Unprecedented Republican Discord: The Compelling Crisis Surrounding the House Speaker
Unveiling the underlying divisions within the Republican party, this article delves into the House speaker crisis and the impact of Trump's influence on the party's dynamics
One may have assumed that a Democrat had made the statement about House Republicans being in the "same stupid clown car with a different driver." However, it was actually Republican Rep. Dusty Johnson who coined this impactful phrase. Congressman Johnson was speaking about the current chaos in the House following the elimination of Kevin McCarthy as speaker, with eight Republicans aligning themselves with the Democrats in the vote.
However, the timing of electing a new speaker is insignificant for the House Republican majority. What we are currently witnessing is unprecedented in modern times.
This situation reflects a deep-rooted division within the House Republicans. It goes beyond ideological differences and delves into the issue of trust in their leaders' ability to find compromises that satisfy the party.
Rep. Jim Jordan speaks to reporters as House Republicans hold a caucus meeting at the Longworth House Office Building on October 13, 2023 in Washington, DC.
Win McNamee/Getty Images
House Republicans in disarray as Jim Jordan hunts for enough votes to be speaker
There has been a lot of talk recently about the divisions within the House Republican Party. The discussion mainly revolves around the ideological differences between the right and left. Those who opposed McCarthy's leadership tend to lean more towards the conservative side compared to the overall GOP. It's worth noting, however, that there are many Republicans who lean conservative but did not vote against McCarthy, like Texas Representative Chip Roy, for instance.
Additionally, there is a divide regarding whether Republicans should prioritize compromise in governing. Are individuals willing to support the compromises made by House GOP leaders in order to maintain the functioning of the government?
Analyzing roll call votes in Congress can provide insights. Notably, according to an academic metric developed by Voteview, Matt Gaetz of Florida stands out as the Republican representative who has been least supportive of party leadership in this Congress.
What is even more significant is that the difference in this regard between House Republicans who are most willing to compromise and align with party leadership, and those who strongly oppose it (i.e., the top and bottom fifth percentiles), is wider than it has been in the past 80 years. These lawmakers on the fringes of the conference hold great importance due to the narrow majority of the current GOP; just a few members can potentially overthrow the speaker, as observed earlier this month.
Representatives like Gaetz didnt pop out of nowhere. They are in the Congress because people elected them.
Specifically, many of the same people who really like former President Donald Trump.
The party of Trump
Here's an inquiry presented in the most recent CNN/SSRS survey released on Thursday. We inquired about whether Republicans in Congress ought to "adhere unwaveringly to their beliefs without making any compromises, even if little progress is made in Washington, or collaborate with members from the opposite party to accomplish tasks in Washington, even if it means relinquishing some of their top-priority policies?"
In the 2024 GOP primary contest, 52% of voters supporting Trump desired unwavering Republican representation in Congress. Conversely, only 23% of non-Trump Republicans favored uncompromising lawmakers, while a significant majority of 77% sought Congressional Republicans who can collaborate across party lines. It is worth noting that in the primary, Trump enjoys the support of the majority of Republicans (58%), as highlighted in the CNN poll. One aspect of Trump's attractiveness lies in his departure from conventional Republican politics, with a rejection of business as usual.
COLUMBUS, GEORGIA - JUNE 10: Arriving at the Columbus Convention and Trade Center in Columbus, Georgia, Former U.S. President Donald Trump gave a speech to the Georgia state GOP convention on June 10, 2023. This event took place shortly after the indictment of former President Trump on 37 felony counts, as announced by Special Counsel Jack Smith in relation to his investigation into classified documents. (Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images
The chance of Trump winning another term is very real
Hence, it is not unexpected that a majority (56%) of Trump's supporters endorse McCarthy's removal as speaker subsequent to his compromise with Democrats to avert a government shutdown. Conversely, only 37% of all other Republicans approved of McCarthy's ousting.
It is important to mention that the attitude towards compromising to prevent a government shutdown among Republican voters has not significantly changed compared to ten years ago. However, there does appear to be a shift in the individuals serving in Congress.
Republican lawmakers who were previously regarded as anti-establishment, such as Thomas Massie of Kentucky, who supported McCarthy's continuation as speaker, do not seem to exhibit the same level of anti-establishment sentiment as they did years ago.
Massie and other individuals like him have been overshadowed by figures like Gaetz, leading some Republicans in Congress to view the party as being under the influence of Trump. Additionally, the current House GOP majority is more comparable to the late 1990s and early 2000s, rather than the tea party era from ten years ago.
About 25 years ago, according to NBC polling, it was observed that Republicans were more inclined towards compromising rather than sticking to their principles. During negotiations with Democratic President Bill Clinton, 63% of Republicans favored compromise, whereas only 28% preferred holding onto their principles when forced to choose between the two options.
In the present day, Republicans once again hold a narrow majority in the House, but their electorate seems to be more willing to accept compromises in the name of principles. Hence, it is not surprising that we are currently witnessing a House GOP leadership battle that appears more suitable for a screenplay by Aaron Sorkin rather than real-life politics.
