The Ultimate Guide to the Top 15 Horror Movies, Voted by Letterboxd Users

Letterboxd offers a valuable platform for discovering new movies and exploring the recommendations of its users. While similar to the popular IMDb, Letterboxd stands out for its personalized and social approach. A comparison of both platforms reveals that the tastes of Letterboxd users differ from those of IMDb users.

In terms of horror movies, Letterboxd users have an eclectic selection of top-rated films. This includes a mix of both well-known and lesser-known titles, spanning various eras and even featuring non-English language films. For any horror enthusiast, the following films are considered essential viewing and are ranked below based on their average ratings on Letterboxd.

Updated October 24, 2023, by Jeremy Urquhart

When it comes to rankings of horror movies, a top 10 list is certainly superior to a mere top 5. However, why settle for just 10 when you can have an even more comprehensive top 15? That's precisely what you'll find below, and it's especially fitting because horror tends to reign supreme during the end of the year. According to Letterboxd, these films are regarded as the ultimate horror classics and are a must-watch for any avid genre enthusiast.

15. 'Black Swan' (2010)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.1/5

Image via Searchlight Pictures

Combining elements of psychological thriller and horror, Black Swan effectively delves into the perils of fixating on one's artistic pursuit. The film chronicles the journey of a ballerina who relentlessly pursues flawlessness, becoming alarmingly consumed by her portrayal in the ballet company's rendition of Swan Lake.

14. Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me (1992)

Darren Aronofsky is known for his penchant for creating thought-provoking and challenging films, often exploring the depths of troubled and tormented minds. His film "Black Swan" is no exception, as it delves deep into the psyche of its characters. Natalie Portman's remarkable performance in the lead role is pivotal in making the film so impactful, and it rightfully earned her an Academy Award for Best Actress.

Letterboxd Rating: 4.1/5

Image via Pathé

Twin Peaks, considered one of the greatest TV series, unfortunately faced cancellation during its second season and had been adversely affected by interference from executives and the network. However, David Lynch had the opportunity to continue the storyline in his own unique manner with Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me. This film serves as both a prequel and a sequel to the original show.

Fire Walk with Me delves into the events leading up to Laura Palmer's murder, showcasing a haunting and tragic narrative that is truly unsettling. It goes beyond the confines of a typical horror movie, incorporating various genres much like the TV series. As a result, it becomes even more unpredictable and nightmarish.

13. 'Aliens' (1986)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.2/5

Image via 20th Century Studios

James Cameron's takeover of the iconic horror series resulted in the creation of one of the greatest sequels of all time. With a more action-focused approach compared to its 1979 predecessor, Aliens may be less easily categorized as a horror movie. However, it successfully maintains high levels of tension and offers numerous terrifying sequences.

While those seeking pure horror may experience some disappointment, Aliens remains a must-watch for enthusiasts of both action and horror genres intersecting. This film encompasses all the elements fans desire in a large-scale horror/thriller/action movie, including an increasingly intense and chaotic narrative, complemented by Sigourney Weaver's outstanding lead performance.

Watch on Starz

12. 'Diabolique' (1955)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.2/5

Describing Diabolique is a challenging task as it encompasses various exceptional qualities. This gothic horror masterpiece stands out as one of the finest French-language films ever made, especially considering its release in the 1950s. Its enigmatic and haunting nature, combined with a captivating atmosphere, ensures its enduring appeal even among modern horror movies from the same era.

Given its emphasis on psychological thrills and terror, it may be advisable to reveal as few details about the plot as possible. In essence, Diabolique revolves around a murder and the ensuing madness triggered by the inexplicable disappearance of the assumed deceased. The film's surreal essence skillfully immerses viewers into the progressively tormented minds of its central characters, guaranteeing an unsettling and appropriately eerie viewing experience that lingers long after it is seen.

11. 'Get Out' (2017)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.2/5

Get Out, an expertly crafted horror/thriller film, offers a powerful blend of social commentary. It firmly ranks among the top horror movies of the 21st century thus far. The story revolves around a young Black man who finds himself in an initially uncomfortable situation when meeting his white girlfriend's parents. However, as the plot unfolds, it evolves into a genuinely terrifying and potentially life-threatening ordeal.

Upon its release, Get Out took the world by surprise, particularly as it was written and directed by the predominantly comedic Jordan Peele. The film not only showcased Peele's versatility but also solidified his position as one of the most innovative and captivating filmmakers within the horror genre. Since then, he has continued to impress with his ambitious and thrilling horror ventures, including Us in 2019 and Nope in 2022.

10. 'Demons' (1971)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.2/5

One of the most obscure horror movies on Letterboxd with an average rating of 4.0/5 or higher is the Japanese film Demons. It should not be confused with the 1985 Italian possession horror movie of the same name. Demons combines elements of horror and samurai drama in a captivating and nightmarish storyline. The film follows a lone samurai, or ronin, seeking revenge after his money is stolen by a geisha.

Being a dark and brutally intense horror movie, Demons explores the theme of all-consuming revenge, with the resulting violence having a devastating impact on the entire cast. While Demons may be slow-paced, challenging, and graphic, it is undeniably visceral and leaves a lasting impression on viewers. Its expert craftsmanship solidifies it as a well-crafted horror film.

9. 'Kwaidan' (1964)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.2/5

Kwaidan is a remarkably distinct horror film, standing out from the norm with its lengthy runtime. Unlike most movies in the genre, it spans over three hours, presenting an anthology of four captivating narratives. Each story unfolds for approximately 40 to 50 minutes, drawing inspiration from traditional Japanese folktales. Consequently, Kwaidan stands as an early and exceptional illustration of the intriguing subgenre known as folk horror.

Rest assured, those who are more frightened by the notion of a three-hour horror film than the actual horror it presents - Kwaidan offers a solution. This remarkable Japanese horror movie, Kwaidan, can be conveniently watched in up to four separate sessions. It rightfully earns its place as one of the finest Japanese horror films ever made, showcasing numerous captivating folk tales through visually striking and audaciously stylish filmmaking.

Stream Kwaidan on Max.

8. 'Rosemary's Baby' (1968)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.2/5

Image via Paramount Pictures

Rosemary's Baby remains one of the most iconic horror films depicting the fears and challenges of parenthood. Set in the 1960s, this timeless masterpiece revolves around Rosemary and her husband, Guy, who embark on a new chapter in their lives by moving into an unfamiliar apartment building. Eerily enough, they soon encounter peculiar neighbors who take a keen interest in Rosemary's pregnancy.

The film deliberately keeps its main character and the viewers in the dark for a significant portion of the movie. This deliberate pacing ultimately pays off, resulting in a powerful conclusion in the film's final moments. "Rosemary's Baby" is a masterfully executed horror movie that continues to stand the test of time, rightfully earning its place as a classic in the genre. Stream it now on AMC+.

7. 'The Cremator' (1969)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.2/5

The Cremator is a uniquely eerie horror film that defies conventional remakes. Esteemed by Letterboxd users, this cinematic gem remains relatively unknown to wider audiences. Seamlessly blending elements of horror and pitch-black comedy, the plot revolves around Mr. Kopfrkingl, a Czechoslovakian man who supports his family by toiling at a crematorium.

As the film progresses, it delves deeper into disturbing and horrific themes, presenting The Cremator as a bleak satire that illustrates the power of ideologies to influence and corrupt individuals. Although certain visuals in the movie may be terrifying, the truly horrifying aspect lies in the unsettling notion that seemingly ordinary people can harbor deeply disturbing thoughts, which later manifest in acts of violence.

Stream The Cremator on the Criterion Channel.

6. 'Cure' (1997)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.2/5

Over time, Cure has gained more and more recognition, even though it was originally well-received. This film is a powerful blend of horror, drama, crime, and mystery genres, delving into a series of bizarre murders in Tokyo and the impact it has on the detectives working on the case.

Watch Cure on the Criterion Channel. It is a captivating film that gradually escalates towards a climactic and shocking conclusion. While appearing straightforward in certain aspects, it possesses a surprising level of intricacy. For enthusiasts of Japanese horror seeking a refreshing departure from the usual Ring or Grudge movies, Cure is unquestionably a must-watch.

5. 'The Shining' (1980)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.3/5

Image via Warner Bros.

When an esteemed director ventures into the realm of horror, despite not having a prior reputation in the genre, and triumphs, it can result in a masterpiece like The Shining. Released in 1980, this film continues to shine as one of the standout highlights of that year.

The Shining, a tale that initially appears clichéd, revolves around a family residing in an abandoned hotel due to the father's caretaking employment during the off-season. However, as the story progresses, the eerie ambiance and psychological elements blend seamlessly with supernatural horror. This mastery catapults The Shining into the ranks of the all-time horror classics, capturing the hearts of countless fans - with the notable exception of Stephen King. Catch it exclusively on Max.

4. 'Alien' (1979)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.3/5

Image via 20th Century Fox

Alien is more than just a run-of-the-mill horror film with a simplistic plot. It intertwines a tale of desperation, solitude, and fighting for survival in the depths of space, resulting in a thrilling and anxiety-inducing blend of science fiction and horror.

Alien, released in 1979, is a franchise that has evolved over the years. While some of the films in the series have received mixed reviews, there is no denying that the first installment is a classic horror film. It is widely regarded as one of the defining movies in the genre, thanks in large part to its exceptional cast. Alien delivers a gripping survival horror narrative, establishing space as the ultimate setting for terror. Catch the film on Hulu.

3. 'Psycho' (1960)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.3/5

Image provided by Paramount Pictures

It is an undisputed fact that Alfred Hitchcock completely transformed the horror genre in 1960 when he unleashed Psycho upon audiences. While there had been numerous remarkable horror films that came before it, only a select few can rival the profound influence and notorious ability to surprise unsuspecting viewers quite like Psycho.

The plot twists in Psycho are widely recognized today, but the film's audacity and its ability to consistently surprise viewers are still admirable. Additionally, it is both entertaining and stylish, making it evident why it is regarded as one of Hitchcock's greatest works. Stream it on Peacock.

2. 'The Silence of the Lambs' (1992)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.3/5

Recently, Letterboxd has made changes to genre tags for certain movies, including The Silence of the Lambs. Now categorized as a horror movie, it has quickly risen to the top of Letterboxd's list of highest-rated horror films. Whether considered a horror movie or a crime/thriller, one thing remains undeniable: The Silence of the Lambs is an iconic masterpiece.

Anthony Hopkins delivers a captivating performance, possibly his finest, while Jodie Foster shines in one of her most acclaimed roles. In this film, Hopkins portrays a perilous incarcerated serial killer and cannibal, whose assistance may aid Foster's character in apprehending a notorious murderer. The gripping interaction between these two actors leads to riveting and intense sequences, leading up to an unforgettable climax. The Silence of the Lambs effortlessly surpasses the thrill and complexity commonly found in the horror genre. Catch it on Max.

1. 'The Thing' (1982)

Letterboxd Rating: 4.3/5

Image via Universal Pictures

Despite its initial cool reception by critics and audiences, The Thing has become the highest-rated horror movie on Letterboxd. Over the years, it has gained a cult following and is now regarded as a crucial contribution to the genres of horror and science fiction. The Thing is widely considered one of John Carpenter's greatest accomplishments.

Peacock offers the opportunity to watch The Thing, a gripping and suspenseful film that delves into the paranoia of isolated researchers in Antarctica. As a shape-shifting alien threatens their trust in one another, the movie showcases exceptional craftsmanship and incredible practical effects that continue to impress. Rated as the top horror movie on Letterboxd, The Thing is a must-watch.

Editor's P/S

As a long-time horror movie fan, I am thrilled to see the recognition given to some of the genre's most outstanding films in this Letterboxd top 15 list. The inclusion of classics like "The Shining" and "Psycho" is a testament to their enduring impact and cultural significance. These movies have rightfully earned their place as essential viewing for any horror enthusiast.

At the same time, I am excited to discover lesser-known gems like "Diabolique" and "Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me." The diversity in the list, spanning different eras and languages, showcases the richness and variety that the horror genre offers. It encourages viewers to venture beyond the mainstream and explore hidden treasures that may have otherwise gone unnoticed.

Overall, I believe this top 15 list compiled by Letterboxd users is a valuable resource for horror aficionados and newcomers alike. It provides a well-rounded selection of movies that cater to different tastes and preferences, offering a terrifying and unforgettable cinematic experience for all.