Why Supernatural Season 16 Must Retcon a Major Plot Twist from the Show's Ending

With the possibility of Supernatural returning for a sixteenth season, fans are curious about how the show will continue after its definitive ending. Many are wondering what aspects of the finale will need to be adjusted for a new season to make sense. The series wrapped up in November 2020 after an impressive fifteen seasons, leaving some viewers satisfied with its conclusion while others were disappointed with the fate of the Winchester brothers. When Jared Padalecki hinted at potential new Supernatural adventures during the 2023 Creation Honolulu convention, excitement among fans grew.

However, bringing back Supernatural for season 16 presents challenges. The original series finale was quite conclusive, with Dean Winchester sacrificing himself during a vampire hunt after defeating God. Sam, mourning his brother's death, eventually moves on to start his own family before passing away of old age and reuniting with Dean in Heaven. Additionally, the show's extensive and intricate lore will need to be reworked in order to continue the storyline. Some previously resolved questions may need to be revisited and adjusted to fit the new narrative.

Padalecki shared his thoughts at the convention, expressing, "I have some ideas, and I hope that now that the writers are back, and the actors are back, that we all get together."

Supernatural Season 16 Would Need To Retcon Jack Becoming God

Jack looking confused in Supernatural.  - Supernatural Season 16 Would Need To Retcon Jack Becoming God

In the finale of Supernatural season 15, Jack becomes the new God after absorbing all of Chuck's powers. Chuck, also known as God, was defeated by Jack with the help of Michael and Lucifer in the penultimate episode. Despite the sadness of leaving Sam and Dean behind, Jack's new role as God was necessary for the well-being of the universe.

If Supernatural wants to continue, Jack will need to be removed as God. This is necessary because Sam and Dean should not have the power of God on their side while they resume hunting. Even though Jack can't be as close to them as before, he could still use his powers to assist the Winchesters, which wouldn't be fair.

In order for Supernatural to remain captivating, the brothers must confront cosmic challenges, and having Jack supporting them would make things too effortless.

How Supernatural Could Remove Jack As The New God

Sam and Dean Winchester in Supernatural finale - How Supernatural Could Remove Jack As The New God

There are many ways in which Supernatural could remove Jack as God. One possible approach is to introduce a major event that alters the course of the show. For example, some fans have suggested that Supernatural season 16 could take place in a brand new universe, where key events like Dean's death and Jack's ascension never occurred. This fresh setting could open up new possibilities for the storyline.

Another option for Supernatural season 16 is to explore Jack's decision to relinquish his godly powers. Perhaps Jack finds the responsibilities too overwhelming and decides to walk away from his divine status. Alternatively, the show could delve into the idea that God's powers have transformed Jack into a different being altogether, making him less susceptible to the influence of the Winchesters.

Lastly, Supernatural could introduce a formidable rival for Jack in season 16. This new powerful entity could challenge Jack for his position as God, creating a sense of urgency and danger for the Winchesters and the world. By shaking up the status quo in these ways, the show can keep viewers on the edge of their seats and explore fresh dynamics within the Supernatural universe.

The Winchesters Already Proved How Useful Jack Would Be

Jensen Ackles as Dean in The Winchesters - The Winchesters Already Proved How Useful Jack Would Be

The Supernatural franchise has already shown why Jack needs to be removed from his role. In Supernatural season 16, it may seem like Jack has no interest in helping the Winchesters, but it's hard to believe. During The Winchesters, Jack assists Dean in bending the rules of the universe. This shows that Jack not only can, but will help the Winchesters on their personal quests. Therefore, his powers must be taken away for Supernatural to continue.

Jack's godly status is just one of the obstacles the Supernatural team needs to overcome to revive the show. Whether season 16 is a brief look back or a mini-series, there are logistical problems that need to be addressed. Supernatural season 16 must resolve these issues before it can live up to the expectations of fans.

Editor's P/S:

This article delves into the complexities of potentially continuing "Supernatural" beyond its definitive ending. It highlights the challenges of reconciling the conclusive finale with a new season, particularly regarding the fate of Dean Winchester and the intricate lore established over 15 seasons. While fans are eager for more adventures with the Winchester brothers, the article raises valid concerns about the need to rework the storyline and address unresolved questions.

It explores various options for removing Jack as God, such as creating a new universe, exploring Jack's decision to relinquish his powers, or introducing a formidable rival. The article concludes that Jack's godly status is an obstacle that must be overcome to maintain the show's captivating nature. Overall, the article provides a thoughtful analysis of the challenges and considerations involved in bringing "Supernatural" back for another season.