Red Dead Redemption: The Explosive Controversy Surrounding its Reviews

Highlights

The PS4 and Switch ports of Red Dead Redemption are being review bombed due to fan frustrations with the lack of a remaster or remake.

The user ratings for the Switch and PS4 versions are significantly lower (3.9 and 1.6 respectively) in comparison to the critic scores (86 for Switch).

Although the ports are not necessarily deemed as poor, fans express disappointment with the absence of proper remastered versions.

Red Dead Redemption for the PS4 and Switch is currently facing a wave of negative reviews, as some players are expressing their dissatisfaction by giving it low scores. It's worth noting that Red Dead Redemption received critical acclaim during the PS3 and Xbox 360 era, boasting a remarkable score of 95 on Metacritic.

Initial speculations hinted towards Rockstar Games releasing a remastered or revamped version of Red Dead Redemption for modern platforms. However, the official announcement of its arrival on the PS4 and Switch debunked these rumors. Consequently, certain fans are venting their frustrations by assigning low ratings to these new ports of Red Dead Redemption.

The user score for the Switch version of Red Dead Redemption on Metacritic is only 3.9, indicating a significant presence of review bombing. The situation is even worse for the PS4 release, with a user score of 1.6. In contrast, the critical response to the Switch version is highly positive, with a respectable score of 86 and no mixed or negative reviews. On the other hand, the PS4 edition of Red Dead Redemption has received two mixed reviews, although the third one is exceptionally positive.

The PS4 and Switch versions of Red Dead Redemption could have been improved with proper remasters. Some fans are disappointed that the game was only ported instead of being remastered. However, these new versions will still allow a larger audience to play the game, especially with the PS4 edition being compatible with the PS5 via backwards compatibility.

It will be interesting to see how well these new ports sell and if the user score changes as more gamers try it out. Red Dead Redemption was at the top of the trending list on the PlayStation Store, indicating its popularity on PSN.

Numerous games, including Red Dead Redemption, have experienced review bombing in 2023. Notable entries in this list include Diablo 4, Star Wars Jedi: Survivor, the PC version of The Last of Us Part 1, and several others.

Red Dead Redemption is currently available for PS3, PS4, Switch, and Xbox 360 platforms.

Source: Metacritic