Holly Madison Claims Crystal Hefner Mirrored Her Writing Style in Tell-All Book on Playboy Mansion Experience

holly madison and Crystal Hefner 131

Getty Images (2)

Holly Madison mentioned that her and Crystal Hefner's memoirs about their experiences in the Playboy Mansion have some similarities.

During a recent interview on the "LadyGang" podcast, Madison, 44, pointed out that the narrative voice in both of their books sounds very similar. She expressed frustration, saying, "Anyone who has read my book from eight years ago and then read her book, can see that the narrative voice is almost identical. It really bothers me."

Both Madison and Crystal, 37, had relationships with the late Playboy founder Hugh Hefner. Madison, known for her role in Girls Next Door, dated Hugh from 2001 to 2008 before leaving the mansion in 2009. Crystal, on the other hand, started dating Hugh in 2009 and the couple got married in 2012. Crystal remained married to Hugh until his passing in 2017 at the age of 91.

Madison penned her memoir, Down the Rabbit Hole, in June 2015. In contrast, Crystal released her book Only Say Good Things in January, eight years after Madison's book came out. Despite Madison's initial expectations of having a different story than Crystal about her time with Hugh, she was surprised to find similarities in their writing styles. They both incorporated "fairy tale references" and "psychological catchphrases" in their books.

Madison found it strange, especially considering that Crystal had used a ghostwriter. She emphasized the importance of doing proper research and avoiding copying others. Madison also mentioned that the publishing team that worked with her had also worked with Crystal, which caught her attention.

She joked that someone reading it might have thought, "That's a bit too similar."

Madison pointed out that Kendra Wilkinson, another Girls Next Door alum, also wrote a memoir about her Playboy Mansion experience. However, she could easily tell that the two books were written by different people.

Madison pointed out that her book and Kendra's book had completely different voices, even though they both lived there at the same time. She emphasized the importance of each person's unique perspective shining through in their writing.

Despite the similarities, Madison appreciated Crystal for sharing her own experiences and validating some of her memories.

"It's always difficult to be the first to share your story, especially when you face criticism for it," she confessed. "When my book was published, [Hugh] was still alive, and it was before the Me Too movement gained widespread attention... The book did well, but I faced backlash. Now, it's a bit easier for others to speak out and share their own stories."

Madison recently revealed to We that Crystal's perception of a rivalry between them during the filming of Girls Next Door was "completely accurate." (Crystal had mentioned in her memoir that a rivalry had developed between her and Madison for the reality show.)

In March, she admitted that the show may have influenced her to say things that upset her from afar. However, she mentioned that she and Crystal have bonded and have a good relationship now. She also acknowledged that Crystal has done other things, so she doesn't solely blame the show for any issues.

Editor's P/S:

Holly Madison's concerns about the similarities between her and Crystal Hefner's memoirs raise questions about the boundaries of inspiration and plagiarism. While it's understandable that two women with similar experiences might share some narrative elements, the alleged similarities in voice and specific phrases suggest a deeper connection. Madison's frustration stems from the fact that Crystal's book was published years after hers, raising suspicions that her writing may have been influenced by Madison's. The fact that the same publishing team worked with both authors further complicates the situation.

Madison's emphasis on the importance of avoiding copying others highlights the ethical considerations involved in writing memoirs. While personal experiences can be a valuable source of material, it's crucial to maintain authenticity and originality. The use of ghostwriters can further blur the lines between authorial voice and outside influence. Madison's experience serves as a reminder that writers must be diligent in their research and ensure that their work is a genuine reflection of their own perspectives.