Summary
Amy Pond's so-called "problematic" actions on Doctor Who are actually highlighted positively and ironically in a viral Twitter thread.
Amy Pond, initially a character that sparked division among fans, ultimately developed into one of Doctor Who's most endearing and multi-dimensional companions. Her journey alongside the Doctor is widely regarded as one of the show's most inspiring storylines, earning her significant admiration and praise.
A Twitter thread has recently gained popularity as it analyzes the ironic crimes committed by Amy Pond on the popular British series Doctor Who. Amy Pond, portrayed by Karen Gillan, was the first and main companion to the Eleventh Doctor. She was initially introduced to him when he crash-landed in her garden, and later joined him on his adventures after he returned many years later. Although Amy was the Doctor's companion from 2010 to 2012, she garnered mixed reviews due to some questionable decisions she made, dividing opinions about her character.
As fans eagerly await the release of Doctor Who season 14, Twitter user @autisticpond has compiled a list of "problematic" aspects about Amy, which has since gone viral. However, upon closer inspection, these tweets actually express admiration for the character, using subtle irony and wordplay. Take a look at them below:
The discussion on the Twitter thread begins with a list of the questionable actions of Amy on the show, without initially mentioning any significant offenses. The first item mentioned is "cannibalism," where it is argued that Amy "consumed all your favorite characters." This is followed by a video edit that showcases various scenes involving Amy, implying that the tweets may be more of an expression of admiration rather than genuine criticism.
Amy's admiration persists, with one tweet describing her as a "murder," meaning she stole the show in every episode she appeared in. Simply put, this tweet underscores Amy's exceptional presence throughout her appearances. The next tweet openly commends her for being a force to reckon with, stating that she single-handedly carried series 6 by going to great lengths, even breaking her own back metaphorically.
Amy is described as a "thief," as she has "stolen" the affection of her fans who have grown fond of her during her time on Doctor Who.
The Twitter user then identifies "public order" as a supposed issue with Amy. They later characterize the offense as "making everyone obsessed with her."
The final tweet bluntly says "breaking and entering" without any definition clarifying its meaning. Instead, the post includes two flattering images of Amy.
What Made Amy Pond Such A Divisive Character In Doctor Who
Amy stood out as a distinctive companion in Doctor Who. Notably, she held the distinction of being the very first companion to have encountered the Doctor during her childhood and also the first to embrace a contented married life. Despite sharing a remarkable chemistry with the Eleventh Doctor, public sentiment towards her remained divided for several reasons.
Amy, a vibrant character, possessed certain personality traits that some viewers found irritating or excessive. Moreover, her choice to elope with the Eleventh Doctor on her wedding night to the beloved Rory Williams unsurprisingly garnered negative reactions from the audience. In Amy's defense, it would have been difficult to resist the opportunity to embark on numerous adventures with the Doctor and travel through time and space in the TARDIS. However, her perplexing decision to later kiss the Eleventh Doctor did not improve her situation.
Although Amy initially divided opinions among Doctor Who viewers, she eventually developed into one of the most well-developed characters and arguably one of the Doctor's finest companions. As time went on, Karen's portrayal of Amy became slightly more restrained and mature. This heightened her character's likability in retrospect, and her journey with the Doctor remains one of the most heartwarming story arcs of the entire show.
Source: @autisticpond/Twitter
