The Key Difference Between Invincible and The Boys

The Success of Invincible and The Boys

Both Invincible and The Boys have elevated the superhero genre over the last few years, and there is one key difference that highlights why both shows are successful despite their different approaches.

Invincible Fire Fight 1

Both shows are adapted from comic book series, and have been celebrated for their deference to the source material. Amazon Prime has established a healthy, and likely overlapping viewer base for both shows thanks to memorable characters and engrossing stories, and there is a perpetual argument over whether Invincible or The Boys is the best superhero show.

Mark flying in his Invincible costume in Invincible.

The Key Difference: Parody vs. Exaggeration

Invincible and The Boys both present an alternative viewpoint on superheroes that departs from the clean and wholesome punches of Captain America and Batman, but Invincible isn't a direct parody like The Boys is. Invincible certainly contains plenty of homages to Marvel and DC heroes, and it greatly exaggerates much of the superhero action, but it still holds on to many of the classic superhero tropes. The Boys, on the other hand, directly mocks the genre to deliver a scathing condemnation of its many overwrought tropes.

Invincible vs Robot 5

Invincible has a classic superhero as its protagonist in Mark Grayson, while The Boys paints a group of individuals who wish to expose and kill superheroes as its protagonists. Where Invincible still glorifies heroes like Invincible and Atom Eve as forces for good, The Boys often implies that merely being a super-powered individual makes you a villain.

invincible and omni-man working together against aliens

Why The Boys & Invincible’s Takes On Superheroes Both Work

Both Invincible and The Boys have been successful because they've helped superhero fans look at the genre from a completely different perspective than the one that they've been spoon-fed for so long. While it's true that Invincible still clings to some of the tropes of the genre, it does so in an exaggerated, ultra-violent manner that shows little deference to the more wholesome elements of superhero content. The Boys spits in the face of the concept entirely with biting commentary on not only superheroes but the world at large. Both are important additions to one of the most popular genres of fiction of the last century.

Invincible Blue Suit Mark Grayson