Taylor Swift Fans Speculate Midnight’s ‘You’re Losing Me’ as a Counterpart to Lover’s ‘I Think He Knows’

Taylor Swift Fans Think Midnights Youre Losing Me Is the Foil Song to Lovers I Think He Knows

Taylor Swift Marcelo Endelli/TAS23/Getty Images for TAS Rights Management

Fans think that Taylor Swift's new breakup song may be in response to a song from her album "Lover" that was inspired by her relationship with ex Joe Alwyn.

After releasing her "revenge" album "Reputation" in 2017, where she hinted at her romance with Alwyn, Swift then released "Lover" in 2019. This album was meant to be a simple love story and continued the narrative of her relationship with Alwyn.

Fans were intrigued by Lover's tracklist, especially when they noticed that several of Taylor Swift's songs like "Lover," "Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince," and "False God" were featured on her "Denial" playlist prior to the release of her 11th studio album, The Tortured Poets Department.

In a recent voice note shared on Apple Music, Swift humorously explained that the playlist is all about getting so wrapped up in something that it's hard to see any warning signs, leading to moments of denial and perhaps a touch of delusion.

Despite not being featured on Swift's "Denial" playlist, fans quickly noticed that the lyrics of "I Think He Knows" are similar to a track on her "Depression" playlist called "You're Losing Me." This song is a vault track from her 2022 album Midnights.

"I Think He Knows" captures a relationship where communication is effortless and partners understand each other without needing to speak. On the other hand, "You're Losing Me" depicts a romance struggling with a breakdown in communication, creating a contrast between the two tracks.

One fan expressed their excitement, saying, "The parallels between I Think He Knows and You’re Losing Me are sending me into orbit." Another fan shared their experience, stating, "I was in the shower and both songs played back to back and I was UNWELL." A third person commented, "I can’t believe she wrote both of these songs about the same man."

In "I Think He Knows," Swift kicks off the lively pop chorus by declaring that her lover makes her heart skip down 16th Avenue. She mentions that she doesn't even have to express her feelings because he already understands.

Taylor Swift Fans Wonder If 'Fresh Out the Slammer' Is 'Ready for It' Dig at Joe Alwyn

Taylor Swift and Joe Alwyn. Jackson Lee/GC Images

In a recent song, Taylor Swift expresses feelings of losing connection with her partner. She mentions not being able to feel a heartbeat in "You're Losing Me" and feeling like her heart has stopped. The lyrics also reflect a strained conversation between the couple, where they struggle to understand each other. Taylor sings, "You say, 'I don't understand,' and I say, 'I know you don't.'"

In "I Think He Knows," Swift proudly declares herself as the center of her lover's attention, warning that he better commit or she will leave. However, in "You're Losing Me," she admits to her insecurities, saying she wouldn't even marry herself and identifying as a "pathological people pleaser" who just wanted to be seen by her partner.

One of Swift's signature songwriting techniques is the use of bridges, which further emphasize the contrast between the two songs.

"He's really into me, and I totally get it," she sings in "I Think He Knows," expressing a sense of understanding. In "You're Losing Me," she simply asks to be acknowledged.

"Don't overlook me on the front lines," she pleads, emphasizing her importance by reminding him, "I'm the life of this party."

Some fans view the tracks as opposites, while others believe that even in "I Think He Knows," Swift expresses doubt in her relationship with Alwyn. She never states her seemingly confident phrases as facts, only as possibilities with the addition of the words "I think."

One Swiftie commented, "Wow, this actually hurts," alongside a screenshot of the conflicting lyrics.

Swift and Alwyn were in a relationship for almost six years before breaking up in April 2023. Throughout their time together, they chose to stay out of the public eye, often walking red carpets separately even when attending the same events. A source revealed to We that Swift's fame played a role in their decision to end the relationship.

Fans have noticed signs that Swift and Alwyn's relationship may have been strained long before they officially split. Swift's struggles with her publicized life and the pressures that came with it were evident in songs like "The Archer," "Peace," and more.

Fans can look forward to gaining more insight into Taylor Swift and Joe Alwyn's relationship when The Tortured Poets Department is released on Friday, April 19. Swift has never confirmed who her songs are about, but this new project is expected to shed some light on their dynamic.

During a February Eras Tour show in Melbourne, Australia, Swift opened up to concertgoers about the importance of the album. She expressed that creating The Tortured Poets was a lifeline for her, highlighting how songwriting has always been a source of strength and comfort in her life. This album, in particular, was a crucial outlet for her emotions.

Editor's P/S:

The article delves into the intriguing relationship between Taylor Swift's songs and her past romance with Joe Alwyn. It highlights the contrasting lyrics between "I Think He Knows" and "You're Losing Me," suggesting a shift in the dynamics of their relationship. Fans speculate that the songs may mirror the evolution of their love story, from a confident and understanding connection to a strained and fading bond.

This analysis offers a glimpse into Swift's songwriting process and how she uses music to express her experiences. The contrasting lyrics in these songs illustrate the complexity of relationships and the emotional journey they can entail. By exploring the connections between her songs and her personal life, fans gain deeper insights into Swift's artistic expression and the emotional depth of her music.