In The Witcher, it has been revealed that The White Flame, portrayed by Bart Edwards, is believed to be the deceased father of Ciri, played by Freya Allan. He is now determined to capture her. However, season 3 of the Netflix series indicates that they will not be adapting the controversial storyline from the books. Despite the popularity of Netflix's The Witcher, it has faced criticism for taking liberties with Andrzej Sapkowski's books and characters, a problem that was evident in season 2. Nonetheless, there is one specific instance where it would be beneficial for the series to deviate from the source material.
In season 2 of The Witcher, it is revealed that various groups on the Continent are in pursuit of Ciri due to her Elder blood, which holds different advantages for them. Among these groups is Emhyr var Emreis, the emperor of Nilfgaard, also known as the White Flame, who is determined to capture his daughter. Emhyr goes to great lengths, forming alliances with mages and elves to ensure his success. However, those familiar with Emhyr and Ciri's story in the books know that this is a cause for concern. The storyline involving The White Flame and Ciri in The Witcher books is controversial and dark. Fortunately, due to season 3, Netflix's The Witcher will not be covering this particular storyline from the source material.
The White Flame & Ciri's Controversial Book Storyline Explained
Emhyr var Emreis's connection to Pavetta through the Law of Surprise played a vital role in breaking the curse imposed on him by the Usurper. Transforming him into a humanoid hedgehog. After marrying Pavetta and the birth of their daughter Ciri, Vilgefortz approached Emhyr with the prophecy of Ithlinne, which foretold that his son would inherit the Elder Blood and rule over the Continent. As Ciri possessed this powerful bloodline, Emhyr made the decision to return to Nilfgaard, overthrow the Usurper, and reclaim his rightful place on the throne.
Forming an alliance, Emhyr and Vilgefortz devised a plan to stage the deaths of Emhyr, Pavetta, and Ciri in order to flee to Nilfgaard. However, Pavetta discovered the scheme and successfully smuggled Ciri away before they set sail. A heated argument broke out between Emhyr and Pavetta, leading to him pushing her overboard. With his wife out of the picture, Emhyr only needed to fake his own death as Duny and then return to Nilfgaard as Emhyr. Successfully executing his plan, Emhyr successfully claimed the throne of Nilfgaard and earned the infamous title of "The White Flame Dancing on the Barrows of his Enemies," as he used the gravestones of his deceased political adversaries to adorn his ballroom.
The Witcher Season 3 Suggests Netflix Is Changing The White Flame & Ciri's Story
Now, Emhyr strongly believes in the prophecy, and due to Ciri possessing the Elder Blood, which grants her extraordinary abilities, the White Flame desires to capture his own daughter. His intention is for her to bear his child, who will fulfill the prophecy as the ruler of the world. This is a proposition that both Queen Calanthe and Pavetta would have vehemently opposed. Consequently, Emhyr resorted to fabricating their deaths as a means to execute his unsettling plans.During Emhyr's search for Ciri in The Witcher books, he encounters a fake Ciri presented by Rience and his companions. Though Emhyr initially grants her the titles belonging to the real Ciri, he immediately realizes that she is not his daughter. As a result, he commands the search for the true Ciri to persist. This imposter Ciri is then dispatched to Darn Rowan, a distant location far removed from the capital, where she is placed under the guardianship of Countess Stella Congreve. The third season of The Witcher unveils that Vilgefortz has been using young half-elf girls as subjects for his manipulative experiments, persuading them into believing they are Ciri. However, unlike the original storyline, the fake Ciri is solely Vilgefortz's creation.
Why The Witcher Changing The White Flame & Ciri's Story Would Be Right
: Vilgefortz's intentions for the fake Ciri in Netflix's The Witcher remain undisclosed. However, this alteration aligns with the series' departure from the controversial storyline involving Emhyr and Ciri in the books. Emhyr's relentless pursuit of his daughter and his aspirations of ruling the Continent alongside her are mentioned, yet his true motivations remain unverified. This notable deviation indicates that Netflix's The Witcher will not delve into the disturbing realm of Emhyr's incestuous plans for his daughter.As stated earlier, Netflix's adaptation of The Witcher has already deviated from the original source material in several ways, particularly evident in the controversial alterations made to Yennefer's character in the second season. While these changes have received criticism, the decision to alter the storyline involving the White Flame and Ciri is a wise one for the series. Emhyr's desire to capture and impregnate his own daughter would be excessively dark and contentious for a TV show. Considering the numerous challenges, problems, and negative feedback that The Witcher has already encountered, it is unnecessary to introduce an even greater controversy. By changing the connection between the White Flame and Ciri, the series can still offer an intriguing storyline, thereby demonstrating that not all alterations in Netflix's adaptation of The Witcher are unfavorable.