A Timeline of Bachelor Nation's Blake Horstmann and Love Is Blind's Giannina Gibelli's Relationship
Blake Horstmann from Bachelor Nation and Giannina Gibelli from Love Is Blind have a captivating relationship timeline From their appearances on reality shows to their blossoming romance, their journey unfolds with moments of love, drama, and surprises Discover their story from December 2021 to November 2023
Blake Horstmann and Giannina Gibelli both found love on reality TV before their relationship began off camera.
Horstmann became known to Bachelor Nation when he competed for Becca Kufrin's heart on season 14 of The Bachelorette. Despite finishing as the runner-up in 2018, Horstmann faced criticism during season 6 of Bachelor in Paradise when it was revealed that he had engaged in pre-show relationships with Caelynn Miller-Keyes and Kristina Schulman. While the 2019 season was airing, Horstmann took to Instagram to reveal his text messages with Miller-Keyes.
Gibelli made her debut on the first season of Love Is Blind where she got engaged to her fellow cast member, Damian Powers. Although they ended their relationship on their wedding day, they reconnected once filming came to an end. Unfortunately, in 2021, they officially ended their romance due to allegations of cheating on Gibelli's part with Francesca Farago from Too Hot to Handle. Powers denied these claims. However, Gibelli's love life took a turn for the better as she found love again towards the end of the year when she met Horstmann while filming season 1 of All Star Shore.
Scroll through for a timeline of their relationship:
Credit: Courtesy of Blake Horstmann/Instagram
Bachelor Nation's Blake Horstmann and Love Is Blind's Giannina Gibelli's Relationship Timeline
Blake Horstmann and Giannina Gibelli both found love on reality TV before their relationship began behind the scenes.
Horstmann first gained attention in Bachelor Nation when he competed for Becca Kufrin's heart on the 14th season of The Bachelorette. Despite finishing as the runner-up in the 2018 season, he faced backlash during the 6th season of Bachelor in Paradise for his previous romantic encounters with Caelynn Miller-Keyes and Kristina Schulman, which were exposed during the show. While the 2019 season was airing, Horstmann took to Instagram to share his text messages with Miller-Keyes.
Gibelli made an appearance on season 1 of Love Is Blind and became engaged to her fellow cast member Damian Powers. Although they ended their relationship on their wedding day, they rekindled their connection once the cameras stopped rolling. However, in 2021, they ended their relationship permanently due to Damian being accused of infidelity with Francesca Farago from Too Hot to Handle, an accusation he denied.
By the end of the year, Gibelli found love again when she met Horstmann during the filming of season 1 of All Star Shore.
Scroll through for a timeline of their relationship:
Credit: Courtesy of Blake Horstmann/Instagram
Bachelor Nation's Blake Horstmann and Love Is Blind's Giannina Gibelli's Relationship Timeline
Blake Horstmann and Giannina Gibelli both found love on reality TV before their relationship blossomed behind the scenes.
Horstmann first gained fame on season 14 of The Bachelorette, where he vied for Becca Kufrin's heart. Although he finished as the runner-up in 2018, controversy arose during season 6 of Bachelor in Paradise when his pre-show flings with Caelynn Miller-Keyes and Kristina Schulman were exposed on the beach. While the 2019 season was airing, Horstmann took to Instagram to reveal his text exchanges with Miller-Keyes.
Gibelli, on her part, made an appearance on the first season of Love Is Blind and became engaged to her costar Damian Powers. Although they broke up on their wedding day, they rekindled their relationship after the show ended. However, in 2021, they officially ended things when Gibelli accused Powers of cheating on her with Francesca Farago from Too Hot to Handle. Powers denied the allegations.
By the end of the year, Gibelli found love once again when she met Horstmann while filming the first season of All Star Shore.
Scroll through for a timeline of their relationship:
Credit: Paul A Hebert/Shutterstock; Courtesy of Giannina Gibelli/Instagram
December 2021
Horstmann and Gibelli remained silent on social media during the filming of an undisclosed upcoming television program. The show, allegedly slated to air on Paramount+, showcases numerous reality stars vying for a lucrative cash reward.
Credit: Shutterstock (2)
January 2022
Social media users recently observed Horstmann and Gibelli sharing images from the same place, sparking speculations that they spent New Year's Eve in each other's company. A trustworthy source informed Us on January 4 that the pair are indeed romantically involved.
Credit: Courtesy of Giannina Gibelli/Instagram; Courtesy of Blake Horstmann/Instagram
March 2022
The twosome kept sharing photos from the same pages as they traveled to Rome to celebrate Gibelli's 29th birthday. In response to a fan's query about the photos, she reportedly said, "I can't post about him right now since we have a project together that hasn't been announced yet." She also mentioned that she is currently enjoying the private moments they are spending together.
Credit: Courtesy of Giannina Gibelli/Instagram
April 2022
The former Netflix star posted a photo with Horstmann on April 3 via Instagram Stories, blocking his face with her phone.
Credit: Courtesy of Giannina Gibelli/Instagram
June 2022
Gibelli publicly addressed her romance with Horstmann for the first time after news of All Star Shore officially broke.
"I had no prior experience with the Bachelor franchise or its members, so I was unfamiliar with him. However, he appeared somewhat recognizable to me and caught my attention with his radiant smile when we first met on the beach," she shared with E! News. "He proves to be highly respectful, but what many people may not realize is his exceptional sense of humor, spontaneity, and unwavering dedication. Currently, he is pursuing his DJ career, and witnessing him achieve new heights and accomplish his goals is truly inspiring. I believe that not everyone is aware of his hidden potential, but he certainly possesses it."
Credit: Courtesy Blake Horstmann/Instagram
June 2022
To celebrate the premiere of All Star Shore, the couple decided to share a collection of intimate moments from their relationship. Gibelli expressed her feelings through a TikTok post, mentioning how meeting the love of her life on a reality TV show has been a significant experience. Horstmann joined in by expressing his immense happiness.
Credit: Courtesy of Giannina Gibelli/Instagram
July 2022
During a podcast appearance on "How Men Think" on July 13, Horstmann shared that while filming All Star Shore, he unexpectedly found a remarkable connection. "To be honest, I didn't anticipate falling in love on the show," he admitted. "But luckily, I quickly crossed paths with Giannina and we instantly clicked. I'm extremely content with where I am right now."
The aspiring DJ expressed admiration for the couple's relationship but wanted to proceed cautiously due to their eventful histories with reality TV dating. He further explained, "Although I developed feelings for her early on, I held back from saying 'I love you' until several months had passed, as I wanted to be absolutely certain. It has been an incredible experience."
Credit: Courtesy Blake Horstmann/Instagram
July 2022
"I have no discomfort discussing my engagement to him or envisioning a lifetime together," Gibelli enthusiastically stated in an interview with E! News. "I genuinely believe the feeling is mutual and it would bring me immense joy. However, there's no need to rush. Timing is important, and relationships must develop organically. But truthfully, I'm content. He is my everything."
The reality star expressed her gratitude for having a thoughtful boyfriend. "On days when I'm not myself or feeling overwhelmed, he takes the time to check in and says, 'Hey, are you alright? You seem quieter today.' It's these small gestures that show he genuinely cares about my happiness and well-being."
Credit: Instagram/Giannina Gibelli
September 2022
The Instagram Stories of Gibelli revealed her partner's new hairstyle, highlighting that the switch to being blonde resulted from Horstmann losing a bet. The fun factor seems to increase for blondes!
For his part, the Bachelor Nation star flaunted his new hairstyle with a smile.
Credit: Courtesy of Giannina Gibelli/TikTok
October 2022
"Love is Blind
Bachelor Nation," the Netflix alum captioned a TikTok video showcasing their Halloween costumes. Horstmann playfully wore a wedding dress, recreating his girlfriend's memorable behavior during the Love Is Blind finale, while Gibelli humorously made light of his numerous appearances on Bachelor Nation shows.
Credit: Courtesy of Giannina Gibelli/Instagram
November 2022
Horstmann asked his girlfriend to move into his Colorado home by spelling out “Will You Move In With Me?” in the snow. Gibelli, naturally, accepted the proposal.
Credit: Courtesy of Blake Horstmann/Instagram
December 2022
The couple embarked on a whimsical trip to Colorado to commemorate their first year together.
"1 year with my closest companion ️. This past year has been a whirlwind of contagious laughter, heartwarming smiles, and unforgettable escapades," he excitedly shared on Instagram. "I adore you @gianninagibelli, and here's to countless more years ahead."
Credit: Courtesy of Giannina Gibellis/Instagram
November 2023
Gibelli announced her pregnancy with Horstmann, welcoming their first child. “Love came first, followed by baby H,” Gibelli shared on Instagram. “We are incredibly thankful for the journey that has brought us here, and we are beyond excited to become parents to our precious baby in the spring of 2024!”
