The Mind-Blowing Twist You Missed in American Horror Story Season 2 Finale

Since its premiere in 2011, season 1 of American Horror Story, commonly known as Murder House, captivated fans with its thrilling storyline. This marked the beginning of an ongoing series that consistently delivers entertainment to genre enthusiasts. Each season introduces a unique setting, ranging from haunted houses to circuses and even New York City. However, it is the second season, American Horror Story: Asylum, that truly stands out for its chilling ambiance, centered around the haunting Briarcliff Manor, a former mental institution.

Ryan Murphy, the mastermind behind the series, frequently chooses the same talented actors to portray characters across multiple seasons, such as Evan Peters, Sarah Paulson, and Jessica Lange. Once again, these remarkable performers grace the screen in Asylum, bringing to life unforgettable characters who drive the compelling narrative forward. Now, let's delve into the events that unfold during season 2 of American Horror Story and discover how this riveting chapter reaches its conclusion.

What Is American Horror Story Season 2 About?

Many fans consider American Horror Story season 2 to be the most frightening season of AHS, mainly due to the terrifying setting of Briarcliff Manor. The season effectively utilizes a narrative technique of switching between the past and the present to provide a deeper understanding of this disturbing location and the development of its main characters.

The pivotal episode that sets up the main storyline in American Horror Story season 2 is titled "Welcome to Briarcliff." Taking place in 1964, it introduces Kit Walker (played by Evan Peters), who is mistakenly believed to be the notorious serial killer known as "Bloody Face" and is one of the iconic villains in American Horror Story. Upon entering Briarcliff, Kit forms a connection with Grace Bertrand (portrayed by Lizzie Brocheré), who has been accused of murdering her relatives. Both characters share the commonality of being regarded as killers while adamantly professing their innocence. Additionally, Evan's character encounters an unforgettable figure from American Horror Story season 2 – a nymphomaniac named Shelley, played by Chloe Sevigny.

In the past timeline, Lana Winters, a reporter, seeks to write a story about the horrors inside the institution. However, Sister Jude Martin, upon discovering Lana's homosexuality, forcibly admits her as a patient. Additionally, the first episode introduces the terrifying experience of Teresa and Leo, a married couple in 2012, who decide to explore Briarcliff. Their ill-fated visit takes a gruesome turn when Leo's arms are severed, and Teresa encounters Bloody Face and his skin mask.

The central enigma of American Horror Story season 2 revolves around the identity of Bloody Face. Throughout the episodes, fragments of information are revealed, adding to the enthralling and mysterious nature of the season. Many fans deem it the best season of American Horror Story for this reason. As the season progresses, Teresa and Leo are relentlessly pursued by Bloody Face, uncovering the existence of multiple culprits. In the ninth episode, "The Coat Hanger," Johnny Morgan is unveiled as the second Bloody Face antagonist. Johnny's parents are revealed to be Lana Winters and Dr. Oliver Thredson, the original Bloody Face.

How Does American Horror Story Season 2 End?

The season 2 finale of American Horror Story is arguably the darkest of all the seasons. In "Madness Ends," Lana Winters' current timeline is explored, revealing her success as a renowned TV journalist. During an interview, Lana discloses her motive to expose the sinister nature of Briarcliff to the world. However, her son, Johnny, unexpectedly appears and attempts to murder her. In a shocking turn of events, Lana manages to overpower and kill Johnny instead. This unsettling scene is a direct result of Lana's traumatic past assault.

In addition to the disturbing storyline, the season 2 finale features a strong ensemble cast of recurring American Horror Story actors. Notably, Sarah Paulson consistently delivers outstanding performances in all the seasons she appears in.

This gripping conclusion of season 2 only emphasizes why American Horror Story stands out as one of the most captivating thriller TV shows of the 2010s. The intricately woven plot reveals that Kit and Jude have formed a deep connection, with Jude loving and caring for Kit's children as they become integral parts of each other's lives. However, tragedy strikes as Jude succumbs to a brain tumor. Adding to the suspense, Kit is abducted by aliens after discovering that he has pancreatic cancer. Surprisingly, the aliens in American Horror Story season 2 are not portrayed as villains; rather, it is revealed that Kit's two children are hybrid beings, a mix of both alien and human DNA.

In the final scene of American Horror Story season 2, Sister Jude engages in a conversation with Lana. Jude advises Lana to not fixate on Bloody Face, stating, "Staring into the face of evil will only invite evil to stare back at you." This particular scene demonstrates Lana Winters' incredible strength and unwavering authenticity, solidifying her position as one of the most remarkable characters in American Horror Story. As the conclusion of season 2 unfolds, Briarcliff ultimately shuts its doors for good, effectively tying up all loose ends.