The anime adaptation of One Piece is a mix of strengths and weaknesses, as is often the case. Netflix's interpretation of Eiichiro Oda's beloved series leans more towards the positive aspects. While it falls short of matching the original in various aspects, it manages to capture occasional glimpses of the fun and creativity that made it so popular. In the midst of the show's most emotional battle yet, the Straw Hats' journey continues to deliver thrilling moments.
Taking the reins for the two-episode Baratie arc is Tim Southam, who has previously directed shows such as Lost in Space and American Gods. Joining him is Laura Jacqmin, an accomplished playwright and one of the founding members of The Kilroys. She has previously written for Grace and Frankie, as well as the critically criticized Minecraft: Story Mode. Among the writers involved in the series, her career stands out as the most intriguing.
After the daring rescue of Kaya from the clutches of Captain Kuro, Luffy, Zoro, Nami, and Usopp embark on their brand new vessel, the renowned ship known as the Going Merry. However, their joyful departure is swiftly interrupted by a relentless assault from the Marines, led by the formidable Garp. Their hearts racing, the newly formed Straw Hat crew hurriedly assumes battle positions, with Nami being the exception, as she appears prepared for the imminent clash. Yet, to the disappointment of every avid fan, the truth becomes glaringly evident - the rest of the crew lacks any semblance of sailing proficiency.
Despite their woeful lack of expertise, a stroke of quick thinking from Luffy enables them to escape the clutches of their pursuers. This exhilarating turn of events also unveils a disconcerting revelation - Vice-Admiral Garp is none other than Luffy's own grandfather, a fact that deeply unsettles the entire crew. Seeking refuge from their pursuers, the Straw Hats navigate through dense fog and serendipitously stumble upon a luxurious floating restaurant named Baratie. It is here that they encounter their next destined comrade, the unfulfilled but talented chef, Sanji.
Sanji is given a significant amount of time in this episode to shine. His English accent adds an intriguing touch to his character. Despite the clearly French atmosphere of Baratie, master chef Zeff speaks with a similar inflection, implying that Sanji learned it from him. Character-wise, Sanji is portrayed almost flawlessly. He is kind, sophisticated, has a discerning palate, and is fixated on women. He briefly displays his unique martial arts skills, and it is impressive. Sanji tends to be a beloved character, and his strong characterization in this episode is noteworthy. Although his dream may seem small compared to others in the cast, its genuine nature makes it significant.
Additionally, Episode 5 introduces a new antagonist for the Straw Hats. After their escape, Garp calls upon Dracule Mihawk, the world's greatest swordsman. During a bonding moment between Zoro and Nami, Zoro's ambition, which had been missing until now, is ignited. As soon as Zoro lays eyes on Mihawk, he challenges him to a duel to the death. Although everyone knows he cannot win, he remains dedicated to the dream he has nurtured for all these years. The fight is faithfully adapted from the anime and showcases Zoro's consistently compelling fighting skills. His swordsmanship is executed brilliantly, even without the vibrant special effects. He appears almost superhuman without reliance on excessive CGI. Watching him face off against Hawk-Eye Mihawk is a pivotal moment in the series. Just like Shanks passing down his hat or Luffy catching a glimpse of the Going Merry, this scene is crucial to portray accurately. The episode handles it well and leaves viewers intrigued.
This episode cleverly balances the action-packed opening and finale, allowing ample room for character development among the crew. Throughout the anime, Zoro and Nami's relationship has been fraught with conflict. While their dynamic reflects the mutual mistrust they harbor, there are subtle nuances that add depth. They often find themselves stepping into the role of Luffy's caretakers, offering sensible solutions where their captain's boundless idealism falls short. The interactions between the crew members are captivating, although the actors fail to deliver their emotional moments convincingly. Perhaps it's challenging to convey deep introspection when one's appearance is dramatically altered with hair dye. Nevertheless, despite the well-crafted portrayal of the characters, they were more relatable when they existed purely in animated form. It's a lamentable lesson that Hollywood continually has to relearn, and fortunately, this show is not entirely oblivious to it.
After five episodes, One Piece continues to surpass expectations by offering an enjoyable adventure within its original world. Although some fans were initially disappointed by the series announcement, it has proven to align more with the spirit of the Rurouni Kenshin movies rather than the lackluster adaptation of Netflix's Cowboy Bebop. While there may be debates regarding the changes made during the adaptation, this version exudes a sincere appreciation for the source material that sets it apart. One Piece is simply pure, effortless entertainment and doesn't strive to be anything more. With only a few remaining episodes, if it maintains this level of quality, fans and newcomers alike will have something truly noteworthy to discuss.