The Unparalleled Brilliance of 'The Simpsons' Treehouse of Horror - A True High Point

Article Summary

The tradition of "Treehouse of Horror" in The Simpsons has endured throughout its history, featuring a remarkable collection of over 100 horror-comedy-animation segments that delight fans with their diverse offerings.

The main Simpson family is typically showcased in bizarre and dark situations in the best "Treehouse of Horror" segments. These segments make clever use of their unique reactions to vampires, alternate dimensions, and other macabre elements. The segment in "Treehouse V" that parodies The Shining is widely regarded as the top Halloween segment in The Simpsons. It masterfully combines humor, scares, and nods to the original film, creating an enjoyable viewing experience.

Bart Simpson, voiced by Nancy Cartwright, is known for causing trouble and getting into trouble. However, when it comes to telling scary stories on Halloween, he has the right idea. In 1990, Bart had a post trick-or-treat storytelling session with his sisters, which started a long-standing tradition in The Simpsons. The 34th episode of the "Treehouse of Horror" series, which includes over 100 segments, is set to premiere on November 5th on Fox. This special episode explores haunted houses, mad scientists, aliens, ghouls, and even references many movies. It has become a tradition for the Simpson family to take a break from the show's canon and venture into the realm of horror.

As with any diverse anthology project, there are both good and not-so-good episodes, and the "Treehouse of Horror" episodes have had their ups and downs over the years. However, the Halloween special can still be the highlight of the season at its best. Some of the episodes within this series are considered among the best episodes in the entire run of The Simpsons. So, what makes a great "Treehouse of Horror" episode? And which segment within those episodes stands out the most? It should come as no surprise that the parody of The Shining in "Treehouse V" is still regarded as the finest Simpsons Halloween segment.

The Simpsons is a long-running animated sitcom that first premiered on December 17, 1989. The talented cast includes Dan Castellaneta, Julie Kavner, Nancy Cartwright, Yeardley Smith, Hank Azaria, and Harry Shearer. The show primarily falls under the genre of comedy and has been rated TV-14. Over the years, it has successfully completed 36 seasons.

The “Treehouse of Horror” Episodes See the Simpsons at Their Best

Let's take a moment to delve into the fascinating history of The Simpsons' "Treehouse of Horror" installments. With 33 episodes and still going strong, the "Treehouse of Horror" series truly caters to every horror-comedy-animation enthusiast out there. Whether you're craving a classic movie parody or something more abstract and thought-provoking, this series has got it all. Some segments delve into the depths of darkness, while others embrace a more lighthearted and quirky approach. There are even segments that draw heavily from traditional Halloween elements, as well as those that venture into uncharted territory.

The finest "Treehouses" typically possess a few key characteristics. One of these is utilizing the Simpson family as themselves. While it is enjoyable to witness Springfield transformed into historical Salem or a world inspired by Dr. Seuss, it is worth noting that The Simpsons has other anthology clip shows where the characters portray different roles. Having the main cast remain unchanged and placing them in peculiar situations far from their usual surroundings offers a wonderful opportunity to observe how they would genuinely react to vampires, alternate dimensions, and more.

This is especially true for parodies of films and TV shows. Such parodies are a common feature of TV animation and often result in condensed recaps of the subject matter, with a few simplistic jokes thrown in. Recently, "Treehouse" parodies have followed a similar formula, but the best ones (mostly from the 90s) took a different approach. Rather than meticulously ticking off plot points of stories like Bram Stoker's Dracula or The Twilight Zone's "Nightmare at 20,000 Feet," The Simpsons adhered to a lean outline of these narratives, populated them with familiar Springfieldians, and allowed chaos to unfold. As a result, these parodies were more playful and imaginative, providing ample room for comedic moments.

"Treehouse of Horror" Episodes Should Stay Close to Halloween

A distinguishing feature of the finest segments in "Treehouse" is their direct connection to Halloween. One of the major disappointments with later "Treehouses" is their lack of alignment with the holiday they are supposed to honor. While horror, science fiction, and fantasy are certainly broad genres, it begs the question if Back to the Future and Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure are truly the most fitting sources to draw inspiration from when creating a Halloween special. "Treehouse" serves as an ideal platform for eerie content, and it showcases its true potential when it embraces such themes.

And, when it comes to creepy stuff - aren't you looking for just a hint of fear? As an unorthodox tribute to the frightful season, "Treehouse of Horror" emerges as the ideal moment for The Simpsons to delve into darkness. Throughout the years, this annual tradition has had its fair share of successes and failures. The unsuccessful attempts often resort to a cynical variation of darkness, seemingly exploiting the Jerkass Homer persona. On the other hand, certain segments embrace the darker side in a manner befitting the Halloween theme - with madness, dismemberment, bloodshed, death, and other mind-boggling displays of the macabre. The initial viewing alone is bound to evoke both screams and laughter in equal measure.

The Best "Treehouse of Horror" Segments Come From David Mirkin

Image via 20th Television

Regarding the best Halloween segment of "Treehouse of Horror" on The Simpsons, it ultimately depends on personal preference. Our website previously compiled a list of top "Treehouse" segments, featuring some exceptional choices. Nevertheless, in the opinion of this writer, the pinnacle of the "Treehouse" series lies within the years when David Mirkin was in charge. Mirkin addressed concerns about violence in The Simpsons by infusing his "Treehouse" episodes (IV and V) with copious amounts of blood and gore (as stated in DVD commentaries). He skillfully covered a gamut of Halloween-themed subject matter, ranging from bizarre narratives involving cannibalistic teachers to clever parodies of famous movies. Throughout Mirkin's tenure, The Simpsons themselves take on various roles in all six segments, experiencing adventures involving time-traveling toasters, Faustian deals centered around donuts, and Stanley Kubrick's interpretation of the haunted Overlook Hotel—an exhilarating and wild ride.

Mirkin’s “Treehouses” have an added visual charm, coinciding with a time when The Simpsons’ animation possessed an enticing casualness. It was not as unrefined as the early seasons, yet it had not become as polished and constrained by model sheets as it has since. The movement within these “Treehouses” is lively, the poses are delightfully exaggerated, and the expressions frequently become exuberantly wild – at times, seemingly unintentionally, resulting in character eyes wandering in opposite directions. However, this is particularly effective when it occurs with a vampirized Marge Simpson (Julie Kavner) cackling with mad glee.

The Parody of 'The Shining' in "Treehouse V" Is the Best 'Simpsons' Halloween Segment

Image via 20th Television

"The Shinning" from "Treehouse V" offers the perfect Halloween experience, combining all the elements for pure delight. This iconic segment of the Simpsons has become a beloved part of the show's history, generating numerous memes. Homer's urge to kill, portrayed brilliantly by Dan Castellaneta, rises and falls with his unique touch, influenced by the iconic performance of Jack Nicholson. The segment strikes a balance, incorporating elements of The Shining while primarily focusing on The Simpson family's eerie tale as they find themselves trapped in a haunted hotel without TV or beer. Groundskeeper Willie, also voiced by Dan Castellaneta, adds an element of fun that resonates throughout the episode, with his defiant jab at Homer's axe-wielding becoming a memorable exit. "The Shinning" is a fast-paced rollercoaster, delivering one joke after another. It provides not only laughs but also great chills, from Alf Clausen's interpretation of The Shining's soundtrack to Marge's shocking discovery of Homer's descent into madness.

"The Shinning" and "Treehouse V" can be seen as a farewell to the original concept of the "Treehouse" episodes, where the Simpsons themselves tell Halloween tales. Although "V" doesn't have the frame stories of the previous four episodes, it ties all the segments together through Groundskeeper Willie and includes Marge's warning about excessive violence. Additionally, it concludes with holiday wishes, maintaining the atmosphere of sharing spooky stories within the family, which adds charm to the early "Treehouse" episodes. The way "The Shinning" incorporates the characters into this atmosphere is exceptional, making it the standout segment in the "Treehouse" series. All seasons of The Simpsons are now available for streaming on Disney+.

Watch on Disney+

Editor's P/S

The Simpsons' Treehouse of Horror episodes have consistently been a highlight of the show's long-running history. These Halloween-themed episodes have allowed the writers and animators to go all out with their creativity, resulting in some truly memorable and iconic moments.

One of the things that makes the Treehouse of Horror episodes so special is their willingness to parody and homage to classic horror movies and stories. The episode "Treehouse V" is a perfect example of this, with its brilliant send-up of Stanley Kubrick's The Shining. The episode perfectly captures the tone and atmosphere of the original film while also adding its own unique Simpsons twist. Another standout episode is "Treehouse of Horror IV," which features a segment called "Dial Z for Zombies." This segment is a hilarious take on the classic zombie genre, complete with all the gore and scares you would expect.