Critical Choice in Baldur's Gate 3: Unveiling the Ultimate Faction - Karlach or Anders?

In Baldur's Gate 3, player choice is of utmost importance. However, even when players try to align themselves with either good or evil, there are instances where they unintentionally aid the opposing side due to a lack of complete information. Alongside a river, there is an injured Tiefling named Karlach, sporting just one horn. Karlach insists that cultists are after her, seeking to return her to the literal hell she managed to escape from.

As the story evolves, it becomes clear that the so-called "cultists" are actually the Pladains of Tyr, led by Anders. Although they acknowledge their pursuit of an escapee from Avernus, they also reveal that Karlach is responsible for the murder of an entire family. In Baldur's Gate 3, uncovering the truth becomes a challenging task, and players must engage in some detective work to ascertain who is truly telling the truth.

Should You Side With Karlach Or Anders?

Serious gamers engrossed in role-playing adventures are advised to pause their perusal at this point. This article will shed light on the ramifications hidden within the virtual realm, as well as expose crucial information that eludes the grasp of the player's character. Those committed to the immersive experience may choose to abstain from further reading and personally unveil these discoveries.

Good and neutral-aligned players should side with Karlach

Evil players should align themselves with Anders.

The Paladins of Tyr are, in reality, loyal followers of the archdemon Zariel. If players utilize the Speak With Dead spell (by changing party members to someone who possesses it), they will uncover this vital information from the deceased. Despite admitting to this deceit when confronted, Anders will persist in trying to convince the player to aid them.

Karlach is an enigmatic figure, openly admitting her escape from Avernus and expressing a strong desire to avoid recapture. Most players will empathize with her situation and assist her in confronting the cultists. However, discussions with friends during gameplay can help determine the group's course of action. In an evil campaign, gamers may find satisfaction in aiding an archdevil and eliminating an innocent Tiefling.

Baldur's Gate 3 is currently in Early Access on PC, with a full release scheduled for August 3rd, 2023. The PlayStation 5 version will be available on September 6th, 2023, while development for the Xbox Series X/S version is still ongoing.