfortunately too late to save him.

Credit: Jon Furniss/WireImage.com

Ryan Dunn, Jackass

On June 20, 2011, the MTV daredevil was driving at a speed of 130 miles per hour, while having a blood alcohol level of .196, which was twice the legal limit in Pennsylvania. He tragically crashed his Porsche 911 GT3 into a guardrail in West Goshen Township and the vehicle caught fire. Jackass costar Bam Margera expressed his disappointment, stating that his 34-year-old friend had immense potential and it was truly unfair.

Credit: Monty Brinton/CBS/Getty Images

Jennifer Lyon, Survivor Palau

After finishing in fourth place in Survivor's 10th season, Lyon, who was 33 years old at the time, received a diagnosis of stage three breast cancer in 2005. She bravely underwent a double mastectomy and chemotherapy, but unfortunately, the cancer later spread and she tragically passed away at the age of 37 on Jan. 19, 2010. Survivor host Jeff Probst spoke highly of Lyon's ability to demonstrate how to love someone who is dying during her time on the reality show.

Credit: Art Streiber/MTV

Joey Kovar, The Real World: Hollywood

Kovar tragically passed away at the age of 29 due to "opiate intoxication" in Chicago on August 17, 2012. His untimely death came after a prolonged battle with substance abuse, which he openly discussed during his appearance on The Real World: Hollywood in 2008. Recognizing the severity of his struggles, Kovar took a step towards recovery in 2010 by seeking treatment for his cocaine and ecstasy addiction on VH1's Celebrity Rehab With Dr. Drew.

Credit: Kevin Foley/ABC/Getty Images

Julien Hug, The Bachelorette

Hug, a participant on Jillian Harris' season of ABC's Bachelorette, tragically ended his own life on November 3, 2010, through a self-inflicted gunshot wound. In a heartfelt suicide note addressed to his parents, the 35-year-old restaurateur revealed his long-standing battle with severe depression. He expressed his overwhelming distress and admitted to feeling helpless in finding ways to cope with his emotional struggles. Hug questioned the purpose of continued existence if life lacked joy and fulfillment.

DeStefano, a standout comedian who reached the top five in season seven of NBC's stand-up comedy competition, tragically passed away on March 6, 2011, at the age of 44. His representative expressed heartfelt condolences, stating, "We will always remember his immense kindness, unwavering love for others, and his selfless dedication to making people laugh."

Credit: Randi Radcliff/Getty Images

Mindy McCready, Celebrity Rehab With Dr. Drew

The country singer had been struggling to cope with the suicide of her boyfriend, David Wilson, in January 2013. Tragically, on February 17, 2013, she took her own life, leaving behind two young sons. Her untimely death, which became the fifth in Celebrity Rehab history, deeply affected her former costars, especially Lisa D'Amato, a renowned alum of America's Next Top Model. "I'm devastated right now; it's heartbreaking to see so many of my friends from the show passing away," expressed D'Amato to Us.

Credit: Tiffany Rose/Getty Images

Jeff Conaway, Celebrity Rehab With Dr. Drew

Three years after seeking treatment on VH1's Celebrity Rehab in 2008, the Grease actor found himself hospitalized due to what was initially believed to be a prescription drug overdose. However, it was later revealed that his May 27 death was caused by pneumonia and sepsis, a dangerous blood infection. At the time of his passing, he was 60 years old.

Credit: Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images

Rodney King, Celebrity Rehab With Dr. Drew

King, who gained notoriety after a brutal encounter with L.A. police in 1991 following a high-speed chase, turned to Celebrity Rehab during its second season to address his struggle with alcohol addiction. Unfortunately, four years later, on June 17, 2012, he was tragically discovered lifeless in his swimming pool. Subsequent findings from an autopsy report exposed the presence of marijuana, cocaine, and alcohol in his system.

Credit: Peter Kramer/Getty Images

Anna Nicole Smith, The Anna Nicole Show

The former Playboy model and star of her own self-titled reality show passed away at the age of 39, after being discovered unconscious and unresponsive in a room at the Seminole Hard Rock Hotel and Casino in Hollywood, Fla., on Feb. 8, 2007. The official cause of her death was determined to be "combined drug intoxication." She leaves behind her daughter Dannielynn Birkhead, whom she shared with her ex-boyfriend Larry Birkhead. 

Credit: Gregg DeGuire/WireImage.com

Daniel Smith, The Anna Nicole Show

Smith's son, who was 20 years old, tragically passed away on September 10, 2006, while visiting his renowned mother in the hospital. According to forensic pathologist Cyril Wecht, the autopsy revealed that his death was a result of a deadly combination of Zoloft, Lexapro, and methadone.

The renowned Mexican-American singer and popular figure in numerous reality shows tragically passed away in a devastating private jet accident on December 9, 2012. The crash occurred just south of Monterrey, a city in northern Mexico, shortly after the plane's departure that morning. At the time of her untimely demise, she was 42 years old and left behind a loving family of five children.

Credit: Frazer Harrison/Getty Images

Leslie Carter, House of Carters

Once a promising young vocalist, the 25-year-old sister of Nick and Aaron Carter had a lengthy history of mental illness and was undergoing treatment for depression, as stated in a police report regarding her untimely demise. Tragically, on January 31, 2012, she tragically succumbed to an overdose of prescription medication at her residence in Mayville, N.Y., leaving her husband Mike to single-handedly care for their then-10-month-old daughter, Alyssa.

Credit:Chelsea Lauren/WireImage.com

Corey Haim, The Two Coreys

The former teen heartthrob successfully battled his struggles with various addictions, only to tragically pass away at the age of 38 on March 11, 2010. The cause of his death was attributed to pneumonia, as well as damage to the air sacs in his lungs and the accumulation of plaque in his blood vessels and heart. Corey Feldman, a close friend and co-star, mourned the loss of this extraordinary yet tormented individual.

Credit: Noel Vasquez/Getty Images

Adam "DJ AM" Goldstein, The Simple Life

Nicole Richie's former partner joined her on the third season of The Simple Life in 2005 and 2006. However, tragedy struck three years later on Aug. 28, 2009, when he passed away at the age of 36 due to an apparent drug overdose. In the months leading up to his untimely death, Goldstein battled with mental anguish stemming from a plane crash he had survived alongside Travis Barker in September 2008.

Credit:Jesse Grant/WireImage.com

Jani Lane, Celebrity Fit Club 2

Former Warrant lead singer Lane passed away at the age of 47 due to alcohol poisoning. His life came to an end on August 11, 2011, while staying at a Comfort Inn in Woodland Hills, California. This tragic event occurred six years after his appearance on VH1's Celebrity Fit Club 2. Lane's passing left behind four children, named Taylar, Brittany, Madison, and Ryan, from his two previous marriages.

Credit: MTV

Frankie Abernathy, The Real World: San Diego

On June 9, 2007, three years after appearing on the 14th season of MTV's The Real World, Abernathy died of complications from cystic fibrosis. She was 25 years old.

The beloved baker, who worked for more than four decades at Carlo's Bake Shop -- where TLC's Cake Boss series was set -- died of cancer on Jan. 30, 2011. He was 63 years old.

Credit: Annamaria DiSanto/WireImage.com

Mike Starr, Celebrity Rehab With Dr. Drew

Starr's passing on March 8, 2011, marked the tragic loss of the first member from the cast of Celebrity Rehab. After seeking treatment on the show in 2009, he continued his journey towards recovery by participating in the second season of VH1's Sober House in the following year. Regrettably, his battle with addiction proved insurmountable, leading to his untimely demise at the age of 44 in Salt Lake City, Utah. Dr. Drew Pinsky expressed his devastation upon hearing the news, sharing his profound sadness over Mike Starr's inability to overcome his illness.