The Mind-Blowing Influence of Elden Ring on P 2: Debunking the Lies

If a sequel to Lies of P, known as Lies of P 2, were to be developed, it would be beneficial for the game to draw inspiration from FromSoftware's expansive open world masterpiece, Elden Ring, rather than following the style of the first game which was influenced by Bloodborne. Since its release, Lies of P has received predominantly positive reviews and has been praised as one of the top Soulslike games. While the initial game took inspiration from Bloodborne and to a lesser extent Sekiro, a potential sequel could greatly benefit from embracing the immersive open world characteristic of Elden Ring.

DISCLAIMER: This article contains significant spoilers for Lies of P.

Those who have successfully defeated the toughest bosses in Lies of P and reached the game's after-credits scene are privy to the game's setup for a potential sequel. Following one of Lies of P's three endings, players are treated to an additional scene that unveils the hidden observation of Pinocchio throughout the game by the Gold Coin Tree merchant on behalf of his mysterious boss. It is then revealed that, with Pinocchio's journey concluded, the focus will shift to Dorothy, the beloved protagonist of The Wizard of Oz literature. In an iconic moment, players witness Dorothy clicking her ruby slippers together, akin to the enchanted act portrayed in both the book and the acclaimed 1939 film adaptation.

This clear indication strongly suggests that Lies of P 2 will trade Pinocchio's tale for The Wizard of Oz, featuring Dorothy as the new central character. Should a sequel come into fruition, this shift in setting from Krat to Oz would have significant implications for the game. Departing from the puppet theme, Lies of P 2 would likely thrive in an open world environment, drawing inspiration from Elden Ring rather than Bloodborne. With the potential narrative possibilities afforded by the enchanting world of Oz, such a transition would undoubtedly enhance the overall experience of Lies of P 2.

Lies of P 2 Having an Open World Would Be a Game-Changer

One of the main criticisms leveled at Lies of P is its notorious difficulty, even challenging veteran Soulslike players. Numerous fans have expressed frustration with the game's difficulty, prompting developers to release patches that make certain boss battles more manageable. However, if Lies of P 2 were to adopt an open world format, the need to nerf bosses may become less necessary. As demonstrated by Elden Ring, an open world Soulslike game appeals to a wider range of players, particularly those who prefer not to become repeatedly stuck on challenging bosses. The allure lies in the freedom to explore diverse locations, discover new sights, and ultimately enhance the overall gaming experience.

The potential setting of Oz in Lies of P 2 opens up a world of possibilities for an expansive open world experience. Envision venturing through the vast expanse of an open world Oz, venturing through renowned landmarks such as the Yellow Brick Road, the castle of the Wicked Witch, and the Emerald City. While these locations would undoubtedly thrive in a linear game, an open world environment would empower the developers to fully capitalize on the setting's potential.

Please note that the announcement of Lies of P 2 has not been made yet, so fans should not get too excited about its possibilities. The greenlight for Lies of P 2 will depend on the success of the first game, and it remains uncertain how successful Lies of P will be. However, Lies of P has received positive reviews from critics and its availability through Xbox Game Pass ensures that many players will give it a try, even those who usually avoid Soulslike games.

Lies of P can currently be played on PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, and Xbox Series X.