The Lost Superman Movie: Robert Downey Jr Almost Played Lex Luthor

The Almost Reality of Robert Downey Jr. as Lex Luthor

Robert Downey Jr. almost played Lex Luthor in a high-profile canceled DC movie from the early 2000s. This could have brought a whole new dimension to the DC universe, with the MCU's Iron Man stepping into the shoes of Lex Luthor. Imagine the charisma and flair of Downey Jr. infusing Luthor's cold, calculating demeanor, transforming the arch-nemesis of Superman into a dangerously genius and unexpectedly human figure.

Robert Downey Jr and Lex Luthor custom News image

With the Superman franchise being rebooted with the upcoming Superman Legacy, the absence of Downey Jr. as Luthor remains one of DC's biggest missed opportunities. The balance of its two most prominent characters is crucial to the success of Superman movies, and the thought of seeing this reality play out is enticing, to say the least.

Lex Luthor and Robert Downey Jr as MCU's Iron Man

The Missed Opportunity and Casting Decisions

Robert Downey Jr. was cast as Lex Luthor five years before he first played Tony Stark in Iron Man. However, the project, known as Superman: Flyby, was eventually canceled, leaving Downey Jr.'s role in it a little-known fact. The provocative version of Lex Luthor played by Downey Jr. could have brought a fresh and relatable perspective to the iconic supervillain.

Robert Downey Jr Lex Luthor

The movie, originally helmed by Director McG and later taken over by Brett Ratner, faced significant casting challenges, including the lead role of Superman. The ambitious production, with a soaring budget exceeding $200 million, also aimed to tap high-profile actors like Christopher Walken and Anthony Hopkins in critical roles. However, budget constraints, logistical issues, and the fear of flying led to the project's eventual cancellation.

Lex Luthor DC Comics Armor

The Potential of Robert Downey Jr. as Lex Luthor

Robert Downey Jr.'s ability to breathe life into his roles and his performance style could have grounded the character of Lex Luthor, making him feel more human and relatable. Downey Jr. would have brought a range of acting skills, past experience in similar roles, and the personality to carry the role to new heights. His portrayal could have added layers of complication to the storyline, amplifying the drama and suspense tenfold.

Robert Downey Jr. as Tony Stark in a Suit in Iron Man 3

The cancelation of DC's Superman: Flyby project serves as a reminder of the fragile nature of film production, where creative visions, personal challenges, and logistical constraints can collide, leading to the unrealized potential of what might have been an extraordinary cinematic experience. Despite the missed opportunity, it gives audiences something to hope for in future versions of the Superman and Lex Luthor mythos across the DCEU.

Superman screaming in sorrow in Man Of Steel (2013)