10 Potential American Idol Judges Who Could Replace Katy Perry

Katy Perry, one of the judges on American Idol, recently announced that the upcoming season 22 will be her final one on the show. Alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, Katy has been a judge on the popular reality singing competition for seven years, starting in 2018 when ABC revived the show after FOX canceled it in 2016.

During an episode of Jimmy Kimmel Live! on February 12, 2024, Katy revealed that she will be leaving American Idol to pursue other plans. Following in the footsteps of previous judges like Randy Jackson, Paula Abdul, and Simon Cowell, who were part of the original panel, Katy has decided to step down. Throughout the years, the judging panel has seen a variety of celebrities, from Kara DioGuardi to Jennifer Lopez, taking their place at the table.

After Katy's departure, there is speculation about who could potentially replace her on American Idol. Here are ten female celebrities who could be a great fit for the judging panel alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan.

Jennifer Lopez

American Idol Judge - Seasons 10, 11, 13, 14, & 15

Jennifer Lopez on American Idol Smiling - American Idol Judge - Seasons 10, 11, 13, 14, & 15

Jennifer Lopez, a global superstar, was a judge on American Idol starting from season 10. She continued to be a judge for seasons 11, 13, 14, and 15. Throughout her time on the show, she played a vital role in discovering talented winners like Scotty McCreery, Phillip Phillips, Caleb Johnson, Nick Fradiani, and Trent Harmon. She also helped launch the careers of runner-up Lauren Alaina, as well as finalists Haley Reinhart and Pia Toscano. Jennifer's unique ability to provide both praise and constructive criticism made her a standout judge. With her kindness, encouragement, and creativity, she would be a great replacement for Katy on the judging panel.

Dolly Parton

American Idol Mentor - Season 7

Dolly Parton and David Archuleta On American Idol Mentoring Session - American Idol Mentor - Season 7

During season 7 of American Idol, Dolly Parton took on the role of a mentor for the contestants. She worked closely with winner David Cook and runner-up David Archuleta, offering guidance and support. Despite her involvement, Dolly made it clear that she did not feel comfortable judging their performances. In an interview with Taste of Country, she explained that she struggles with critiquing others and always declines offers to be a judge on the show. Dolly expressed, "I really have trouble judging people. I would have a lot of trouble telling them yes or no - especially no."

Taylor Swift

Taylor Swift, like Dolly Parton, would be a perfect fit for the judging panel on American Idol. In this era of kindness and encouragement, Taylor's positive and supportive feedback would make her a valuable addition to the show. With her years of experience in the music industry and her exceptional songwriting skills, Taylor would bring a unique perspective to the judging table.

The Voice Knockout Round Advisor - Seasons 7 and 17

Taylor Swift On The Voice With Arms Raised - The Voice Knockout Round Advisor - Seasons 7 and 17

Beyoncé

Superstar singer Beyoncé has not been a mentor or guest judge on American Idol, but she did provide guidance as a Knockout Round advisor on The Voice. Beyoncé is a highly talented and beloved artist with fans of all ages. Rising to fame at a young age, she can offer valuable insight to aspiring American Idol contestants. Beyoncé would be a fantastic choice for the judging panel.

American Idol Mentor - Season 10

Beyonce Mentoring Haley Reinhart on American Idol In Front Of A Piano - American Idol Mentor - Season 10 - Beyoncé

Katharine McPhee & David Foster

Singer and actress Katharine McPhee was a guest mentor on American Idol season 17. She shared her musical knowledge and experience with the contestants, offering guidance and support. Katharine's presence brought a new perspective to the competition, and her insights were invaluable to the aspiring singers. David Foster, a renowned music producer, also appeared as a mentor on the show. His expertise and advice helped the contestants refine their performances and elevate their skills. Together, Katharine McPhee and David Foster played a crucial role in shaping the next generation of music stars on American Idol.

Katharine Was The American Idol Season 5 Runner-Up; David Served As A Mentor During That Same Season

David Foster and Katharine McPhee Posing Together - Katharine Was The American Idol Season 5 Runner-Up; David Served As A Mentor During That Same Season - Katharine McPhee & David Foster

Katharine McPhee and David Foster first met when Katharine was a contestant on American Idol season 5 and David was a mentor. Their love story began later on. Katharine is known for her powerful singing and acting skills, while David is a renowned record producer, composer, and music executive. Both of them shine on their own and together, bringing a special spark to any judging panel.

Katharine and David not only have incredible talent but also a magnetic presence on stage. They entertained fans with their humor and musical abilities on "The Kat and Dave Show" on Instagram Live during the pandemic. Their advice to singers is top-notch, as seen in David's mentoring of Katharine on American Idol and Katharine's duets with contestants on later seasons. They are true stars who also know how to let others shine, making them ideal American Idol judges.

Miley Cyrus

American Idol Mentor - Season 9

Miley Cyrus On American Idol Singing - American Idol Mentor - Season 9

Miley was a mentor on American Idol season 9 at just 17 years old. She gave great advice to contestants, a role she continued on The Voice seasons 11 and 13. Starting her career young, she relates to American Idol contestants. Like Katy, Miley is bold and boundary-pushing, with a mission to include everyone. Her vibrant personality and energy would seamlessly continue Katy's legacy.

Jordin Sparks

American Idol Winner - Season 6 & Mentor - Season 21

Twitter article posted by Jordin Sparks

Jordin Sparks, the winner of American Idol season 6, expressed her interest in becoming a judge on the show in a post on February 16. She mentioned that there is an open seat at the judges' table and said, "I’m putting my name in the hat!" Jordin is not only a talented singer and actress but also holds the title of the youngest winner ever at 17 years old. Her experience and success make her an ideal candidate for the judging panel.

Lady Gaga has also shown that she has what it takes to succeed in the music industry. She has a strong track record of success and would bring valuable experience to the judging panel. Lady Gaga's unique perspective and creative insights would make her a great addition to the team.

American Idol Mentor - Season 10

Lady Gaga With the American Idol Season 10 Contestants As a Mentor - American Idol Mentor - Season 10

Paula Abdul is not only a renowned singer but also a talented dancer and choreographer. She was a judge on American Idol for eight seasons, bringing her unique perspective and expertise to the show. Paula's feedback was always constructive and encouraging, helping contestants to grow and improve. Her positive energy and warm personality made her a fan favorite and a beloved mentor to many aspiring artists. Paula Abdul would be a fantastic addition to the American Idol judging panel.

American Idol Judge - Seasons 1-8

Paula Abdul as a judge on American Idol - American Idol Judge - Seasons 1-8

Paula Abdul, an original American Idol judge, singer, and dancer, was known for her kind and considerate judging style on the show. While Simon Cowell and Randy Jackson provided tough feedback, Paula always kept the contestants' feelings in mind when giving her commentary. She played a crucial role in the show's success, helping to discover talented singers like Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood, and Adam Lambert, among others.

Similar to Paula, Katy Perry also serves as a supportive cheerleader for the contestants on American Idol, offering constructive criticism when necessary. Both judges provide a nurturing and maternal approach to supporting the singers on the show. Paula's potential return to American Idol could reignite the show's former glory and remind viewers of its significant influence in the music industry.

Just Sam

American Idol Winner - Season 18

Just Sam on American Idol Smiling and Holding a Microphone - American Idol Winner - Season 18

Just Sam, also known as Samantha Diaz, emerged as the winner of American Idol season 18 in 2020. However, their journey post-show was challenging, leading them back to performing in the New York City subways where they first began showcasing their talent. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, Just Sam missed out on the typical opportunities that past winners had. By bringing their unique perspective as a former contestant to the judging panel, American Idol could also rectify the lack of support and promotion they received by offering them a second chance to shine on the show.

Although filling Katy's shoes may be a tough task, there are ten singers who could be great replacements for her. These talented individuals have the skills and background to support aspiring singers in reaching new heights. Their past experiences on American Idol have shown that they have the ability to guide and nurture new talents. With their compatibility with Lionel and Luke, they could seamlessly step into Katy's role on the judging panel. While Katy will be missed, there are plenty of amazing candidates who could take her place on American Idol.

Don't forget to catch American Idol season 22 airing Sundays at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.

Sources: Taste of Country, Jordin Sparks/X

Editor's P/S:

The article provides a comprehensive overview of potential female celebrities who could replace Katy Perry as a judge on American Idol following her departure. Each candidate is presented with their relevant experience and qualifications, highlighting their suitability for the role. The author also acknowledges the legacy of past judges and the impact they have had on the show.

Overall, the article offers a well-rounded analysis of the potential replacements for Katy Perry, considering their individual strengths and contributions to the music industry. The inclusion of quotes and information from reliable sources adds credibility to the article.