Fans of Marvel's Secret Invasion were left disappointed after the show's opening credits revealed the use of AI in its creative production. The series, based on the 2008 Marvel Comics, revolves around Nick Fury's discovery of shape-shifting Skrulls infiltrating Earth. Despite generating significant anticipation and garnering a dedicated fan following since its announcement in 2020, Marvel's decision to incorporate AI has sparked criticism on social media. Audiences believe that the billion-dollar company has crossed an ethical boundary by utilizing this technology.
In an interview with Polygon, Ali Selim, director and executive producer of Secret Invasion, revealed that the show's title sequence was crafted using artificial intelligence. Selim emphasized that the use of AI aligns perfectly with the show's overarching theme of distortion, stating, "When we approached AI vendors, we wanted to capture the essence of the shapeshifting Skrull world, the sense of mystery and uncertainty. Who is behind this? Who are they?". Following the gripping opening of the first episode, the title sequence showcases a series of enigmatic images, all enveloped in the Skrulls' signature fluorescent green hue. Through the utilization of AI, abstract illustrations of Secret Invasion's characters and landscapes are brought to life. Notably, figures like Nick Fury and the Skrulls are depicted in a distorted manner, while the eerie green glow illuminating the scenery of Moscow and London adds to the sinister ambiance.
Marvel enlisted the expertise of Method Studios, a renowned company known for their work on Marvel series such as Loki and Moon Knight, to create the title sequence for Secret Invasion. Selim, a representative from Method Studios, explained their process of utilizing AI, stating that they would discuss ideas, themes, and words with the computer, which would then generate something based on that input. Although the specifics of how AI was used to create the images have not been disclosed by Method Studios, Polygon likened the AI prompt to "Skrull cubism," adding to the confusion surrounding its implementation. Interestingly, Selim himself admitted to Polygon that he doesn't fully comprehend how AI functions. The use of AI in an attempt to capture the show's unsettling atmosphere has sparked a debate among fans about the ethical implications of Marvel's decision to employ this controversial software.
Once audiences noticed the slightly unconventional opening credits, they took to social media to express their observations. Selim's confirmation of AI involvement left fans feeling disappointed. Despite Selim's assurance that the use of artificial intelligence aligns with the shape-shifting narrative of the show, viewers perceive Secret Invasion's reliance on AI as a sign of Marvel's lack of originality and innovation.
Marvel's decision to employ AI has sparked outrage among those in the creative industries, particularly in light of the ongoing strike led by the Writers Guild of America (WGA). The writers involved in the strike have expressed concerns about the potential for major corporations to replace human workers with AI technology. Consequently, Marvel has faced severe criticism for its choice to utilize artificial intelligence, with many fans feeling frustrated that the company did not opt for original artwork created by talented artists. The fact that Marvel, a billion-dollar company, opted for the cheaper alternative of AI instead of supporting artists financially has led audiences to dub their actions as hypocritical.
Secret Invasion's use of AI in its title sequence is viewed by some as a lack of creativity compared to other Marvel series. For instance, She-Hulk's opening titles showcased the unique artwork of Kagan McLeod, which added to the show's memorable appeal. The incorporation of artificial intelligence in Secret Invasion's title sequence makes it challenging to achieve the same level of artistic impact.
It remains to be seen if other companies will be deterred from adopting AI in their films and TV shows, as some audience members have expressed their intention to distance themselves from Marvel and boycott Secret Invasion. Although Marvel still maintains a dedicated fan base, the impact of this backlash on the future of AI in the industry is worth observing. Catch new episodes of Secret Invasion on Disney+ every Wednesday.