ConcernedApe's Stardew Valley is widely regarded as one of the top simulation RPGs, even after being released more than seven years ago. Combining the mechanics of a farming sim with the intricacies of a role-playing game, Stardew Valley has garnered critical acclaim for its complex in-game community and engaging gameplay. Among its many layers, one of the most beloved aspects of the game is the ability for players to form relationships with the town's residents.
In recent years, cozy gaming has gained popularity, with players seeking out relaxing, low-stress gameplay. Stardew Valley offers exactly that with its focus on farm management and charming rural setting. However, what surprises many gamers is the depth and maturity found within some of the game's features, particularly the way friendships and romantic relationships develop. Players have the option to pursue romance with a select number of NPCs, resulting in touching, relatable, and unforgettable pairings. Each player may have their preferred romance option, with some being considered superior to others.
S-Tier
Abigail - Despite not being everyone's favorite, Abigail stands out as a unique and intriguing character in Stardew Valley compared to her neighbors. Fan theories surrounding her parentage add an extra layer of fun and mystery. With her feisty and independent nature, coupled with her nerdy side, Abigail easily charms many gamers. She's not afraid to venture into the dangerous depths of the mine and fight alongside players. As a spouse, she presents valuable gifts like Cherry Bombs, Void Essence, and Solar Essence.
Leah - Leah proves to be one of the most approachable characters in Stardew Valley, thanks to her fondness for gifts found in nature. She effortlessly fits into the farming lifestyle once players marry her. Alongside her artistic flair, she possesses a captivating backstory filled with relatable self-doubt and a longing for independence. Although her gifts may not be the most exotic, Leah brings warmth and creativity to the farm.
A-Tier
Emily is a distinctive character in Stardew Valley, perfect for players seeking a touch of uniqueness. With her striking blue hair, she easily catches the eye and radiates enthusiasm, always embracing life to the fullest. Unlike some of the more sorrowful stories found in town, Emily's vibrant personality adds a refreshing twist to the game. Upon entering matrimony, she lavishes her spouse with a diverse array of presents. Additionally, she holds the exclusive knowledge of the Red Plate recipe, which grants a temporary surge in maximum energy.
Maru - With a passion for all things scientific, Maru stands out as a unique individual. Although her preferred gifts may be a bit on the pricier side and not always readily available, her ten-heart event is undeniably one of the finest in the game, showcasing her captivating interests. Furthermore, her married life proves to be invaluable due to the exceptional value of the gifts she bestows upon her partner, making her an astute choice for those seeking mutual benefit in a romantic relationship.
Shane stands out as one of the most tragic figures in Stardew Valley, with a captivating backstory and character arc that evokes strong emotions. Initially guarded, Shane's journey is rewarding for players who invest their time. Exploring the complexities of depression and its impact not only on the individual but also on those around them, Shane's heartfelt events offer a unique experience compared to the other eligible partners.
Harvey, on the other hand, may be seen as a safe and conventional option but having the town doctor as a spouse comes with its benefits. While he may have reservations about indulging in unhealthy foods, Harvey appreciates a wide range of gifts and is easy to connect with. With his sweet and uncomplicated nature, Harvey is a great choice for those seeking a lovely and slightly nerdy life partner.
B-Tier
Sebastian - Among the many characters on their personal journeys in Stardew Valley, Sebastian stands out. Initially seen as withdrawn and mysterious, some may even find him a bit gloomy. However, as players begin to know him better and peel back his introverted layers, they'll discover a surprisingly cool individual. With his motorcycle, passion for Dungeons & Dragons, and hidden intensity, Sebastian is truly intriguing.
Penny - In the complex fabric of Stardew Valley, Penny carries a burden of a troubled family history. Living with her alcoholic mother, Pam, life hasn't been easy for her. Nonetheless, this challenging upbringing has not dampened Penny's kind and caring nature. As a dedicated teacher for the community's youth in Pelican Town, her character shines through. While her gifts may not be the most extravagant, her wholesome personality and touching story more than compensate.
Elliott - If players were selecting partners based solely on their hairstyles, Elliott would likely be among the top choices. Apart from his impressive mane, however, Elliott may not offer the most thrilling romantic storyline in Stardew Valley. While other non-playable characters undergo significant personal development, this enigmatic writer remains relatively unchanged throughout the game. Nevertheless, his exceptional writing abilities bring an added touch of charm.
C-Tier
Sam - Despite his amiable and affable nature, Sam fails to leave a lasting impression among the other potential suitors in Pelican Town. Resembling an excessively eager puppy, Sam is easily satisfied and free from any complications. Regrettably, his offerings as a marriage partner are not particularly noteworthy, which leads most players to ultimately overlook him as a viable romantic choice.
Alex - While Alex can sometimes come across as a stereotypical jock character, he lacks depth at times. Similar to Sam, he is easy to get along with and please, but this may not always engage players. Nevertheless, he is lovable and genuinely sweet, which may still appeal to certain players.
Haley - At first glance, Haley may appear to embody common negative stereotypes associated with being snobby and shallow due to her blonde hair. However, there are redeeming qualities to her character. Her passion for photography adds an intriguing layer that slowly unfolds, and dedicated players can discover her compassionate side as well.
Stardew Valley is available now for Mobile, Nintendo Switch, PC, PS4, PlayStation Vita, and Xbox One.