Exploring Scheana Shay's Revelations on Dating John Mayer: From Throuples to Orgies

Look Back at Scheana Shay Brief Throuple Situation With John Mayer

Scheana Shay and John Mayer Getty Images (2)

Scheana Shay has hinted at her sexy past with John Mayer again, but true Vanderpump Rules fans have been aware of this for years.

During a March 2024 episode of Vanderpump Rules, Shay shared during game night that she had participated in an orgy.

Scheana revealed in a confessional that she had a fling with an A-list celebrity. She hinted at the person's identity by saying, "Once upon a time, my body was a wonderland. I’ll say that."

Viewers quickly linked Shay’s comment to John Mayer’s popular song “Your Body Is a Wonderland.” What some may not recall is that Shay has openly discussed her encounter with Mayer off screen.

Before becoming well-known for her time at Lisa Vanderpump's SUR restaurant, where Vanderpump Rules was filmed, Shay worked at the Grand Havana Room in Beverly Hills. This exclusive cigar club, co-owned by Stanley Shuster, the father of Skyler Shaye, was where Shay crossed paths with Mayer in 2008 while working as a waitress.

During an Amazon Live session in August 2023, Shay shared the story of meeting Mayer, who expressed interest in hanging out with her. Unfortunately, the encounter led to Shay getting fired from the private club.

Shay was let go from her job at the Grand Havana Room for breaking the rule against socializing with members.

Feeling the financial strain, Shay shared, "I'm out of money and relying on tips from auditions." She reached out to a college friend who had recently started bartending in Beverly Hills. He mentioned a new spot called Villa Blanca that had just opened and suggested Shay visit that day.

Shay began working at another Vanderpump establishment, which eventually led to her landing a role in a popular Bravo series.

Read on to discover Shay’s quotes about her unexpected throuple situation with Mayer. Unfortunately, Mayer has chosen not to comment on his previous relationship with the reality star.

Their Star-Studded Meeting

Their Star-Studded Meeting Look Back at Scheana Shay Brief Throuple Situation With John Mayer

In 2020, Scheana Shay made a surprising revelation about her past connection with John Mayer. She shared that they had met while Mayer was still dating Jennifer Aniston back in 2008 to 2009.

"I was working at this party and ended up getting wasted with them," she shared on the "Flashbacks" podcast. "Every time they took a shot, they would offer me one too. Later, [Jennifer] invited me to join them for an afterparty at her place in the Palisades."

However, Shay didn't go to Aniston's house because she was too drunk to drive. After his breakup with Aniston, Mayer went back to the cigar club and requested Shay's phone number.

Shay mentioned that she was fired because of a situation she was discussing at work. One of her coworkers overheard her talking about another coworker who was having an affair with a married man with four kids. This coworker got fired for her actions. Then, when Shay's coworker found out that Shay was dating or spending time with John Mayer, she discovered that he was a member of a different club in New York, not Beverly Hills, where fraternizing with members was not allowed.

When the episode originally aired, we tried to reach out for a comment.

Ending Up in a Throuple

Ending Up in a Throuple Look Back at Scheana Shay Brief Throuple Situation With John Mayer

Scheana Shay, John Mayer, and Stacie Adams were involved in a unique relationship. Shay revealed that her relationship with Mayer evolved into a throuple involving Stacie Adams, also known as Stacie the Bartender from The Hills.

I was living with Stacie at the time. We spent about six months together. We would often visit his house in Calabasas or Hidden Hills. It was like the three of us formed a little group.

When asked if things were "sexual" between the three of them, Shay confirmed that they were.

It All Comes Back to Vanderpump Rules

"But then there was, like, me and another her. Everyone always had attention," she added. She admitted feeling "jealous" of Adams because Mayer seemed to "like her" more by the end of their alleged romance. "I was like, 'Wait, I brought you into this and now you're getting more attention than I'm getting.' And even after he and I stopped talking, they continued talking."

It All Comes Back to Vanderpump Rules Look Back at Scheana Shay Brief Throuple Situation With John Mayer

Scheana Shay Gizelle Hernandez/Bravo

During an episode of her “Scheananigans” podcast in August 2023, Shay talked about how meeting Mayer led to her job on Vanderpump Rules. She shared a fun fact that Skyler Shaye's dad owned the first restaurant she worked at when she moved to LA/Beverly Hills. Shay mentioned that she got fired from that job for dating John Mayer, leading her to share a much longer story for another time. However, getting fired from that job eventually led her to Villa Blanca, owned by Lisa Vanderpump, which later became the setting for Real Housewives of Beverly Hills and Vanderpump Rules. Shay expressed her gratitude to Skyler Shaye’s dad for indirectly helping her start her journey on the show.

Spilling the Tea

Spilling the Tea Look Back at Scheana Shay Brief Throuple Situation With John Mayer

Scheana Shay opened up about her short-lived relationship with John Mayer on the Vanderpump Rules After Show in March 2024. She mentioned that it happened around 2008, back in her Hollywood days, recalling, "One guy, me, and two other girls."

Editor's P/S:

The article delves into the intriguing past of "Vanderpump Rules" star Scheana Shay, including her alleged involvement with renowned musician John Mayer. Shay has hinted at a "Wonderland" fling with Mayer, leading fans to connect the dots with his famous song "Your Body Is a Wonderland." The article exposes Shay's open discussions about the encounter, which reportedly occurred in 2008 while she worked at an exclusive cigar club. Shay's revelation about a throuple situation involving Mayer and Stacie Adams adds another layer to this captivating story. It raises questions about the dynamics of their relationship and the potential impact on Shay's emotions.

Furthermore, the article highlights the ripple effects of Shay's encounter with Mayer, leading to her getting fired from the cigar club. This event ultimately played a role in her landing a spot on "Vanderpump Rules" at Lisa Vanderpump's Villa Blanca. The article offers a detailed account of Shay's journey, showcasing the interconnectedness of her personal life and her reality TV career. It leaves readers curious about the extent of Mayer's involvement and whether there will be any further developments in this intriguing tale.