Sauron was undeniably one of the most terrifying beings in The Lord Of The Rings universe. Throughout the trilogy, he was portrayed as an ominous and unbeatable force of evil in Middle Earth. However, some believe that Aragorn would have had a good chance of standing against the dark lord.
While it seems probable that Aragorn could have defeated Sauron in a one-on-one battle, the situation might have changed if Sauron had successfully regained possession of the One Ring. It is impossible to predict the extent of power that the lord of evil could have wielded with control over the ring.
How Powerful Was Sauron With The One Ring?
Even without possessing the One Ring, Sauron was already a formidable force in the history of Middle Earth. His connection to the Ring granted him immortality and the ability to reform his physical form even after repeated destruction. If Sauron had obtained the Ring, his power would have been unrivaled, making him unstoppable. In the final moments of the film trilogy, had he acquired the ring from Frodo at Mount Doom, both Aragorn and Gandalf would have been defeated by his forces. Middle Earth would have been left defenseless, facing total domination at Sauron's command. Only intervention from the higher powers of Middle Earth could have prevented everything from falling under Sauron's control.
Could Aragorn Have Defeated Full-Strength Sauron?
Sauron's existing power and the added might of the One Ring would have elevated him to god-like strength. He could effortlessly manipulate minds and control individuals, eliminating the need for direct confrontation with the realm of Men. However, he might have engaged in battles to instill fear and showcase his dominance. With the One Ring in his possession, only a handful of individuals would have stood a chance against him.Absolutely not, the short answer is no, unless Aragorn experienced extraordinarily good luck like Isildur did. However, it is essential to include a small caveat in case Sauron's power were to return and he became similarly arrogant once again. It is important to acknowledge that Sauron would likely be cautious and less arrogant when facing an opponent like Aragorn, which would severely limit any opportunity for Aragorn to defeat him. In a one-on-one confrontation, Aragorn would have been at the mercy of Sauron, potentially resulting in his death. The situation may have been different if Aragorn had the support of his allies against Sauron, but even in a victorious scenario, the casualties incurred would have been significant.
Could Aragorn Have Beaten Sauron If He Used The One Ring?
It is reasonable to assume that Aragorn's combat skills surpass those of Sauron, especially considering his impressive track record in previous battles. This implies that a fully empowered Sauron would consider Aragorn a significant threat, prompting the dark lord to eliminate him swiftly. Consequently, Aragorn would have no choice but to rely solely on his skill, which could potentially falter if Sauron possesses such immense power that he can dominate Aragorn's mind and will.
It is considerably more challenging to ascertain a definitive answer to this question. The actual response is that it is likely contingent upon the specific circumstances surrounding Aragorn's possession of the One Ring. According to insights gleaned from Tolkien's original works, it appears that Aragorn, within the context of The Lord of the Rings trilogy, would not have been able to overpower Sauron. Even if the events had unfolded differently, there is a possibility that Aragorn could have triumphed over Sauron, albeit with dire consequences akin to Sauron reclaiming the ring himself.
Aragorn's superior fighting skills give him an advantage over a weakened Sauron. Having the ring would enable Aragorn to launch a massive offensive against Sauron's forces, decimating the evil presence and taking the battle to the dark lord himself. However, defeating Sauron would lead to Aragorn's own inevitable downfall as the corrupting influence of the ring would transform him into a lord of darkness.
Without the destruction of the ring, Sauron would have the opportunity to rebuild his power. If Aragorn were to succumb to the ring's corruption, he would eventually become so corrupted that Sauron could manipulate him to deliver the ring into his hands. While Aragorn, wielding the ring, would have the potential to defeat Sauron in certain circumstances, he would ultimately be defeated by the unstoppable evil nature of Sauron.
If this question pertains specifically to Aragorn's ultimate attack on Sauron's forces in The Return Of The King, Aragorn would have unquestionably faced defeat. It's crucial to bear in mind that Aragorn's troops were designed to serve as a final diversion for Sauron. The group never genuinely harbored the belief that they would overcome his armies or even the dark lord himself. The gamble at play was that Sauron might suspect Aragorn of possessing the ring and, naively influenced by it, think that a small force would be formidable enough to challenge Sauron. Aragorn would have suffered defeat without Sauron even needing to engage in battle on the field, and Sauron would have once again risen to power.
Stream The Lord Of The Rings on Amazon Prime Video.