Craig Mazin, the creator of the HBO show The Last of Us, has addressed the theories surrounding Abby's cameo in the season 1 finale. In an interview on the Happy Sad Confused podcast, Mazin dismissed the idea that Abby appeared during Joel's shootout scene and clarified that the character has not been cast for the upcoming season 2.
No one has been chosen for the role yet. I can confirm that the character Abby was not present in the season 1 finale. The person seen with a ponytail was simply one of the Fireflies, and it is important to note that many individuals have ponytails, so it was not Abby.
Why Fans Thought Abby Appeared In The Last Of Us Season 1
The moment that caught the attention of many viewers as a possible appearance of Abby in the season 1 finale of The Last of Us was when Joel attacked the Firefly base in Salt Lake City. His goal was to save Ellie from a potentially deadly operation where they would study her immunity to Cordyceps. Keen-eyed fans of the video game noticed a mysterious figure, with a braided ponytail reminiscent of Laura Bailey's notorious character from The Last of Us Part II, fleeing from Joel.
The association between Abby's introduction in the 2020 sequel game and The Last of Us season 1 finale may lead some to believe it was an intentional Easter egg from Neil Druckmann, the creator of the games and co-creator of the HBO show. Adding to this speculation, Bailey even made a cameo appearance in the episode as a nurse in the operating room where Joel rescued Ellie. This could have been seen as a clever way to foreshadow the show's future for fans of the original material.
However, with Mazin officially debunking these theories, it is ultimately for the best that The Last of Us season 1's finale did not include an Abby cameo. Not only would it have limited Mazin and Druckmann's casting choices for Abby in season 2, but it also allows the creative duo to introduce the character in a way that will have just as much impact on viewers who are unfamiliar with the video game storyline.
Source: Happy Sad Confused