The Mind-Blowing Truth Behind Allison's Controversial Journey in Umbrella Academy

In The Umbrella Academy season 3, a disturbing theory attempts to explain Allison's controversial transformation into a villain. The season brought about numerous challenges for the Hargreeves siblings as they found themselves in a timeline where their superhero team never existed. These alterations in the timeline not only led to another apocalypse but also created various issues within the Hargreeves family, particularly impacting Allison. While her siblings embarked on their individual journeys, Allison's path took a dark turn, ultimately leading her to become one of the villains of season 3.

Throughout the season, the Hargreeves siblings made significant revelations, with the most noteworthy being that their own father, Reginald Hargreeves, had been the true enemy all along. Reginald exploited Allison, who was already emotionally vulnerable due to the timeline changes, by striking a deal that primarily served his own interests. At this point, Allison had already transformed into one of the season's villains, marking one of the most controversial moments. Although the show provided an explanation for her transformation, a theory suggests that Allison's own powers may have been the cause.

Theory: Allison Rumoring Herself Triggered Her Villain Transformation

In season 3 of The Umbrella Academy, each member of the team faced their own personal challenges. However, it was Allison who ultimately betrayed her siblings by turning against them. One could argue that she suffered the greatest loss in the altered timeline when she discovered that her daughter, Claire, was not biologically hers. This revelation drove Allison to desperate measures in her quest to return to their original timeline. With Luther no longer by her side and no clear path back, Allison resorted to using her powers and rumoring herself into a state of happiness. Interestingly, this action may have had unintended consequences, as it is theorized that it actually fractured her mind.

A Reddit user put forth an intriguing theory about what truly caused Allison's transformation into a villain in The Umbrella Academy season 3. According to this theory, the act of self-rumoring created a dissonance between her true personality and her rumor powers, with the latter ultimately taking control. This idea gains support from the fact that Allison was visibly unhappy after rumoring herself, even resorting to angrily punching a mirror. From that point onward, Allison underwent a profound change, fueled by anger and resentment. She went so far as to kill Harlan and even rumor Luther into desiring her, resulting in one of the most unsettling scenes in The Umbrella Academy.

The theory suggests that if Allison's ability to spread rumors is the cause of her transformation into a villain, she will experience an "interpersonal conflict" in season 4 of The Umbrella Academy. The author even draws a comparison between her situation and how the Ring in Lord of the Rings desires to be desired and used.

Does Umbrella Academy's Allison Theory Actually Work?

Despite three seasons of The Umbrella Academy, there are still many unanswered questions about the Hargreeves' powers. The Netflix series has deviated from the original comic books, leaving gaps in our understanding of the characters and their abilities. One particular aspect that remains unclear is the potential effects of rumoring oneself. Season 3 revealed that Allison cannot use her power to influence herself, as seen in her failed attempt to make herself happy. Consequently, her subsequent attitude and actions were solely driven by her pent-up frustration and anger, rather than a malfunction in her personality or powers.

Now, assuming that she can also utilize her powers on herself (considering that the vocal rings were observed entering her ears and her eyes became white), it remains uncertain to what extent these powers can impact her. Allison possesses the ability to manipulate people's minds and alter reality, but it is important to note that she was experiencing intense pain and harboring feelings of anger when she applied her power of rumors to herself. It is possible that such emotional turmoil could potentially result in unintended consequences for her powers.

Umbrella Academy’s Allison Theory Shows Why Her Story Was So Controversial

Allison's dark storyline in season 3 of The Umbrella Academy was marked by unexpected twists and turns. However, it was her villainous transformation that sparked controversy among viewers. This sudden shift in her character seemed out of place, especially considering her previous role as a key member in keeping the team united. The moments where she killed Harlan, sexually assaulted Luther out of jealousy, and betrayed her siblings by striking a deal with Reginald for her own gain were particularly polarizing. The need for a theory, such as the one mentioned above, to further explain her character development only highlights the strangeness and shortcomings of her arc in season 3.

Allison is poised to take on the role of an antagonist in season 4 of The Umbrella Academy, particularly because she is the only one who achieved her desired outcome in the present timeline. It remains uncertain whether her own self-doubt played a part in her transformation into a villain. However, given that The Umbrella Academy is concluding with season 4, it is anticipated that she will ultimately find redemption, having caused significant pain and chaos.