The Unseen Brilliance: Why Rotten Tomatoes Scores Don't Define Netflix Hits

The Misleading Influence of Rotten Tomatoes

Netflix is challenging the traditional notion that a bad Rotten Tomatoes score equates to a bad movie or show. Several of the platform's most popular properties have defied the odds and captured the hearts of audiences despite being deemed 'rotten'.

You People Jonah Hill and Lauren London

The recent engagement report from Netflix sheds light on the surprising truth that movies and shows with Rotten Tomatoes scores below 60% are still drawing in a significant viewership. This revelation challenges the widely-held belief that a low Rotten Tomatoes score is synonymous with poor quality entertainment.

Arnold Schwarzenegger and Monica Barbaro in FUBAR Season 1

The phenomenon of rotten movies and shows achieving popularity on Netflix can be attributed to various factors. One key factor is the influence of lead actors, where dedicated fans are drawn to watch anything featuring their favorite stars, regardless of critical reception. Additionally, the exceptional talent of certain actors or acting duos can elevate the appeal of a movie, making it a worthwhile watch despite its Rotten Tomatoes rating.

Lily Collins as Emily in Emily in Paris season 3 episode 8

The Allure of Iconic Casts and Engaging Narratives

The success of certain Netflix movies and shows with low Rotten Tomatoes scores can be attributed to the captivating nature of their casts and storylines. Despite receiving unfavorable ratings, these productions have managed to captivate audiences through the allure of iconic cast members and engaging narratives.

Lily Collins as Emily in Emily in Paris season 3 episode 10.

One such example is the movie 'You People', featuring a star-studded cast including Jonah Hill, Eddie Murphy, and Julia Louis-Dreyfus. Despite its Rotten Tomatoes score of 40%, the movie's modern take on race relations and the central romance has made it popular among Netflix subscribers, highlighting the influence of talented actors in driving viewership.

Lily Collins in Emily in Paris Season 3

Similarly, the series 'Kaleidoscope' has garnered attention with its heist scenarios and non-linear storyline, despite its Rotten Tomatoes score of 49%. The cast's portrayal of a master thief and the crew's plotting to rob an impenetrable vault has fascinated viewers, showcasing the enduring appeal of captivating narratives and well-executed performances.

Lily Collins as Emily and Ashley Park as Mindy in Emily in Paris season 3 episode 7

The Enduring Allure of Fan Favorites and Future Prospects

The enduring allure of fan favorites and the possibilities of future prospects have played a significant role in the success of Netflix productions with low Rotten Tomatoes scores. Despite critical reception, the dedication of loyal fans and the potential for future developments have contributed to the sustained popularity of these movies and shows.

Lily Collins as Emily in Emily in Paris season 3

For instance, the series 'Emily In Paris' has continued to attract viewers, despite its Rotten Tomatoes score of 63%. The allure of Parisian fashion and cuisine showcased throughout the series, along with the potential for future seasons, has kept the audience engaged, demonstrating the influence of fan loyalty and the promise of future content.

Netflix's Kaleidoscope Cast standing and looking at the screen of something

Additionally, the movie 'The Mother', despite its Rotten Tomatoes score of 46%, has garnered attention due to its thrilling espionage storyline and the compelling relationship between a mother and the daughter she gave up for adoption. The enduring popularity of such productions highlights the fact that critics' opinions are not the sole determinants of a production's success.

Reese Witherspoon and Ashton Kutcher in Your Place or Mine