The Unbelievable Truth: How Robert Redford Almost Starred in HBO's Hit Series Yellowstone

Yellowstone had the potential to be a completely different show if it had been led by screen icon Robert Redford. The popular Paramount Network series, created by Taylor Sheridan, the writer of the critically acclaimed film Hell or High Water, has since spawned a successful franchise with spinoff series like 1883 and 1923, and more in the works. The main series centers around Kevin Costner's character, John Dutton III, as he battles to protect his family's ranch in Montana from various threats.

In a recent interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Sheridan discussed the early stages of Yellowstone's development, when he initially pitched the show to HBO. Despite the then-president of programming, Michael Lombardo, recognizing Sheridan's talent and believing in the project, HBO's team was not supportive and instead suggested casting Robert Redford as the lead. Sheridan fought for Redford, but HBO clarified that they wanted someone who embodied the essence of Redford, rather than the actor himself. Here are Lombardo and Sheridan's full statements on the matter:

Would Yellowstone Have Succeeded at HBO with Robert Redford?

Michael Lombardo: I was truly impressed by Taylor's authenticity. While many people in the industry put on a façade, Taylor was genuine and wrote from personal experience. He had a deep passion for the show and its success. The concept of creating a modern-day Western with a touch of classic elements was brilliant. We had always focused on urban shows, so this felt like a breath of fresh air.

Taylor Sheridan: When I initially pitched Kevin Costner as the lead to the HBO executives, they weren't convinced. They expressed their preference for Robert Redford, stating that if I could bring him on board, they would greenlight the pilot. Determined to make it happen, I made my way to Sundance and spent the day with Robert Redford, eventually convincing him to play the role of John Dutton. Excitedly, I called the senior vice president in charge of production to share the news.

His response was nothing short of shocking.

"What?! Who did you get?"

"Robert Redford."

"You got who?"

"Robert Redford himself."

And then, in a twist that seemed too unbelievable to be true, he replied, "We meant a Robert Redford type."

(Note: The placeholder

Would Yellowstone Have Succeeded at HBO with Robert Redford?

Had HBO opted for Redford as the protagonist, Yellowstone would have taken on an entirely different tone. However, upon initial observation, it appears that both Redford and Costner are suitable choices for the lead role, despite their 18-year age gap. They both boast a comparable level of experience in Westerns and neo-Westerns. Redford has previously showcased his talent in acclaimed projects such as Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid and Jeremiah Johnson, while Costner has left his mark with performances in Wyatt Earp and Silverado.

HBO possibly rejected casting Robert Redford due to his high price tag as an Oscar-winning star. It is unclear how much of a price difference there would have been between Redford and Costner, as both actors had recently achieved success in major franchises. However, Redford's established status as a more seasoned actor would likely have commanded a higher fee.

Had Yellowstone aired with Redford in the lead role, the expectations for viewership would have been much higher in order for the show to be renewed. Although the series is now a great success, its viewership grew gradually over the seasons, and the numbers from season 1 might not have been enough to justify the higher cost of the lead actor. This could have hindered the show's potential growth, especially considering Warner Bros., HBO's parent company, is currently facing financial difficulties and undergoing significant restructuring that would have also affected the show if it had continued.

Source: THR