The Top 10 Overlooked Gems of Arthouse Comedy

Comedy films, in general, would greatly benefit from embracing a more unconventional approach. It is disheartening to observe that in an era where highly innovative and imaginative comedic talents are gravitating towards television and streaming platforms, there is an unfortunate scarcity of noteworthy comedic films in theaters. It appears that audiences are more inclined to fulfill their comedic cravings through big-budget blockbusters such as The Super Mario Bros. Movie or Barbie, as opposed to seeking out smaller, independent endeavors that present fresh perspectives and distinct voices.

When seeking out comedies that venture beyond traditional boundaries, one can always rely on indie cinema. In fact, numerous independent and arthouse filmmakers have successfully created comedies that stray from the mainstream, yet are equally amusing. While these projects may not attain commercial success or critical acclaim, they consistently demonstrate boldness and intellectually stimulating humor that is often lacking in mainstream productions.

10. 'The Land of Steady Habits' (2018)

Starring Ben Mendelsohn

Image via Netflix

Nicole Holofcener, director of You Hurt My Feelings, didn't receive as much acclaim for her 2018 Netflix dramedy, The Land of Steady Habits, which is unfortunate. This arthouse comedy follows the life of a recently divorced man (portrayed by the always dependable Ben Mendelsohn) as he attempts to relive the freedom of his youth, only to find himself caring for his troubled, drug-addicted son (played by Thomas Mann).

The Land of Steady Habits, like Holofcener's best films, combines sharp humor with serious emotional drama. It's intriguing to witness Mendelsohn in a role that's more lighthearted and down-to-earth, contrasting with his typically dark performances. Seamlessly blending comedy and drama, this film offers a reflective exploration of family dynamics, presenting a unique perspective on the mid-life crisis cliché. Stream it on Netflix.

9. 'Living in Oblivion' (1995)

Starring Steve Buscemi

Image courtesy of Sony Pictures

For any budding filmmaker who has ever encountered the terrors of a troubled set, Living in Oblivion could serve as a therapeutic remedy. The movie delves into the bedlam that unfolds behind the scenes during the making of an independent drama, as the hard-pressed director (Steve Buscemi) strives to corral his unconventional cast in order to bring the shot list to fruition.

The film's comedic portrayal strikes a chord with industry insiders, capturing the essence of the filmmaking experience on a smaller scale. Additionally, it serves as undeniable proof of Buscemi's exceptional talent and his knack for elevating any project he is involved in. While Living in Oblivion is one of many films centered around the craft of filmmaking, its insightful exploration of the behind-the-scenes world makes it a worthwhile watch for viewers.

Stream it on Pluto TV.

8. 'The Comedian' (2016)

Starring Robert De Niro

Sony Pictures Classics

Despite some missteps in recent years, Robert De Niro has managed to reclaim his brilliance with notable roles in films like Silver Linings Playbook and The Irishman. However, his comedic talents have faced some setbacks with less successful projects like Dirty Grandpa, The War With Grandpa, Grudge Match, and Last Vegas. Nevertheless, De Niro demonstrates his enduring sense of humor in Taylor Hackford's The Comedian, where he portrays an aging insult comic fulfilling his community service.

Despite its imperfections, The Comedian shines due to De Niro's confident performance, although it shamelessly draws inspiration from superior dark comedies of the past. Nonetheless, De Niro enthusiasts will be thrilled to witness the cameos of his fellow co-stars in the movie, such as Danny DeVito and Harvey Keitel.

Stream on Max.

7. 'The Fundamentals of Caring' (2016)

Starring Paul Rudd and Selena Gomez

Image via Netflix

In the world of entertainment, Paul Rudd stands out as one of the most adored actors. It is this immense likability that makes him an impeccable choice for the lead role in the heartwarming 2017 dramedy, The Fundamentals of Caring, available on Netflix. Within the film, Rudd flawlessly portrays the character of Ben Benjamin, a caregiver who realizes his life has become too solitary. Fuelled by this revelation, he embarks on a transformative journey alongside Trevor, a terminally ill teenager portrayed by Craig Roberts. Together, they embark on a road trip to reunite Trevor with his father.

The Fundamentals of Caring stands out by exploring familiar coming-of-age themes with a delightful blend of humor and wit. Instead of detracting from the seriousness of the cancer subplot, the film skillfully captures the darkly humorous nature of Trevor's situation. While the entire cast delivers outstanding performances, Bobby Cannavale's portrayal of Trevor's cruel and unlikeable father is particularly memorable. Catch this captivating film on Netflix.

6. 'Maggie's Plan' (2015)

Starring Greta Gerwig, Ethan Hawke, and Julianne Moore

Sony Picture Classics presents a delightful tale of fractured relationships in Maggie's Plan. The story revolves around John, a self-absorbed writer (played by Ethan Hawke), who leaves his long-time spouse Georgette (portrayed by Julianne Moore) when he falls head over heels for the peculiar Maggie (played by Greta Gerwig). Maggie, who had intended to become a single mother, soon realizes that her newfound existence is not as flawless as she had imagined when her baby arrives.

Maggie's Plan is a delightful, endearing, and slightly eccentric film that offers a thought-provoking exploration of family, love, and the pressures of society. Greta Gerwig effortlessly captivates with her undeniable charisma, and Julianne Moore shines as she effortlessly steals every scene she's in. However, it is Ethan Hawke who steals the show with a hilariously toxic portrayal of a male character. Writer-director Rebecca Miller fearlessly presents a charming and unconventional perspective on relationships that is sure to resonate with contemporary viewers. Catch it now on Max.

5. 'Brigsby Bear' (2017)

Starring Kyle Mooney

Image Via Sony Pictures Classics

Similar to Living in Oblivion, Brigsby Bear is a film specifically crafted for cinephiles who have a soft spot for geeky franchise properties. The storyline revolves around James (Kyle Mooney), a man who has spent his entire life confined in a bunker under the care of his adoptive father (Mark Hamill). With an imaginative mind, James' father created a fictional adventure show called Brigsby Bear, which solely captivates his adoptive son. Upon his release from this unsuspecting captivity, James reconnects with his biological family and forms new friendships by producing his own version of the Brigsby Bear series.

Birgsby Bear is a charming and unexpectedly delightful comedy. The movie's affectionate treatment of pop culture and its impact is genuinely sincere and heartwarming, enhanced by an outstanding performance from an exceptional ensemble led by Mooney, a former cast member of Saturday Night Live. Quirky yet rejuvenating and fulfilling, Brigsby Bear is a unique comedy that fans mustn't overlook.

View on YouTube

4. 'Love & Friendship' (2016)

Starring Kate Beckinsale

Image via Amazon Studios

Jane Austen's work is known for its universal humor, which is evident in the 2016 historical comedy Love & Friendship. This film sheds light on one of Austen's underappreciated novels and showcases a remarkable performance by Kate Beckinsale in a more distinct role. Taking place at the tail end of the 18th century, the story revolves around Lady Susan (portrayed by Beckinsale), a recently widowed woman who skillfully orchestrates strategic marriages in order to secure her family's future.

Beckinsale showcases her exceptional acting skills, stepping away from her typical action roles in the Underworld series. In this role, she portrays Lady Susan, a clever and sly character who stands out as one of Jane Austen's finest heroines. Director Whit Stillman successfully captures the sharp wit and dark humor of Austen's original writing, creating a charming and humorous period dramedy that is truly one of the best adaptations of Austen's works. Don't miss the opportunity to watch it on Prime Video.

3. 'The Man Who Killed Don Quixote' (2019)

Starring Adam Driver and Jonathan Pryce

Image via Don Quixote AIE

After decades of work, Brazil and The Fisher King director Terry Gilliam finally released The Man Who Killed Don Quixote in early 2019. The film pays homage to the art of storytelling and the enduring appeal of heroic characters. It tells the story of an ambitious filmmaker (Adam Driver) who embarks on an unexpected adventure when he encounters one of his former actors (Jonathan Pryce), who truly believes he is the legendary knight-errant Don Quixote.

The Man Who Killed Don Quixote faced numerous obstacles and delays before finally being released, which impacted its overall quality. The decision to cast Pryce as a Spanish shoemaker seems to lack a sense of authenticity, and the lengthy development process overshadowed the film's actual strengths. However, there is still much to appreciate in The Man Who Killed Don Quixote's bold and chaotic approach, as it deliberately aims to be loud and unpredictable.

Stream it on Crackle.

2. 'Watching the Detectives' (2007)

Starring Cillian Murphy and Lucy Liu

Peace Arch Films presents an entertaining performance by Cillian Murphy in the highly underestimated 2017 mystery comedy, Watching the Detectives. The story revolves around a socially awkward film enthusiast (Murphy) whose life takes an unexpected turn when he becomes infatuated with a mysterious femme fatale (Lucy Liu), leading him into a string of actual criminal activities.

The movie Watching the Detectives is a true hidden gem, made even better by the delightful chemistry between Murphy and Liu. While it pays homage to classic film noir and detective movies, it also beautifully captures the essence of fan culture. Although quirky and offbeat, the film's underlying message about the unhealthy nature of attempting to live one's life by movie standards resonates deeply, particularly in today's era of parasocial relationships. Catch it on Pluto TV.

1. 'Be Kind Rewind' (2008)

Starring Jack Black

Image Via New Line Cinema

In 2008, Michel Gondry, the director of Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, once again delved into the realm of arthouse comedy with his quirky yet undeniably heartwarming film Be Kind Rewind. The story revolves around two video store clerks, played by Jack Black and Mos Def, who accidentally erase all the tapes of their movies and are compelled to recreate them from scratch.

Be Kind Rewind is a film that explores the joy of movie-making, celebrating its collaborative and liberating nature. Jack Black delivers an underrated performance, portraying passion and bliss in an unrestrained yet sincere manner. The characters' creation of a peculiar version of Ghostbusters surprisingly holds its own against the original classic.

Stream on Max

Editor's P/S

As an ardent fan of arthouse cinema, I find great joy in exploring the overlooked gems of the comedy genre. It is disheartening to see that mainstream theaters often neglect innovative and imaginative comedic talents, leaving audiences to seek fulfillment through big-budget blockbusters. Fortunately, independent and arthouse filmmakers have consistently filled this void with bold and intellectually stimulating comedies that push the boundaries of the genre.

One such hidden gem is "The Land of Steady Habits," directed by Nicole Holofcener. This arthouse comedy follows a recently divorced man as he attempts to relive his youth, only to find himself caring for his troubled son. The film combines sharp humor with serious emotional drama, offering a unique perspective on the mid-life crisis cliché. Ben Mendelsohn delivers a standout performance, showcasing his range and versatility in a role that is both lighthearted and emotionally complex.

Another overlooked gem is "Living in Oblivion," directed by Steve Buscemi. This comedy delves into the bedlam that unfolds behind the scenes during the making of an independent drama. Buscemi brilliantly captures the essence of the filmmaking experience on a smaller scale, providing a humorous and insightful look at the challenges and tribulations faced by filmmakers. The film is a must-watch for anyone interested in the craft of filmmaking, and it showcases Buscemi's exceptional talent both as an actor and a director.