Summary
Secret Invasion being an Avengers movie would have been more comic-accurate, with the involvement of Earth's Mightiest Heroes and the full-blown invasion of the Skrulls.
The limited six-episode format of the Disney+ series hindered the exploration of the expansive Marvel Comics storyline, leading to a lack of dramatic impact and diminished stakes.
Had Secret Invasion been presented as an Avengers crossover film, it could have successfully avoided its disappointing performance, offering a grander scale and a more contemplative conclusion.
Marvel Studios' Secret Invasion received mixed reviews when it premiered on Disney+ on June 21, 2023. Despite being highly anticipated, the series faced criticism and became one of the lowest-rated projects in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. The story revolved around former SHIELD Director Nick Fury, played by Samuel L. Jackson, facing a rebellious faction of shape-shifting Skrulls who aimed to exterminate humanity and take over the Earth. However, viewers felt that the series, with its emphasis on espionage and personal themes, left them wanting more.
Following the release of Secret Invasion, many wondered if it would have been better as an Avengers crossover movie. This would have allowed the project to have a grander scale. A fan poster created by spideyvegas visualizes this idea, featuring beloved Avengers such as Iron Man, Doctor Strange, and Thor joining forces to battle the Skrulls.
The fan poster, released in April 2020, presented an alternate narrative for Secret Invasion well before the series made its debut. Titled Avengers: The Secret Invasion, this iteration had the potential to address and alleviate numerous criticisms raised against the Disney+ show.
Secret Invasion Being An Avengers Movie Would Have Been More Comic-Accurate
Nick Fury overlooked the idea of summoning Earth's Mightiest Heroes during Secret Invasion, disregarding the fact that one of the Avengers had been replaced. Many believed that the Avengers should have been involved in the event, as their participation would have aligned with the original comic storyline rather than Marvel Studios' adaptation. Secret Invasion, released by Marvel Comics in 2008, portrayed a full-scale Skrull invasion of Earth that included the infiltration of several Avengers members. This aspect would have been intriguing to explore in Phase 5 of the MCU.
However, due to the decision to transform Secret Invasion into a Disney+ series, the six-episode format limited Marvel Studios' ability to fully delve into Nick Fury's backstory and personal life. Consequently, much of the dramatic intensity of the Marvel Comics storyline was lost. The Avengers uniting to confront the Skrulls on Earth would have heightened the stakes and provided a more satisfying conclusion, aligning the series closer to the source material. Although Secret Invasion introduced significant plot developments for the future of the MCU, the series' disappointing performance may have been preventable from the start.
Source: Instagram