Summary
Wil Wheaton quit Star Trek: The Next Generation due to emotional abuse and a desire to prove his worth outside of the show.
The TNG writers faced difficulties in crafting a relatable character for young viewers in the development of Wesley Crusher's arc.
Although absent from Star Trek: Picard season 3, Wil Wheaton continues to maintain a prominent presence in Hollywood and the Star Trek franchise by making guest appearances, providing voiceovers, and hosting his own aftershow.
Why did Wil Wheaton quit Star Trek: The Next Generation? Wesley Crusher, the highly intelligent prodigal son of Chief Medical Officer Dr. Beverly Crusher, was introduced in TNG's series premiere "Encounter at Farpoint." However, fans grew weary of Wesley's portrayal as a teenager who often believed he knew better than the adults. Despite regularly appearing in the show's first four seasons, Wesley eventually left the USS Enterprise-D for Starfleet Academy in season 4. Although he made guest appearances in later seasons and in Star Trek: Nemesis, Wil Wheaton initially distanced himself from Starfleet matters due to the backlash from viewers. However, as Wheaton grew older and fans got to know him better, their relationship experienced a complete turnaround. He is now considered a respected member of the Star Trek community and has become more open about his decision to leave the Enterprise and the emotional aftermath it caused. Here is the real explanation behind the Wesley Crusher Star Trek issue.
The Real Reason Wil Wheaton Quit Star Trek
When Wil Wheaton departed from Star Trek: The Next Generation in 1990, he was just 18 years old. In his recently updated memoir, Still Just a Geek, he reflects on his younger self at 16, determined to show the world that he had more to offer than just being a part of Star Trek. Wheaton has been open about the emotional mistreatment he endured from his parents. His mother found fulfillment through his fame, while his father disregarded his desire to pursue interests beyond acting. Regrettably, his parents mismanaged the money he earned, leaving Wheaton feeling that the only way to gain their attention and approval was to excel in his acting career. Thus, he made the decision to leave Star Trek, aspiring to become a movie star and prove his value, all with the hope of making his parents proud.
Prior to joining the Enterprise, Wheaton gained recognition for his role in Stand By Me. However, his commitment to Star Trek prevented him from accepting significant movie offers. In 1989, when he was cast in Valmont, he only needed to be written out of one episode of The Next Generation to accommodate the filming in France. Wheaton believed that this arrangement would have been acceptable under the leadership of Gene Roddenberry. However, the newly appointed leadership of The Next Generation claimed that the episode in question was essential to Wesley's character development and couldn't proceed without Wheaton's involvement, leading him to reluctantly decline the Valmont opportunity. To his disappointment, Wheaton later discovered that he had been written out of the episode he had actually requested time off for, viewing it as a form of "message" from the show's creators.
Wil Wheaton's Picard Season 2 Cameo (But Not Season 3)
In retrospect, it is evident that the writers of Star Trek: TNG struggled to find a suitable role for Wesley Crusher. Being one of the few youthful individuals residing among a crew comprising seasoned Starfleet officers, he possessed the potential to serve as a relatable character for the younger audience. Regrettably, just as the team responsible for TNG failed to fully develop Wesley Crusher's character, those who should have offered unwavering support to Wil Wheaton also fell short.
Star Trek: Picard season 2's finale saw a surprising return of Wil Wheaton as he made a cameo appearance. He portrayed Wesley Crusher, now a Traveler who can navigate through time and space. In the year 2024, Wesley appeared in Los Angeles to enlist Kore Soong (Isa Briones) as a new member of the Travelers. This development hinted at a potential comeback for Wesley Crusher in the Star Trek universe. Consequently, when it was announced that the actors from Star Trek: The Next Generation would be featured in Star Trek: Picard season 3, it was only natural to anticipate Wesley Crusher's reunion with his former USS Enterprise-D crewmates.
However, with the reunion of the Star Trek: The Next Generation cast and the introduction of new characters such as Jack Crusher (Ed Speleers), who is the son of Admiral Jean-Luc Picard and Dr. Beverly Crusher, the addition of Wesley as a Traveler to the mix may have been overwhelming. Although the exact reason for Wheaton not being asked to return by the creators behind Picard has not been revealed, he himself hinted at a possible explanation on his social media pages. He noted that the Travelers are typically not meant to visit individuals from their past. While this may be Wheaton's personal interpretation, it is logical to assume that Wesley would understand and respect this rule.
What Wil Wheaton Has Done Since Star Trek
Wheaton continues to be a prominent figure in Hollywood and the Star Trek universe, making guest appearances on multiple shows and hosting his own Star Trek aftershow. He briefly returned as Wesley in the movie Star Trek: Nemesis after making a few appearances in later seasons of The Next Generation. Although he didn't appear in Star Trek: Picard season 3, he did have conversations with the cast and crew on his Star Trek aftershow, The Ready Room. The show covers all currently-running Star Trek series and features interviews with creators and cast members. Additionally, Wheaton has lent his voice to numerous animated shows, video games, and audiobooks. He has also played minor characters on popular television shows and had a recurring role as a fictional version of himself on The Big Bang Theory.
In "Still a Geek," he admits that his passion for writing surpasses his passion for acting. As a result, he engages in both pursuits. In addition to his memoir with annotations, he contributed a short story to the Star Wars anthology From a Certain Point of View and maintains an active presence on his personal blog and social media accounts. While he may not have achieved the level of stardom he once desired, he remains connected to the franchise he deeply cherishes. Wil Wheaton will forever be a cherished member of the Star Trek: The Next Generation community.