The Top Horror Films of 2023 (Thus Far)

1. 'The Pale Blue Eye'

The year 2023 has been a truly remarkable one for horror, offering a wide range of eclectic, bizarre, gruesome, and simply amazing films. From Allison WIlliams escaping the clutches of Lena Dunham only to face the terrifying presence of a lifelike evil AI doll in M3GAN, to Mia Goth returning to her usual maniacal form in Infinity Pool, which made its debut at the Sundance Film Festival. Streaming platforms also surprised audiences with unexpected hits, particularly Shudder's Skinamarink, which took everyone back to their childhood nightmares. Among the most highly anticipated releases was Scream VI, as it bid farewell to Woodsboro and Sidney Prescott, bringing the terror to the vibrant streets of New York City. Additionally, we cannot overlook the outstanding and terrifying directorial debut from Down Under, Talk to Me, directed by Danny Philippou and Michael Philippou. Although we would love to proclaim that horror is making a triumphant comeback, the past few years have already demonstrated a thriving and diverse landscape for the genre, and this year continues that trend. Without further ado, here are the best horror movies of 2023, thus far.

Few names in the realm of horror fiction are held in higher regard than that of Edgar Allen Poe. However, The Pale Blue Eye goes beyond the ordinary adaptation of one of his most renowned works. In this bone-chilling murder mystery, directed by Scott Cooper, Poe (portrayed by Harry Melling) assumes the role of a supporting character. The plot revolves around the perplexing deaths of numerous cadets at the United States Military Academy in West Point, New York. Reuniting with Christian Bale, whom he previously collaborated with in Hostiles (2017), Cooper showcases Bale's exceptional talent in a restrained yet captivating performance as the weathered detective, Augustus Landor. Initially presenting itself as a straightforward investigative thriller, The Pale Blue Eye gradually introduces elements of gothic horror as the murders become increasingly grisly. Though it may not rely heavily on jump scares, its shocking conclusion encompasses a genuine sense of horror that will linger long after the final credits roll.

Watch The Pale Blue Eye on Netflix, a psychologically chilling film that delves into themes of revenge and obsession. This biographical fiction piece explores the traumatic events that influenced Poe and shaped his worldview. Melling's unique and nuanced performance as the reclusive author is a perfect fit. Cooper's superb production design effectively captures the eerie atmosphere of a frosty 19th-century military academy. The film's woodland environments are ideal for exploring mankind's primal instincts. Unapologetically brutal, it never sensationalizes the violence, adding to its disturbing nature. With standout performances from Lucy Boynton and Harry Lawtey, The Pale Blue Eye is a must-watch winter-bound horror favorite and a standout among Netflix originals.

2. 'M3GAN'

In the realm of horror, killer dolls have been a recurring theme for decades. We have iconic examples like Chucky and Annabelle. However, it is not easy to introduce a similar antagonist without it being seen as a mere imitation. M3GAN manages to set itself apart by introducing a completely original character. M3GAN, portrayed by Amie Donald and Jenna Davis, is an eerily lifelike A.I. doll designed to mimic human speech and movement. Originally programmed to be a companion for a newly orphaned child, M3GAN's dedication turns sinister as she becomes dangerously overprotective, resorting to murder. The performances of Allison Williams and young Violent McGraw as the aunt and niece attempting to thwart M3GAN's homicidal tendencies are commendable. This film strikes a balance between horror and humor, and although its blood-soaked climax is somewhat constrained by its PG-13 rating, it features a chillingly unique dance sequence that went viral even before the movie's release. One must wonder if Annabelle could achieve such notoriety. - Shawn Van Horn

Watch on Prime Video

3. 'Skinamarink'

From its unsettling opening to its chilling conclusion, Kyle Edward Ball's debut feature "Skinamarink" is a modern masterpiece of horror. This film tells the story of two siblings trapped in their home, with all the windows and doors mysteriously disappearing. What sets it apart is its precise execution, creating an atmosphere unlike any other. It proves to be a restrained yet captivating horror experience, where the unseen is just as terrifying as the visible. Set entirely within this singular location, which seems detached from time and space, the film immerses you in a darkness that threatens to consume. As voices echo through the house and figures materialize out of thin air, it lures you into a hypnotic and unsettling rhythm. "Skinamarink" may not appeal to everyone, but for those willing to take the plunge, it's a rewarding journey. Brace yourself by turning off all lights and wearing headphones, fully embracing the evocative vision that awaits. - Chase Hutchinson

Watch on Shudder

4. 'Infinity Pool'

Image via NEON

Looking for a vacation experience that takes you away from the ordinary? Brandon Cronenberg's Infinity Pool offers a unique getaway for those with more unconventional tastes. This darkly delightful film explores the twisted desires of its depraved characters, who indulge in acts of violence and witness their clones being executed in their place. It's a macabre journey that reveals the unsettling power of wealth and privilege, with a touch of bleak humor woven throughout. Mia Goth delivers a stunningly unhinged performance in standout sequences, highlighting the film's compelling narrative. Not only does Infinity Pool stand out among the fantastic lineup of midnight films at Sundance, but it also leaves a lasting impression with its beautifully grim ending, serving as a haunting souvenir in your mind. - Chase Hutchinson

Watch on Hulu

5. 'Huesera: The Bone Woman'

Image via XYZ Films

Huesera: The Bone Woman delves into the complexities of motherhood, embracing both its joys and hardships in an unfiltered (and sometimes brutal) manner. Michelle Garza Cervera's directorial debut is a testament to her ambition, and anyone brave enough to experience this Spanish-language horror tale will encounter profound insights into familial expectations, economic struggles in Latin countries, and the existential struggle for female autonomy in a patriarchal society. Natalia Solián delivers a captivating performance as the lead, leaving viewers shocked and perhaps disturbed by the harsh realities that await women who defy societal norms and don't conform to conventional housewife roles. This is precisely what makes horror films so impactful – they shine a light on the shadowy recesses of the human psyche and compel us to confront the traumas we suppress on a daily basis. A screening of Huesera guarantees an emotionally charged reaction, not only due to the technical brilliance of Cervera's debut, but also because of the uncomfortable themes she fearlessly exposes. Coupled with elements of visceral body horror, this film stands as one of the standout movies of 2023. – Marco Vito Oddo

Watch on AMC+

6. 'Knock at the Cabin'

Watch Knock at the Cabin on Prime Video, M. Night Shyamalan's finest film in years, adapted from Paul Tremblay's renowned book, The Cabin at the End of the World. This gripping thriller initially portrays a typical home invasion but takes a surprising turn when the intruders disclose a life-or-death ultimatum to the family. Tremendous suspense ensues as the family fights to defend themselves, leaving the audience pondering the truth behind the villains' intentions. The film culminates in a powerful and emotional climax. Notably, Dave Bautista delivers a standout performance, proving his versatility as a leading man.

7. 'The Outwaters'

The Outwaters is a unique twist on the found footage genre that we can't help but be intrigued by. While it does take some time to build up to the thrilling and terrifying descent into madness, the payoff is definitely worth it. The story follows a group of friends who venture into the desert to film a music video. However, they soon realize that something is terribly wrong. Mysterious sounds emanate from within the Earth and they encounter a strangely familiar figure. Before they can make sense of the situation, their world is turned upside down by a cycle of violence that feels detached from reality. The less you know about it, the more enjoyable the experience, as it leads to a conclusion that will leave you crushed. - Chase Hutchinson.

Stream now on Roku Channel.

8. 'Scream VI'

Image Via Paramount Pictures

Scream VI, released in 2022, exceeded expectations and proved to be a significant step forward for filmmakers Tyler Gillett and Matt Bettinelli-Olpin. While their previous film served as a solid introduction to the iconic horror franchise created by Wes Craven, Scream VI showcases their full creative vision. This installment adds a metatextual commentary on "legacy sequels" while delving deep into the themes of victimization and the public's perception of tragedies. It is worth noting that Scream VI is the most violent and intense film in the series thus far, holding viewers in suspense for its entire two-hour duration as it unravels its mystery seamlessly.

Despite the strong connection 2022's Scream had with the original characters, the absence of Neve Campbell in Scream VI does not diminish its impact. Melissa Barrera and Jenna Ortega prove themselves to be the defining final girls of this generation, even as they grapple with the ghosts of the franchise's past. Audiences are treated to the immensely satisfying return of Hayden Panittere to the series, and Courteney Cox delivers one of her strongest performances to date, portraying a character who has withstood significant trauma. This installment takes a darker turn, exploring themes of college campus safety, conspiracy theories, toxic masculinity, and society's obsession with violence. The relevance of these themes in Scream VI feels particularly timely, highlighting the franchise's ongoing impact on popular culture. Overall, Scream VI is a continuation that honors Craven's legacy and stands as the best installment since Scream 2.

9. 'Evil Dead Rise'

Image via Warner Bros.

The Evil Dead franchise made its long-awaited return to theaters with Evil Dead Rise, written and directed by Lee Cronin (The Hole in the Ground). This film combines the brutal intensity of Fede Álvarez's semi-remake with the comically violent style of Sam Raimi's original trilogy. Evil Dead Rise successfully captures the attention of the audience by skillfully balancing moments of humor with deeply disturbing scenes. Alyssa Sutherland's portrayal of Mommy Deadite, one of the franchise's most terrifying creatures, steals every scene she appears in. Her performance, filled with profanities and child torture, showcases her talent at its finest. Cronin's take on the Evil Dead franchise fearlessly extends its reach, sparing none of the young cast from the massacre inflicted by the Deadites. By the end of the movie, all characters are immersed in blood. Aside from the captivating storyline, Evil Dead Rise impresses with its use of practical effects, creating gruesome scenes that will send shivers down your spine. - Marco Vito Oddo

Stream on Max

10. 'The Boogeyman'

Rob Savage, the filmmaker behind the breakout hit Host (which, unlike his follow-up Dashcam, still holds up), delivers another chilling masterpiece with his latest horror film, The Boogeyman. Based on Stephen King's renowned short story, this adaptation is a truly terrifying experience. The story revolves around Sadie Harper (played by Sophie Thatcher from Yellowjackets), who must cope with the recent loss of her mother while dealing with an unwelcome houseguest that seems to have taken over her home. The film excels in evoking our fear of the unknown entity that haunts the characters, particularly in the scenes where the flashing lights give us glimpses of the impending horror. The strategic use of sound, often imitating familiar voices, enhances the unease that lingers long after the film ends. Though the ending may dilute the impact of the film's technical brilliance by leaning towards spectacle and excessive revelations, the central tension remains potent, delving into the depths of darkness where something sinister lurks. Prepare yourself for the bone-chilling experience when The Boogeyman hits theaters on Friday, June 2nd. - Chase Hutchinson

Watch on Hulu

11. 'Talk to Me'

Image taken from A24

Talk to Me is a remarkable film that defies the boundaries of human imagination. The narrative centers around a cursed hand that enables individuals to communicate with wandering spirits, allowing them to temporarily possess a living body and unveil secrets from beyond the grave. For a group of teenagers, this means engaging in perilous games to add excitement to their gatherings. Despite the abundance of horror movies exploring possession and the mysteries of the afterlife, Talk to Me offers a fresh perspective on this theme. What sets this film apart is not only its innovative approach, but also its technical brilliance. The skillful direction masterfully blends spine-chilling moments with the reckless thrill-seeking of adolescents eager to push their limits.

The young cast, led by Sophie Wilde's phenomenal performance, brings joy as they have fun with the occult. However, they soon realize the gruesome consequences of their actions, which are made more intense by impressive practical effects. Talk to Me effectively explores themes of trauma and the bond of found family in a relatable manner, while still providing an entertaining horror experience. It's hard to believe that Talk to Me is the directorial debut of Danny Philippou and Michael Philippou, as it stands as one of the top movies of the year, in the horror genre and beyond. - Marco Vito Oddo

Available for rent on Prime Video.

12. 'Birth/Rebirth'

Image via Shudder

Birth/Rebirth, a reimagining of Frankenstein, captivates audiences with its powerful performances. Written and directed by Laura Moss, this delightfully dark and grimly humorous experience takes place almost entirely within the confines of a single apartment, yet manages to evoke a sense of vastness that sneaks up on you. At its heart is Celie (played by Judy Reyes), a compassionate maternity nurse who works long hours and single-handedly cares for her daughter Lila (A.J. Lister). In the same hospital, but in a world of isolation, lives Rose (Marin Ireland), a pathologist with a morbid fascination with death.

Tragedy brings these two lives together, offering a potential second chance at life. However, as is often the case, this opportunity comes with a heavy price, explored with a striking and evocative brutality in this body horror narrative. Both Reyes and Ireland deliver spectacular performances, never overplaying their characters as they navigate the increasingly fragile consequences of an act of reanimation. While not as lighthearted as "Reanimator," this film exudes a similar passion for its story, injecting it with bold bleakness. It culminates in a powerful final statement that expertly ties together its bloody narrative.

Rent on Apple TV

13. 'El Conde'

Image via Netflix

Pablo Larraín's El Conde is a vampire satire that defies expectations with its bloody and visceral portrayal. Premiering at the Venice Film Festival, the film reimagines Augusto Pinochet, the murderous dictator, as a pitiful vampire longing for death, while his descendants gather to claim their stolen wealth. This unique horror film is a blend of chilling tension and dark humor, punctuated by moments of terrifying violence. It skillfully navigates the fine line between grim absurdity and breathtaking beauty, with stunning black-and-white shots that contrast with painful realities on the ground. While it demands patience, the film rewards viewers with deadpan wit and a surprising revelation involving another historical figure. Ultimately, El Conde highlights the recurring threat of fascism, emphasizing the need to repeatedly vanquish it to safeguard the world. - Chase Hutchinson

14. 'When Evil Lurks'

Image via IFC

A delightfully malevolent journey into the depths of horror, Demian Rugna's When Evil Lurks is an incessantly eerie film like no other you'll encounter this year. Unveiled at this year's Toronto International Film Festival, it not only stands as one of the most wicked possession films ever made, but also a shockingly gruesome piece that will leave indelible imprints on your mind, regardless of your attempts to shake them off. What starts off as a tale of two brothers stumbling upon a possessed man near their farm transforms into a harrowing escape from terror when they make the disastrously ill-fated choice to release chaos into their world. Embarking on a perilous journey to rescue their loved ones from the impending catastrophe, every pit stop they make only ushers in more death and destruction, threatening to consume everything they hold dear. Brace yourself, as no one is safe from the impending carnage. - Chase Hutchinson

Watch on Shudder

Editor's P/S

As a horror enthusiast, I am thrilled to see the genre continue to thrive in 2023. The Pale Blue Eye and M3GAN are prime examples of the diverse and innovative films that are pushing the boundaries of the genre.

The Pale Blue Eye's unique take on the Edgar Allan Poe story is a testament to the enduring power of classic horror literature. The film's atmospheric setting, strong performances, and clever storytelling make it a standout in the genre. M3GAN, on the other hand, brings a fresh and terrifying perspective to the killer doll trope. The film's clever use of technology and the unnerving performance by Amie Donald as M3GAN make it a truly memorable horror experience.

Overall, I am excited to see what else the horror genre has in store for us in 2023. With such a strong start, it's sure to be a year filled with scares and thrills.