10 Real Western Heroes Who Can Replace Bass Reeves In Taylor Sheridan's Lawmen Season 2

The Legacy of Bass Reeves

The hit Paramount+ series Lawmen, created by Chad Feehan and led by actor David Oyelowo, has captivated audiences with its portrayal of the remarkable life of Bass Reeves, one of the first black Deputy U.S. Marshals in American history. Reeves' story, from his time as a slave to his exceptional career as a lawman, has set the stage for a potential anthology series that delves into the lives of other significant American lawmen.

The Legacy of Bass Reeves

Exploring Potential Protagonists for Lawmen Season 2

As the future of Lawmen Season 2 remains uncertain, creator Chad Feehan and lead actor David Oyelowo have expressed interest in exploring the lives of other real-life lawmen, potentially turning the series into an anthology that chronicles the stories of these unsung heroes. Here are 10 real Western heroes who could potentially replace Bass Reeves as the protagonist in Taylor Sheridan's Lawmen Season 2:

1. Wyatt Earp

Wyatt Earp, a central figure in the Old West, is known for his influential role in Deadwood, Dodge City, and Tombstone. His storied history and impact on Hollywood Westerns make him a compelling choice for Lawmen Season 2. With his experiences in prominent Old West towns and his influence on Western cinema, Earp's story offers a wealth of material for the series to explore.

Wyatt Earp portrait

2. Bat Masterson

Bat Masterson's legend in Dodge City, Kansas, and his reputation as a gunfighter and professional gambler present an exciting opportunity for Lawmen Season 2. His time in Denver, Colorado, and his friendship with President Theodore Roosevelt add further intrigue to the potential storyline, offering a unique angle for the series to delve into.

Bat Masterson

3. Pat Garrett

Pat Garrett, known for his role in the Billy the Kid saga, transitioned from outlaw to law enforcement, becoming the Sheriff of Lincoln County, New Mexico. Lawmen Season 2 could focus on other aspects of Garrett's career, including his time as a Texas Ranger and his return to Roswell, New Mexico, providing a fresh perspective on this legendary lawman.

Pat Garrett in Billy the Kid season 2 episode 4

4. Wild Bill Hicock

Wild Bill Hicock, a heroic figure as a Marshal and Sheriff in Kansas, has a rich history that goes beyond his portrayal in Deadwood. His involvement in the Civil War and his renowned gunfights offer compelling material for Lawmen Season 2 to explore, shedding light on his courageous and tumultuous life as a lawman.

5. John Selman

John Selman's dual reputation as both a lawman and an outlaw presents an intriguing dynamic for Lawmen Season 2. His struggle to maintain a straight and narrow path in the Old West mirrors the complexities faced by Bass Reeves, offering the series an opportunity to delve into the moral ambiguity of lawmen in the Wild West.

John Selman

6. Bill Tilghman

Bill Tilghman, one of the Three Guardsmen of Oklahoma, played a pivotal role in apprehending the notorious Doolin-Dalton Gang. Lawmen Season 2 could modernize the showdown between the Three Guardsmen and the Wild Bunch, offering a fresh take on Tilghman's legendary law enforcement career.

Sam Eliiott as Bill Tilghman stands in front of an open doorway with his head slightly tilted to the side and holding a Winchester rifle in You Know My Name

7. Heck Thomas

Heck Thomas, a fearless lawman and Sheriff of Lawton, Oklahoma, was instrumental in bringing the Wild Bunch to justice. Contrasting with Bass Reeves' approach to law enforcement, Thomas's confrontations with dangerous outlaws provide an intense and action-packed narrative potential for Lawmen Season 2.

A 19th century photo of a front-facing Heck Thomas adorned in a nice suit, and sporting a well-groomed mustache

8. Doc Holiday

Doc Holiday, renowned for his association with Wyatt Earp and his reputation as a dangerous gunslinger, offers a compelling perspective for Lawmen Season 2. His involvement in numerous gunfights and his dual role as a dentist add depth to his character, presenting an intriguing portrayal of a lawman in the Old West.

Doc Holliday smiling in Tombstone

9. John Hughes

John Hughes, one of the most famous Texas Rangers, shares similarities with Bass Reeves and has been cited as an inspiration for the iconic Lone Ranger. Exploring Hughes' career as a Texas Ranger offers an opportunity to delve into the rich history of the legendary lawman, providing a fresh perspective for Lawmen Season 2.

Lawman John Hughes

10. John Barclay Armstrong

John Barclay Armstrong, a decorated Texas Ranger and U.S. Marshal, presents an intriguing candidate for Lawmen Season 2. His distinguished career and unique appearance offer a pivot from Bass Reeves' story, delving into the broader history of the Texas Rangers and their unsung heroes.

John Barclay Armstrong