The Ultimate Dilemma in Baldur's Gate 3: The Intrinsic Value of a Single Mortal Life

In the Overgrown Ruins of Baldur's Gate 3, players will encounter an intriguing undead entity that poses a thought-provoking query: "What is the value of a solitary life?" This profound question delves into philosophical matters, allowing players to respond sincerely or strategize for optimal outcomes.

Alternatively, gamers may choose to ignore the question altogether and engage in combat with the creature, triggering various consequences within the world of Baldur's Gate 3. While players are free to roleplay their decision, being aware of the potential outcomes beforehand can prove advantageous.

Correct Answer(s) To The Riddle In the Overgrown Ruins

All options have a passable outcome.

Withers does not respond positively to being attacked or to selfish answers.

Withers seems to like answers 1 and 4 to most.

Several characters will possess a seventh response option that is influenced by their race and class.

This particular being is identified as Withers, although the character will only discover this information at a later stage. While he cannot be recruited as a party member, he offers resurrection services at the camp for a fee of 200 gold per service. Although Withers disapproves of aggressive actions or selfish responses, he will still eventually end up at the camp.

Withers cannot be killed, at least not conventionally. It's very likely that he's a lich or has undergone a similar process.

Players have the option to confront the Sarcophagus trap near the front door or explore the surrounding area known as the Dark Crypt. Withers will inspect the Dank Crypt and provide comments before departing.

Baldur's Gate 3 is currently accessible through Early Access on PC and will officially launch on August 3rd, 2023. The PlayStation 5 version is scheduled to release on September 6th, 2023. The development of an Xbox Series X/S version is still underway.