Top 15 Missteps in The Traitors US Season 2

15. The Overlooked Asthmatic Excuse

John Bercow's claim of asthma as a reason for his irregular breathing when the traitors were initially tapped was a curious moment. His condition was brought into question later when he effortlessly participated in a physical challenge without an inhaler in sight. This inconsistency raised eyebrows but ultimately turned out to be a distraction rather than a clue. The faithfuls' undue attention to John's behavior may have been better placed on scrutinizing more subtle signs of treachery within their ranks. While John's medical claim could have been a clever ruse, it was a misstep for the faithfuls to fixate on it so early in the game without further evidence.

John Bercow in The Traitors US Season 2 promotional photo

14. Parvati's Poisonous Performance

The decision to allow Parvati Shallow to take on the high-risk task of poisoning a chalice was questionable. Her attempts seemed too overt, heightening the risk of detection by observant players like Sandra. While Phaedra's strategy to remain in the shadows was wise, and Dan was already under suspicion, Parvati's actions could have easily backfired. The traitors' ability to deceive hinges on subtlety and finesse, and Parvati's performance lacked these crucial elements. It was a gamble that could have compromised the traitors' position and revealed their identities prematurely, potentially derailing their mission entirely.

Parvati Shallow The Traitors

13. Letting Dan Escape Scrutiny

Dan Gheesling's quiet demeanor raised suspicions among his peers, but the failure to act on these instincts was a notable oversight. At the second round table, despite being a prime suspect, Dan remained in the game. This lapse in judgment by the faithfuls allowed a possible traitor to continue influencing the game's outcome. Larsa Pippen's reluctance to let Dan off the hook hinted at potential consequences in future episodes. The group's hesitance to confront Dan's aloofness could be seen as a missed opportunity to root out deceit and strengthen the faithfuls' collective defense against the hidden enemies among them.

Dan Gheesling in The Traitors promotional poster

12. The Premature Elimination of Marcus

Marcus Johnson's premature elimination from The Traitors US triggered an unexpected chain reaction, igniting Larsa Pippen's determination to seek justice. Marcus, known for his strong gameplay, was a formidable ally to the faithfuls. His removal from the game not only weakened the faithfuls' ranks but also roused Larsa's suspicions, particularly towards Dan. This misstep by the players not only cost them a valuable team member but also intensified the scrutiny on the remaining contestants. The backlash from Marcus' ousting demonstrated the delicate balance required in the game, where each elimination can have far-reaching implications beyond the immediate round.

Larsa Pippen and Marcus Jordan from The Real Housewives of Miami

11. Dan's Disappearing Act

Dan Gheesling's subdued presence on The Traitors US became his Achilles' heel. Renowned for his strategic prowess in Big Brother, Dan struggled to replicate that success in a game where speaking up is as important as staying silent. His reluctance to share candid opinions made him appear disengaged and potentially untrustworthy. Dan's failure to balance participation and observation led to him becoming the weakest link among the traitors. His silent strategy not only made him a target for suspicion but also hindered his ability to rally support and secure his position within the group. Dan's reticence became a strategic misstep that could jeopardize the traitors' overall chances of success.

10. Peppermint's Accidental Admission

Peppermint's verbal slip-up, where she inadvertently referred to herself as a traitor, was a critical error that exacerbated her already precarious situation. Her immediate attempt to backtrack did little to assuage the suspicions of her fellow contestants. Despite her dramatic reaction to Trishelle's accusations and her desire to defend herself, Peppermint's blunder was the final straw that led the faithfuls to mistakenly eliminate an innocent player. This incident showcased the high stakes of verbal communication in The Traitors US, where a single misstep in speech can seal a player's fate.

Peppermint in the Traitors US Season 2 promotional photo

9. Disregarding Peppermint's Potential

The decision to eliminate Peppermint from The Traitors US was a grave miscalculation. Known for her outspoken nature and keen insight, Peppermint was a strong contender who could have been instrumental in identifying the traitors. Her popularity and assertiveness made her a valuable asset to the faithfuls. However, her elimination not only removed a potential key player from the game but also played into the hands of the traitors, who benefitted from the removal of a perceptive and influential contestant. This strategic blunder by the faithfuls highlighted the importance of carefully weighing each player's contributions and potential before rushing to judgment.

8. The Accusation Fallout Between Trishelle and Peppermint

Trishelle Cannatella's baseless accusation against Peppermint created unnecessary tensions and divided the group. By singling out Peppermint without substantial evidence, Trishelle not only alienated a fellow contestant but also fostered an environment of distrust. The fallout from this accusation was disproportionate, leading to rallying support against an undeserving faithful. The hasty formation of alliances based on unfounded suspicions demonstrated a lack of strategic forethought. This episode served as a cautionary tale, highlighting the risks of making enemies too quickly in a game where alliances can be both a shield and a sword.

Trishelle Canatella The Traitors Promotional Poster

7. Larsa's Premature Accusations

Larsa Pippen's strategy to openly accuse Parvati Shallow of being a traitor early in the game was a bold move that could have easily backfired. While her intuition about Dan eventually proved correct, her initial accusations against Parvati were unfounded, as Parvati was still a faithful at the time. Larsa's aggressive approach risked alienating potential allies and undermining her credibility. Her eagerness to identify traitors overshadowed the need for a more calculated and observant stance. This aggressive tactic exemplified the fine line players must walk between voicing suspicions and maintaining a level of diplomacy that doesn't jeopardize their own standing in the game.

Larsa Pippen The Traitors Promotional Poster

6. Parvati's Risky Poison Plot

Parvati Shallow's decision to take on the risky role of poisoning a chalice was fraught with danger. Her actions were far from covert, potentially exposing her as a traitor to vigilant players like Sandra. The gamble not only threatened to reveal the traitors' identities but also put Parvati in the hot seat. The challenge called for stealth and guile, qualities that Parvati's approach seemed to lack at that moment. This tactical error could have had severe repercussions for the traitors' collective agenda, throwing a wrench into their carefully laid plans.

5. Dismissing the Asthma Alibi

John Bercow's asthma alibi during the traitor selection process was a peculiar episode that diverted the faithfuls' attention. While his irregular breathing was initially deemed suspicious, it was later overshadowed by his active participation in challenges without any apparent need for an inhaler. The faithfuls' preoccupation with John's breathing patterns was a misdirected effort that could have been better spent on more pressing matters. In a game where every clue counts, the faithfuls' fixation on John's health condition was a tactical misstep that cost them valuable time and focus.

4. Peppermint's Tragic Tongue Twister

Peppermint's inadvertent self-identification as a traitor was an unfortunate slip of the tongue that had dire consequences. The mishap occurred during a heated moment when she was already under scrutiny, and her correction was too little too late. This miscommunication amplified existing doubts and led to her wrongful elimination. In an environment where words are dissected for truth and lies, Peppermint's tongue twister was a devastating blow to her game, illustrating the fragile nature of trust and the swift judgment that can follow a simple linguistic error.

3. The Unwarranted Targeting of Peppermint

The faithfuls' decision to target Peppermint for elimination was an error that removed a strong player from their midst. Her vibrant personality and ability to read people could have been key assets in uncovering the traitors. Instead, her forceful exit was a boon for the traitors, who benefited from the loss of a perceptive and influential player. This miscalculation by the faithfuls underscored the need for a strategic approach to eliminations, ensuring that each decision strengthens their position rather than inadvertently aiding their adversaries.

2. The Rash Accusatory Tactics of Trishelle

Trishelle Cannatella's rash approach to leveling accusations created an atmosphere of animosity and suspicion, particularly toward Peppermint. Her claim had no substantial evidence, and yet it led to a bandwagon effect, with some players too eager to jump on board. This impulsive behavior highlighted the dangers of hurried judgment and the potential for creating rifts within the group. Trishelle's tactic of making enemies swiftly was a glaring mistake that could have long-term repercussions for her game, as it jeopardized potential alliances and fostered unnecessary conflict.

1. Larsa's Rash Betrayal Allegations

Larsa Pippen's hasty allegations against Parvati Shallow set the stage for a tumultuous start to The Traitors US. Despite her later correct suspicion of Dan, Larsa's early accusation against Parvati, who was a faithful at the time, was premature. This aggressive tactic could have derailed her own game by casting doubt on her judgment and alienating potential allies. Larsa's approach highlights the delicate balance required in The Traitors US, where bold claims can quickly turn the tide of the game for better or worse, depending on their accuracy and timing.