Logan, released in 2017, delves into one of the darkest elements of the X-Men universe - the reason for the absence of the X-Men team. The film marks Hugh Jackman's intended final portrayal of Wolverine, drawing inspiration from the Old Man Logan comic story by Mark Millar and Steve McNiven. In addition, Logan introduces Laura Kinney, also known as X-23, adding a new dimension to the story.
In Logan, Sir Patrick Stewart's character Charles Xavier plays a significant role, despite his deteriorating mental state. Charles, once the leader of the X-Men, now battles senility and suffers from dangerous seizures due to his powerful telepathic abilities. These seizures are revealed to have caused the tragic demise of most of the X-Men, a devastating event known as the "Westchester Incident." This explains why Charles and Logan are the only familiar mutants featured in the film, adding to the grim and emotional narrative that has made Logan a standout among Fox's X-Men movies.
In Old Man Logan, it is Wolverine who inadvertently kills the X-Men, having been tricked into attacking his friends by Mysterio's illusions.
Why Logan Avoids Showing The Westchester Incident
Patrick Stewart as Charles Xavier holding the arm of Hugh Jackman as Wolverine in Logan, 2017 - Why Logan Avoids Showing The Westchester Incident
In an interview with ComingSoon.net, Logan director James Mangold shared that he almost included the Westchester Incident in the film. He thought about showing the tragic death of the X-Men at the beginning of Logan, but ultimately chose not to.
The movie suddenly shifted its focus to the X-Men dying, rather than unraveling the story gradually like peeling an onion. It felt overwhelming and seemed to follow the typical movie formula, starting with a big opener to establish the mythology. I wondered, “What if we prioritize character development in the beginning?”
Mangold's choice to have a smaller opening for Logan and slowly reveal the story turned out to be the right decision, benefiting the film.
Logan's Mysterious Opening Works Better Without The X-Men's Deaths
Hugh Jackman's Wolverine fighting at the end of Logan - Logan's Mysterious Opening Works Better Without The X-Men's Deaths
Logan is unique in its focus on small-scale, character-driven storytelling, setting it apart from the typical superhero movie. Unlike the Marvel Cinematic Universe's trend of interconnected narratives, Logan keeps the spotlight on its titular character and his journey. Director Mangold's decision to start the film with a focus on Logan himself, rather than the lore-heavy Westchester Incident, adds depth to the story. This approach allows for a gradual reveal of the dark fate of the X-Men, keeping the audience engaged and invested in the characters. Overall, Logan's narrative choice to prioritize the personal stories of Wolverine and Professor X in a dystopian setting enhances the emotional impact of the film.
Editor's P/S:
The article delves into the intriguing decision behind the omission of the Westchester Incident in the film Logan. Director James Mangold's justification for prioritizing character development over a potentially overwhelming opening sequence resonates with me. By gradually revealing the tragic fate of the X-Men, the film maintains a focus on its main protagonists and allows the audience to connect with their emotional journey.
Logan's distinct approach to storytelling sets it apart from other superhero movies, emphasizing the personal struggles and dynamics of its characters amidst a grim and unforgiving world. The decision to avoid showing the Westchester Incident allows the film to unfold at its own pace, allowing the audience to fully appreciate the weight of the X-Men's loss and the consequences it has on Logan and Professor X. This approach creates a more intimate and emotionally resonant experience, ultimately enhancing the film's impact.
