The Ultimate Review: Netflix's Live-Action One Piece Sets a New Standard for Anime Adaptations

Summary

Netflix's new One Piece live-action series breaks the curse of bad anime adaptations, staying true to the source material and delivering a great show in its own right.

The show's simplicity and captivating characters create an enjoyable viewing experience, filled with entertaining interactions and touching moments that establish a sense of belonging. Though the artistic style may discourage certain viewers due to its animated appearance, the well-crafted narrative and compelling characters seamlessly integrate even the most lighthearted aspects, while the visual style complements the realistic aspects of the show.

During the 2023 WGA and SAG-AFTRA strikes, this piece was written acknowledging the absence of the writers and actors currently on strike. Without their labor, the series being discussed here would not exist.

Netflix has finally shattered the curse of poorly made live-action anime adaptations with the introduction of the new One Piece show. Previous attempts, such as the Death Note and Cowboy Bebop live-action series, have tarnished the reputation of these adaptations, leaving fans skeptical about the quality of One Piece. However, by remaining true to the core elements that made the source material exceptional, the new One Piece series has not only served as a remarkable adaptation but has also become an exceptional show in its own right.

Monkey D. Luffy, an amiable young man portrayed by Iñaki Godoy, embarks on a quest to become the king of pirates and uncover the legendary treasure known as the One Piece. However, achieving this feat requires him to gather a crew and obtain a map leading to the treacherous Grand Line, a perilous expanse of ocean teeming with deadly adversaries. Along his journey, Luffy encounters a skilled swordsman named Zoro (played by Mackenyu) and a reluctant ally, the cunning thief Nami (portrayed by Emily Rudd). Together, they traverse various islands, forming new alliances and facing off against both friends and foes. Yet, amidst their adventures, they must constantly evade the relentless pursuit of the Marines, determined to apprehend them for their past transgressions.

The beauty of One Piece lies in its straightforward plot, allowing the show to focus on its delightful cast of characters. The interactions between Luffy and his crew are a joy to watch as they transform from strangers to a true found family. Characters like Zoro bring a lot of humor to the show. These fun moments are contrasted against the tragic backstories and challenges faced by the main protagonists, revealed through well-placed flashbacks.

While the characters are the heart of the show, the plot keeps the audience engaged. Luffy's journey to become a pirate involves gathering a crew and a ship, but each island he visits presents new obstacles and villains to overcome, keeping the series exciting. The threat of the Marines chasing him adds tension and urgency.

Certain changes have been made to make the early arcs of One Piece more streamlined and cohesive, which may upset some hardcore fans. However, as a hardcore fan myself, I believe these changes actually improve certain storylines. The show isn't without flaws, including minor pacing issues and plot holes, but these do not detract from the overall enjoyment of the show.

The show's aesthetic, which has preserved the cartoonish look of the original anime and manga, will likely be the most controversial aspect. Some viewers may be put off by the over-the-top makeup and set design, as it can make certain characters and stories seem goofier than intended. However, despite the initial absurdity, One Piece's story is incredibly enjoyable and its characters are compelling. By the end of the first episode, even the most whimsical elements seamlessly blend into the world. Surprisingly, the cartoonish style also makes the show's bizarre elements, such as evil magic clowns and fish-human hybrids, feel more grounded, magnifying the menacing nature of the villains.

The One Piece live-action show is a delightful watch for both longtime fans and newcomers. It also serves as a promising indication for Netflix's future live-action anime adaptations. If they receive the same level of dedication and enthusiasm as One Piece, they have the potential to be extraordinary. However, after watching One Piece, fans will likely anticipate the second season as the most thrilling live-action anime adaptation. Stream all eight episodes of One Piece now on Netflix.