Summary
Retiring from his role as Gotham's protector, Keaton's Batman made the difficult decision after inadvertently causing the death of a criminal in the presence of their child, a haunting reminder of his own harrowing past.However, without this vital backstory explored in The Flash movie, Keaton's Batman appeared shallow and merely serving as a fleeting appearance, lacking the depth and substance that was expected.
The exclusion of such a significant and tragic event from Keaton's Batman's past is both puzzling and undermines the potential for a more gripping character development. The Flash director, Andy Muschietti, has finally disclosed the brutal reason behind Michael Keaton's Batman's decision to retire as Gotham's Caped Crusader. Thanks to the havoc caused by Barry Allen (Ezra Miller) and his meddling with the multiverse through time-travel, Ben Affleck's Batman was replaced by Keaton's version from Tim Burton's iconic movies of the early 90s. However, surprisingly, The Flash fails to address the tragic event that compelled Bruce Wayne to step back from his heroic duties.
In a new behind-the-scenes featurette for The Flash titled Let's Get Nuts: Batman Returns... Again, important background information about Keaton's Batman is uncovered. It explains why he retired for 25 years before being discovered by two versions of Barry Allen. Developed specifically for Keaton's return in The Flash, director Muschietti aimed to create a tragic reason for Bruce Wayne to give up his role as Batman. According to him, there should be an event that goes against Bruce's principles, where he unknowingly kills a criminal in front of the criminal's child. This parallels the traumatic experience Bruce had when his parents were murdered in front of him near Monarch Theaters, which ultimately shaped him into the figure of Batman.
Undoubtedly, this recently disclosed backstory for Keaton's Batman sheds light on the reasons behind his retirement, transforming him into a considerably more poignant character than portrayed in The Flash film itself.
The Flash's Missing Batman Story Was The Depth We All Missed
Surprisingly, Gotham no longer needed Michael Keaton's Batman in the Flash movie, leaving us wondering why. The once corrupt and crime-ridden city had transformed into one of the safest places worldwide. Unfortunately, the Flash failed to delve into Muschietti's missing backstory for Batman, which could have added significant depth to Keaton's character. Burdened with guilt, resuming his role as Batman after years of retirement would have been his last opportunity for redemption. This crucial detail would have provided a clearer understanding of his decision to assist the Flashes and ultimately sacrifice himself in the epic battle against General Zod.
The omission of Batman's retirement and the tragic breaking of his rule in The Flash is a significant missed opportunity. One major criticism of Keaton's role in the film was its lack of depth, with his Batman feeling more like a brief appearance rather than a fully explored character. Many fans would have appreciated a deeper exploration of his past. The decision not to utilize this crucial backstory for Michael Keaton's Batman in The Flash is perplexing, especially considering its recent reveal in a new featurette.