Could 'But Daddy I Love Him' Be Taylor Swift's Most Heart-Wrenching Song Yet?

New Theories Suggests But Daddy I Love Him Might Be Taylor Swift s Most Gut Wrenching Song

Kevin Mazur/Getty Images for TAS Rights Management

Taylor Swift is famous for her heart-wrenching ballads, and fans believe she has outdone herself with a new song on her upcoming album, The Tortured Poets Department.

The sixth track on the album, titled "But Daddy I Love Him," is the longest at five minutes and 40 seconds. It is followed by the title track, which is four minutes and 53 seconds long.

Swift's song "But Daddy I Love Him" crosses the five-minute mark, placing it among her top five longest songs. This includes "All Too Well" from Red (Taylor's Version), with two versions clocking in at five minutes and 29 seconds or 10 minutes and 13 seconds. Additionally, "Dear John" runs for six minutes and 45 seconds, "Last Kiss" for six minutes and eight seconds, and "Enchanted" for five minutes and 53 seconds, all from her 2010 album Speak Now.

Except for "Enchanted," which is a sweet love song about falling in love at first sight, Swift's lengthiest tracks delve into detailed accounts of relationships that have either failed or are on the brink of failing.

Swift often includes references to her father in her more emotional tracks. In songs like "All Too Well (10 Minute Version)" and "Picture To Burn," she reflects on her relationship with her dad. In the former, she sings about her father charming her ex with jokes, while in the latter, she warns of her dad's protective nature.

In the song "But Daddy I Love Him," the title itself directly mentions her father. This track is believed to be a part of an album inspired by her breakup with Joe Alwyn, making it a particularly heart-wrenching listen for fans.

Taylor Swift is known for including some of her most emotionally powerful ballads as track five on her albums. This is where you can find heartbreaking songs like "All to Well" and "Dear John". Other notable track fives include "You're on You're Own Kid" from Midnights, "My Tears Ricochet" from Folklore, and "Cold As You" from her debut album.

New Theories Suggests But Daddy I Love Him Might Be Taylor Swift s Most Gut Wrenching Song

"But Daddy I Love Him" is the sixth track on Tortured Poets. Some fans believe that the singer might be preparing them for a surprise, especially since the fifth track is called "So Long, London." During her relationship with Alwyn, 32, Swift spent a lot of time in the U.K. to be closer to him. However, since their breakup in April 2023, Swift has returned to her roots in New York City and has been seen spending time in Los Angeles with her current boyfriend, Travis Kelce.

"Goodbye, London" could have a hidden meaning. It wouldn't be the first time for the Grammy-winner to hint at both her return to the US and the end of her relationship with Alwyn. Regardless of the subject, Swift has made it clear that her fifth tracks will always hit fans hard, giving credit to them.

Swift revealed during a July 2019 Instagram Live, "Track five has become a tradition that started with you guys. I didn't plan it, but I noticed that I always ended up putting a vulnerable, personal, honest, emotional song as the fifth track on my albums."

She explained that she began noticing a trend in her music where the most honest, emotional, vulnerable, and personal songs were consistently placed as track five on her albums. This observation led her to intentionally choose track five on her album Lover to reflect these qualities.

This pattern continued with Reputation featuring “Delicate” and Midnights’ “YOYOK.” With the release of TTPD on April 19, track six may also hold significance for fans. Swift has hinted that the entire album may be emotionally impactful, as she has revealed only a few details about the inspiration behind it.

At a February Eras Tour show in Melbourne, Australia, she shared with the audience how important it was for her to create the album. She expressed that songwriting is like a lifeline for her, helping her navigate through life's challenges. She emphasized that on Tortured Poets, she felt the need for songwriting more than ever before.

The Tortured Poets Department is set to be released on Friday, April 19.

Editor's P/S:

Taylor Swift's upcoming album, The Tortured Poets Department, promises to deliver an emotional rollercoaster with its heartfelt ballads. The album's sixth track, "But Daddy I Love Him," stands out as a particularly poignant piece, with its extended runtime and focus on a failed relationship, possibly inspired by Swift's breakup with Joe Alwyn. The song's title directly references her father, a theme Swift has explored in other emotional tracks.

Swift has a history of placing some of her most vulnerable songs as track five on her albums, a tradition that has continued with "But Daddy I Love Him" as track six. This placement suggests that the song carries significant emotional weight and will likely resonate deeply with fans. Swift's ability to craft heartrending ballads is a testament to her songwriting prowess and her ability to connect with listeners on a deeply personal level. The Tortured Poets Department is shaping up to be a powerful collection that showcases the singer's raw talent and emotional vulnerability.