The Color Purple: The Cast, The Controversy, and The Right Choice

The Controversy Surrounding The Cast

The lead role in The Color Purple almost went to one of two major musicians. An adaptation of the Marsha Norman musical version of The Color Purple, the film is one of the most highly-anticipated films for the end of 2023. It stars Fantasia Barrino, Taraji P. Henson, Danielle Brooks, Colman Domingo, Corey Hawkins, and Halle Bailey. The Color Purple is set for release on December 25.

The Color Purple characters looking in awe in the back of a convertible

Producer Oprah Winfrey reveals that The Color Purple cast could have looked far different. As Winfrey tells The Hollywood Reporter, the conversation about casting shifted as the film’s budget increased. Then, the studio started asking “Can you get Beyoncé or can you get Rhianna?” This revelation sheds light on the influence of budget on casting decisions and raises questions about the ideal cast for the iconic roles.

To be completely honest about it, if you were doing this film for $30 or $40 million, the interest in the cast would be very different. Once the film moved to $90 to $100 million, then everybody wants us to bring Beyoncé. 'Can you get Beyoncé or can you get Rihanna?’ So we’re sitting in a room saying, ‘Listen, we love Beyoncé. We love Rihanna, but there are other actors who can do this job.’ I do remember conversations about, ‘Y’all, Beyoncé is going to be busy this year.’ It wasn’t even a negotiation, because you’re not getting Beyoncé.

Fantasia Barrino: The Right Choice for Celie

Though Beyoncé or Rhianna certainly would have added to the appeal of The Color Purple for many audiences, the strength of Barrino's casting cannot be ignored. Barrino was chosen for the role because she played the role of Celie on Broadway from 2007 to 2008. During her stage run, Barrino was praised for her incredible vocals and the stirring performance she gave as she took audiences on her journey from abuse victim to empowered young woman in The Color Purple stage show.

The Color Purple's Danielle Brooks also played her role on Broadway previously. Casting Beyoncé or Rhianna in The Color Purple could also risk feeling gimmicky, and taking out some of the emotional core of the film. While both are trained singers who have acted, Barrino is more well-versed in acting for a musical, something she can transfer over to the film adaptation. Barrino is also a significantly less well-known name than either of the musicians, meaning that her persona will not be distracting, as audiences are less likely to have pre-existing knowledge of her.

So far, this casting decision has worked out for The Color Purple musical adaptation. Both Barrino and co-star Brooks received Golden Globe nominations for their performances in the film. This early buzz bodes well for The Color Purple as it prepares for its end-of-year release and Oscar season.

The Impact of Casting Controversy on The Color Purple

The casting controversy surrounding The Color Purple has sparked discussions about the influence of budget on casting decisions and the impact of celebrity status on film adaptations. The revelation that Beyoncé and Rhianna were considered for the lead roles has brought attention to the balance between star power and the suitability of actors for iconic roles. The success of Fantasia Barrino's portrayal of Celie has brought recognition to the importance of casting decisions based on talent and experience rather than celebrity status alone.

As The Color Purple prepares for its release on December 25, the controversy surrounding the casting choices has added to the anticipation and intrigue surrounding the film. The audience's curiosity about the casting decisions and the subsequent success of the chosen actors have positioned The Color Purple as a film to watch, not only for its compelling story but also for the impact of casting on the overall cinematic experience.