The Heartbreaking Truth Behind Benedict's Role in 'FBoy Island' Season 3

The Big Picture

FBoy Island is a dating show where three women have to determine if the men are nice guys or f-boys, with a $100,000 cash prize on the line.

Kate Thurston from The Bachelorette appears on the show and finds herself drawn to Benedict Polizzi, a contestant from the previous season. However, there is a chance that his return could lead to heartbreak. Benedict has exhibited concerning behavior, such as making derogatory jokes about fellow contestants and treating the dating process like a game. Will Katie ultimately endure a painful outcome?

FBoy Island revolves around three women who embark on a journey to find love. What adds an intriguing twist is that these ladies are unaware of the true intentions of the men who have applied to be on the show – whether they are f-boys or nice guys. In the concluding episode, each woman selects one final suitor who will ultimately unveil their true identity as either a nice guy or an f-boy. With $100,000 on the line, the three ladies are faced with the choice of either sharing the prize or keeping it all for themselves. Adding to the excitement, the show features Kate Thurston from The Bachelorette as she searches for love, along with the return of Benedict Polizzi from the previous season. Although Kate was thrilled to see him back, the revelation of his inclusion in the cast raises the question of whether it will turn out to be a heartbreaking twist.

Who is Benedict Polizzi of FBoy Island?

The comedian from Indiana made his first appearance in season 2 of the show. His initial date with Louise Bernard took place at the marina and they had a strong connection. In the final episode, Louise had to make a choice between f-boy Mercedes Knox and the kind-hearted Benedict. Benedict's last date with Louise involved giving her a massage and indulging in some unconventional activities. However, the massage failed to leave a lasting impression as she ultimately chose the reformed f-boy Mercedes, with whom she also split the cash prize.

During a podcast episode of "Espresso w/Benedict Polizzi," Benedict contemplated whether he would return to the island. He expressed his enthusiasm, stating that it was a perfect experience. He appreciated being guided throughout his time there, enjoying the delicious meals provided and acquiring a tan. He questioned who wouldn't want to go back, regardless of any personal awkwardness he may have felt. Benedict openly admitted to feeling uncomfortable kissing on camera, especially with the presence of the filming crew and a boom microphone. Despite these challenges, Benedict is now making a comeback for season 2.

Why Benedict Could Be the FBoy

In Season 3, Episode 3 of FBoy Island, three familiar faces from the previous season made their return: Mercedes, Benedict, and Danny Louisa. However, this time around, Danny Louisa has transformed from being a f-boy into a genuinely nice guy. In a surprising twist, it was revealed that Marquies is actually Mercedes' brother. Benedict, who had his heart broken in his previous appearance on FBoy Island, expressed his determination to adopt a more bold and daring approach this time. Meanwhile, the former star of The Bachelorette, Katie, found herself captivated by Benedict, which made it difficult for her to focus on Marco Delvecchio. When Benedict approached her for a conversation, they quickly connected over their shared love for comedy. Despite her excitement, Katie needs to be cautious because FBoy Island is notorious for its unexpected surprises. In the previous seasons, participants like Tamaris Sepulveda and Sarah Emig made shocking choices, revealing themselves as f-girls and f-boys respectively, and opting to keep the prize money for themselves. However, this season, host Nikki Glaser declared that the prize money would be donated rather than given to the chosen contestant.

So each season of FBoy Island has concluded with someone confessing that they are not who they claimed to be initially. Perhaps someone was aware that Katie was a fan of Benedict, leading to his reintroduction with the understanding that his objective this time should be both money and love. Ultimately, this could potentially leave Katie heartbroken and disappoint his supporters. There are a few indicators to watch out for if this scenario turns out to be true.

Benedict Has Major Red Flags

Image via ABC

F-boys often boast about their connections with women and about themselves. Benedict, on the other hand, has a knack for maintaining a low profile as he tends to mock himself rather than engage in self-promotion. However, he does have his occasional moments. Benedict playfully pointed at Marco and jokingly asked, "Are you the diet version of me?" Marco, who is also a comedian, burst into laughter. Katie then chimed in, mentioning that f-boys often rub their hands together. Interestingly, the comedian immediately demonstrated this behavior right after the host introduced them to the rest of the cast.

Episode 4 showcases Benedict's introduction to the other guys. He remarks that the previous night's eviction revealed that everyone is involved in a game. This conclusion was drawn after witnessing a seemingly nice guy insult one of the ladies before leaving. However, it raises concerns when contestants in dating shows start discussing the process as if it were a game. It's possible that they are referring to everyone else as players or unknowingly exposing their own mindset. One of the popular TikTokers stated, "They're all psychos deep down."

In this particular episode, Vince Xu went on a date with Katie, participating in a activity called "is it real or is it cake?" The evening concluded with a fun food fight and the two of them smearing cake on each other. Vince returned to the other men feeling intoxicated by love and confidently declared, "Marco, Benny, man. Like, it's game over man." Surprisingly, Benedict remained unfazed by this intimidation. Speaking in his private interview, he calmly acknowledged, "You're Vince." Typically, the main contenders of the season are seen as threats by their fellow competitors and are called out. It's intriguing that Benedict, who just arrived, is already being called out by Katie's preferred suitors.

Another potential warning sign is when a man associates with players. That's why it was difficult to trust that Casey Johnson had truly changed last season when his biggest supporter was Garrett. Mercedes and Benedict became friends after the previous season, and now they're back together once more. While Mercedes could easily steal all the attention with his troubled past, it detracts from Benedict's image this season. Mercedes claims he has turned over a new leaf, but he also pursued the woman who his brother is interested in, sparking a fight.

Benedict is a prime target, but he still faces strong competition. The men attempted to undermine Vince in Katie's eyes due to his remarks after their date. However, she paid no mind to their efforts and even made out with him at the mixer. Vince expressed that he felt like he had found his perfect match. In the end, Marco found himself once again in last place after getting into an argument. We're left wondering if he will be eliminated. If he is, Benedict will have a better advantage over the other guys. But will this only result in Katie crying during the finale?