The Ultimate Truth: The Moral Dilemma of Alidoro's Fate

Alidoro, a character in Lies of P, is a secretive treasure hunter who trades special weapons for Boss Ergos. He always wears a dog mask, which obscures his true appearance. Eugenie, who was saved by Alidoro during her childhood, holds a deep admiration for him. Similarly, Hugo the Rookie Explorer idolizes Alidoro and became a treasure hunter because of him.

Throughout the game, players controlling Pinocchio will come across various areas and eventually face a significant choice relating to Alidoro. This decision holds the same level of importance as the Antonia cure decision in Lies of P.

Should You Kill Alidoro In Lies of P?

The correct choice in Lies of P is to kill Alidoro, as he drops Alidoro's Cryptic Vessel, which is essential for completing Eugenie's Side Quest. After Venigni deciphers the vessel, players can communicate with Eugenie, who reveals that Alidoro is actually an imposter, not the real treasure hunter. At this point, Pinocchio can choose to lie, claiming that he believes Alidoro was a skilled stalker, or tell the truth by saying that he was Eugenie's older brother.

Another benefit of eliminating Alidoro in Lies of P is the opportunity to obtain some collectible Records, making it worth completing Eugenie's Side Quest. Records are important items that greatly contribute to Pinocchio's Humanity Meter. Assisting Eugenie will result in players being rewarded with either the Far East Princess Record (Lie) or the Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1 Record (Truth). As Records are crucial for achieving the true/good ending known as the Rise of P, it is necessary to defeat Alidoro in two separate playthroughs in order to acquire both Records in Lies of P.

What Happens If Alidoro Is Spared In Lies of P

If you're uncertain about eliminating Alidoro, the treasure hunter who trades specialized weapons, there's no need to fret. Rest assured, another merchant named Hugo will step into his shoes at Hotel Krat in Lies of P.

Keeping Alidoro alive in Lies of P will have no significant impact, except for the loss of two crucial Records. Moreover, the completion of Eugenie's Side Quest will be impossible, resulting in the inability to unlock an Achievement and acquire extra Humanity Points.

The individual posing as Alidoro is not the real adventurer, but rather his sidekick. In a tragic turn of events, the sidekick ended up killing the genuine treasure hunter following a heated argument. Seizing the opportunity, the impostor acquired the iconic dog mask and assumed the identity of Alidoro. Eventually, players can come across this imposter within the remarkable confines of St. Frangelico Cathedral and extend an invitation to the Hotel Krat. Remaining incognito for a period of time, the fake Alidoro subsequently relocates to the treacherous Barren Swamp, where a boss resides, in an attempt to claim a valuable treasure. As the imposter disables the security system of the hotel, it grants the nefarious Black Rabbit Brotherhood unrestricted access into the premises of Hotel Krat in the fervently deceiving game, Lies of P, leading to the unfortunate abduction of Geppetto.

Lies of P

Platform(s) PC, PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X, Xbox Series S, Xbox OneReleased September 19, 2023Developer(s) Round8 Studio, Neowiz